User talk:Carina J

Snape

The reason I took out the material you have now re-added (without explaining the re-addition) [1] to Severus Snape is two-fold: first, neither in the page you link to nor in the New York Post article there referenced was there anything about "support" for Snape. In fact, the interview is from before the appearance of Book 7, so she cannot have expressed such support (she expressed her belief that Snape was "good"); (in the future you should link to the original source, not to a page that has multiple links including that of the source you are quoting. In this case, [2]). And, second, the second part of the material you included is about Evanna expressing her opinion about the movie adaptation of the fifth book; it has nothing to do with Snape's loyalty. Magidin (talk) 20:31, 12 May 2008 (UTC)