User talk:Logical Premise/Archive2

Monday

11

November

11:20 UTC

Toolz	Welcome to my talk page
	Please sign your posts with four tildes (~~~~) and add comments on a new topic in a new section. Threads older than two months are typically archived. I welcome badgering on RfA and AfD votes. If you can convince me to reverse my AfD vote, you win a barnstar. Questions, requests, criticism, and any other comments are always welcome!

Toolz	Archival Section
	Archive One (September - October 2008) Archive Two (October 2008 - August 2010) Archive Three (August 2010 - May 2011) Archive Four (May 2011 - April 2016) Hiatus Archive

Toolz

Warning!

Angry complaints of personal attacks will be completely ignored unless you provide a diff and a rational reason why it's a personal attack. I do not refactor comments. If you insist I refactor a comment, please consult an Arabic translator for "اذهب يمارس الجنس مع نفسك" for instructions on how to proceed. If you don't like what I say that is your problem. If you state your case without resorting to logical fallacies such as ad hominems and other marks of a weak mind, I will be more than happy to apologize for any legitimate concerns and/or strike or delete (NOT refactor) comments I've made that are offensive. I am not trying to be pointy, I'm trying to avoid situations where I will snatch someone's head right off their shoulders for levels of stupidity no human being should have to endure. If you are an editor of Conservapedia or a Bright and you wish to discuss anything involving religion, do not edit my talk page. You will be reverted. I do not engage in conversation with POV pushers, of any stripe. If you are new to Wikipedia, please ignore all of the above and ask whatever you like. I am happy to help newcomers.

Toolz	Directory

Toolz

Talk!

Re: RFA vote See my talk page. Crystal whacker (talk) 19:48, 24 October 2008 (UTC) Redundancy I was under the impression that a super-earth was a "an extrasolar terrestrial planet". Was the repeat of that in the Gliese 581 c article for people who didn't click the link? In a GA review, someone will almost certainly make a comment on that. You also reverted my minor copyediting, was this intentional or accidental? -- Logical Premise Ergo? 03:47, 29 October 2008 (UTC) You may have noticed that in the article the term "Super-Earth" is in quotes, and as was noted in the talk page of the article for Gliese 581 c most recently not everyone agrees with that assesment. But it is unfortunately that is how the media and scientist have refered to it. I argued at the Super-Earth article that it is a misnomer, in some cases, and in the end all reference to anything but mass was removed from that article for clarification. the idea of stating both is for those who appreciate that it is a "quote" and that it is qualified by referencing, and though thoroughly published not necessarily accurate. ie a Super-Venus is more likely. I think the reasoning on what you call redundant is clear enough to the GA review people considering the made no comment about it recently when the reviewed it twice this month. As to you other edits in the same edit, it was neither, just inconsiderate of me. I feel no responsibility for your mistake of making many small edits all together, which I recommend that you don't as others that disagree with one of your edits can revert the whole thing just as I did... I was not feeling charitable towards you but I appreciate your level headed contact of me directly now. I meant to go back and replace the other parts, that made sense, but ran out of time. GabrielVelasquez (talk) 16:50, 29 October 2008 (UTC) Notability in the Information Age I appreciate the tag on the notability issue on the WILDSOUND FILM FESTIVAL page, and like that it comes from someone who seems to care both about integrity and getting personally involved. My defense of the inclusion of WILDSOUND in Wikipedia is rooted in the same place. Wildsound has not been featured in books, or magazines, or in any form of printed catalogue or listing. It has been mentioned in passing in several newspaper articles, but nothing where the festival itself is more than a name used to cite someone else's credits. Wildsound is a festival and organization completely promoted and advertised on the Internet, whose website attracts upwards of 50,000 unique visitors per month and whose competitions are entered by hundreds of filmmakers and screenwriters during every monthly deadline period. Its live events are attended by nearly sold-out crowds at Toronto's National Film Board. It does not care that there has been no interest from the traditional media in its unique format and its international scope. Canadian media outlets avoid anything that isn't funded by the government and features artists that aren't exclusively home-grown. In order to attract a world-wide audience, Wildsound has totally eschewed the traditional kinds of marketing used in this country, focusing exclusively on the Web to build an audience and to network with artists. That's the reason none of the sources cited on the Wikipedia page refer to print media. There are none. But for filmmakers and film fans, all the important sources prove the influence and notability of this unique festival. IMDB is the ultimate resource for film credits and credibility, and Withoutabox is an almost indispensable tool for filmmakers to submit their work to accredited festivals. Wildsound and its creator, Wildcard Pictures Corp, are recognized by both. I would hate the fact that Wildsound has deviated from traditional marketing and promotion techniques to exclude it from Wikipedia, which, admittedly, spent its own early years in the same position. Let me know if you feel able to remove the citation from the page, or if you have some suggestion of some other proof of notability that would allow you to feel comfortable doing so. Otherwise, I'll leave it as a challenge to Wildsound. A4democracy (talk) 21:09, 4 November 2008 (UTC) RfA thanks Thank you for participating in my RfA, which recently passed with 126 in support, 22 in opposition and 6 neutral votes. Thanks for your support in my RFA!! • If you want to reply to this message please use my talk page as watch listing about 150 pages is a bit messy • ·Add§hore· Talk/Cont 19:40, 5 November 2008 (UTC) AfC news Dear AfC participant, Msgj and Tnxman307 are organising the AfC challenge! It's a little competition to help improve some of the articles created through AfC and we are hoping that everyone will get involved. For level 1, you just need to bring a stub up to Start-class. Level 2 is improving a Start-class article to C-class. And so on. To get involved or for more information please see the competition page. Those of you who haven't reviewed an article recently might not have noticed the new process that was implemented this year. Reviewing articles is now more enjoyable than ever :) You might like to give it a try. All articles waiting for review are in Category:Pending Afc requests. (Please read the updated instructions.) Please consider adding {{AFC status}} to your userpage to keep track of the number of articles waiting for review. At the time of writing we are officially backlogged, so help is needed! There is currently a proposal to bring the Images for upload process under the umbrella of WikiProject Articles for creation. The rationale is that both processes are designed to allow unregistered users to take part more fully in Wikipedia, and partipants in each process can probably help each other. If you no longer wish to receive messages from WikiProject Articles for creation, please remove your name from this list. Thank you. IRC Making an edit -- Logical Premise Ergo? 04:01, 20 December 2008 (UTC) RFC on me, not poetry I find this RFC on me discouraging overall but it isn't stopping from learning which is why I use wikipedia. I started editing in the encyclopedia because I found errors in what I was looking at and that didn't help what I was trying to learn. You took an exception to my saying some scientists are ignorant and that is why you didn't bother to help with the Planetary Human Habitability article, but then you went on to edit at the Gliese 581 c talk page and I would note that no one is improving the Super-Earth article to clarify what is meant there and what is not. I hate the term as bias and narrow minded since it excludes the idea of a Super-Venus, or a Super-Mars, Super-Titan etc. so I won't be arguing with people there. As for my use of the term "ignorant" I don't appologize for that as all I have to do is look at the article for Habitability to know what astrophysicits are not getting, they are talking over the word without carifying when they are using it for extremeophile life and when they are using it for people, and I think creating that confusion is ignorant. You added a comment on the talkpage of the RFC on me and I am surprised that you are not in support of banning or deleting my account. I think that is gracious of you and more forgiving than me. I don't quite understand it but neither am I fishing for compliments. I wanted to add sarcastic remarks to the discussion on Gliese 581 c after Icalanise left things hanging on the Super-Earth not being made of "earth" discusion. There is a clear example of his thinking he must be right and then running off when he can't continue the discussion. He has to have the last word, and I pity him for that. But all this to say thanks for the comment at the RFC talkpage. and you are right, I will leave, (in that case) I don't need to edit to learn what I want to to make a better Stargen. GabrielVelasquez (talk) 03:56, 24 December 2008 (UTC) Great it looks like GabrielVelasquez is persisting in attacks on me. Nice. If not ARBCOM, what? Icalanise (talk) Note I have opened an WP:RFARB because of his comment here and on other talk pages, as a participant in the RfC you might be interested in it. 17:18, 29 December 2008 (UTC) Merry Christmas from Promethean O'Hai there Logical Premise, Merry Christmas! Logical Premise, I wish you and your family all the best this Christmas and that you also have a Happy and safe new year. Thankyou for all your contributions to Wikipedia this year and I look forward to seeing many more from you in the future. Your work around Wikipedia has not gone un-noticed, this notice is testimony to that Please feel free to drop by my talkpage any time to say Hi, as I will probably say Hi back :) All the Best.   «l| Ψrometheăn ™|l»  (talk) RFC on " Astobiological Potential " Is what is happening here what I think is happening here? 198.163.53.11 (talk) 20:13, 7 January 2009 (UTC) IP spam from a City of Winnipeg network. Make what you will of that. . dave souza, talk 22:57, 7 January 2009 (UTC) Alphabetization and collation I am inviting you to comment, in your capacity as an informatician, at Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style#Alphabetization and collation. -- Wavelength (talk) 03:20, 28 January 2009 (UTC) Antonio Romano Twinkle didn't finish the AFD process. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Many otters • One bat • One hammer) 23:20, 27 May 2009 (UTC) WP:Missing Wikipedians Hey there. Nice userpage. Unfortunely it seems you haven't edited for a while, and this is to inform you that I've added this username to the list of missing Wikipedians. If you don't want to be listed just go ahead and remove your name. However, would I be correct to infer from your Wikiwangst poem that you're still editing under an alternate account? If so, why not just redirect to your new account's userpage? -- œ™ 07:41, 1 November 2009 (UTC) Nobel Prize Hey! I saw you as a member on the Guild of Copy-Editors and am wondering if you could help me out with an article I am working on, the Nobel Prize. A quite important article since, many link to it etc. I think the content is starting to get good but it really needs some copy-editing and sourcing love. Do you have any chance to help out? --Esuzu 21:58, 15 January 2010 (UTC) —Preceding unsigned comment added by Esuzu (talk • contribs) WikiProject Economics census Hello there. Sorry to bother you, but you are (titularly at least) a member of WP:WikiProject Economics, as defined by this category. If you don't know me, I'm a Wikipedia administrator, but an unqualified economist. I enjoy writing about economics, but I'm not very good at it, which is why I would like to support in any way I can the strong body of economists here on Wikipedia. I'm only bothering you because you are probably one of them. Together, I'd like us to establish the future direction of WikiProject Economics, but first, we need to know who we've got to help. Whatever your area of expertise or level of qualification, if you're interested in helping with the WikiProject (even if only as part of a larger commitment to this wonderful online encyclopedia of ours), would you mind adding your signature to this page? It only takes a second. Thank you. Message delivered on behalf of User:Jarry1250 by LivingBot. Copyedit Backlog Elimination Drive Hi, as a member of the Guild of Copy Editors you're hereby notified of and invited to participate in the WikiProject Guild of Copy Editors/Backlog elimination drives/May 2010. Please help us eliminate the 8,000+ copyedit backlog! Participating editors will receive barnstars and other awards, according to their level of participation. ɳorɑfʈ Talk! 00:16, 22 April 2010 (UTC) Grab some glory, and a barnstar Hi, I'd like to invite you to participate in the Guild of Copy Editors July 2010 Backlog Elimination Drive. In May, about 30 editors helped remove the {{copyedit}} tag from 1175 articles. The backlog is still over 7500 articles, and extends back to the beginning of 2008! We really need your help to reduce it. Copyediting just a couple articles can qualify you for a barnstar. Serious copyeditors can win prestigious and exclusive rewards. See the event page for more information. And thanks for your consideration. ɳorɑfʈ Talk! 14:56, 10 June 2010 (UTC) GOCE Backlog Elimination Drive Wrap-up Greetings from the Guild of Copy Editors July 2010 Backlog Elimination Drive. Thanks to all who participated in the drive! Over 100 editors—including Jimbo Wales—signed up this time (nearly triple the participants of the May drive). This benefited the Guild as well as the articles in need of copy editing. You can see from the comparison graphs that we increased the number of completed copyedits substantially. Unfortunately, we were not able to meet our goal of completely wiping out 2008 from the queue. We also were not able to reduce the backlog to less than 6,000 articles. We suspect people were busy with real life summertime things, at least in the northern hemisphere! We were able to remove the months of January, February, March, April, and May from the backlog, and we almost wiped out the month of June. We reduced the backlog by 1,289 articles (17%), so all in all it was a very successful drive, and we will be holding another event soon. We'll come up with some new ideas to try to keep things fresh and interesting. Keep up the good work, everybody! Stats If you copy edited at least 4,000 words, you qualify for a barnstar. If you edited in the May 2010 GOCE Backlog Elimination Drive, your word totals are cumulative for barnstars (not the leaderboard). Over the course of the next week or two, we will be handing out the barnstars. GOCE backlog elimination drive chart up to 31 July Eight people will receive The Most Excellent Order of the Caretaker's Barnstar (100,000+ words): Chaosdruid, Diannaa, Ericleb01, Lfstevens, Shimeru, S Masters, The Utahraptor, and Torchiest. Bullock and Slon02 will receive The Order of the Superior Scribe (80,000+). The Barnstar of Diligence (60,000+) goes to Derild4921, GaryColemanFan, kojozone, and Mlpearc. The Modern Guild of Copy Editors Barnstar (40,000+) goes to A. Parrot, AirplanePro, Auntieruth55, Bejinhan, David Rush, and mono. Nobody will receive The Old School League of Copy Editors award (30,000+). The Tireless Contributor Barnstar (20,000+) goes to Backtable, Cindamuse, dtgriffith, Duff, e. ripley, Laurinavicius, NerdyScienceDude, and TEK. The Cleanup Barnstar (12,000+) goes to Brickie, Casliber, cymru lass, December21st2012Freak, Nolelover, TheTito, Whoosit, and YellowMonkey. The Working Man's Barnstar (8,000+) goes to Bsherr, Duchess of Bathwick, HELLKNOWZ, Mabeenot, noraft, Pyfan, and Richard asr. The Modest Barnstar (4,000+) goes to Adrian J. Hunter, Airplaneman, Annalise, Camerafiend, Cricket02, Fetchcomms, Gosox5555, LeonidasSpartan, Paulmnguyen, Piotrus, SuperHamster, Taelus, and TPW. Gold Star Award Gold Star Award Leaderboard Articles Words 5k+ Articles 1. Diannaa (248) Shimeru (200,392) Shimeru/Ericleb01 (13) 2. Slon02 (157) Diannaa (164,960) Chaosdruid (8) 3. GaryColemanFan (101) Chaosdruid (130,630) Derild4921 (7) 4. Torchiest (100) The Utahraptor (117,347) GaryColemanFan/Slon02 (6) 5. Shimeru (80) Ericleb01 (114,893) Bejinhan/The Utahraptor (5) Coordinator: ɳorɑfʈ Talk! Co-coordinators: Diannaa TALK and S Masters (talk) | Newsletter by: The Raptor You rang?/My mistakes; I mean, er, contributions Delivered by MessageDeliveryBot on behalf of The Utahraptor at 22:16, 3 August 2010 (UTC). GOCE Invitation There are currently 2,503 articles in the backlog. You can help us! Join the September 2010 drive today! The Guild of Copy-Editors – September 2010 Backlog Elimination Drive The Wikipedia Guild of Copy-Editors invite you to participate in the September 2010 Backlog Elimination Drive, a month-long effort to reduce the backlog of articles that require copy-editing. The drive will begin on 1 September at 00:00 (UTC) and will end on 30 September at 23:59 (UTC). The goals for this drive are to eliminate 2008 from the queue and to reduce the backlog to fewer than 5,000 articles. Sign-up has already begun at the September drive page, and will be open throughout the drive. If you have any questions or concerns, please leave a message on the drive's talk page. Before you begin copy-editing, please carefully read the instructions on the main drive page. Please make sure that you know how to copy-edit, and be familiar with the Wikipedia Manual of Style. Awards and barnstars A range of barnstars will be awarded to active participants. Some are exclusive to GoCE drives. More information on awards can be found on the main drive page. Thank you; we look forward to meeting you on the drive! — ɳorɑfʈ Talk! and S Masters (talk).