User talk:Emordnilap

Maori child killings

It appears you have removed completely my page on Maori child killings, saying "rm redlink, not a particularly likely topic for an article." I disagree, considering there are articles on child murders, and New Zealand crime. This is a more specific summation of a subset of those killings.

I would like to know where the page has gone ?

I object to your actions.— Preceding unsigned comment added by Emordnilap (talk • contribs)

(copied from my talk page) I didn't delete your page. I removed a link to it after it was deleted. I note that three editors who viewed your page thought it was a bad idea for an encyclopedia article, and on viewing it now, I agree. One of those editors said "Lousy name for an encyclopedia entry. Destroy this craptacular page.", the second suggested deletion as "Incitement to racial hatred", and the third deleted it as "No context". The article was emotive - not a good thing for an encyclopedia article. It almost immediately veered off topic onto crime committed by Maori, and it was confused about whether it was a biography of the victims or a list of them. I cannot see there will ever be a place for such articles on Wikipedia.-gadfium 18:00, 21 October 2006 (UTC)