User:TFA Protector Bot/Semi-protection trial

For Wikipedia:Bots/Requests for approval/TFA Protector Bot 3. The 30-day trial is being spread over 60 days to allow for a comparison of the impact of semi-protection vs no protection. Please feel free to contribute commentary or opinions on the quality or value of specific edits. The goal is to be able to understand what edits hypothetical the protection stopped from happening and at what quantity.

Semi-protected

• A.C. Monza (Sept 20)
  • 12 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: none
  • Good-faith reverted edits: overlinking (ECP), incorrect grammar change (admin)
  • Good edits: template change (ECP), copyedit (ECP), copyedit (ECP)
• A and B Loop (Sept 22)
  • 19 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: None
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Image placement change (ECP), Incorrect formatting change (ECP), Incorrect formatting change (autoconfirmed)
  • Good faith non-reverted edits: Image placement change (ECP) Image and map placement changes (ECP), Protection template addition (ECP), Short description change (ECP), Portal addition (ECP), Infobox formatting tweaks (ECP), Infobox formatting tweak (ECP), series of copyedits (autoconfirmed), addition of dubious template and spelling tweak (autoconfirmed)
• Sawmill Fire (2017) (Sept 24)
  • 26 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: None
  • Good-faith reverted edits: none
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Formatting fixes (ECP), Timezone changes (ECP), Capitalization (ECP), Citation bot edit, Content change (ECP), Copyedit (ECP), Image addition (ECP), Wording changes (ECP), Removal of extra precision from numbers (autoconfirmed), Category addition (autoconfirmed) , Comma edition (ECP), Infobox tweaks (ECP), Formatting tweaks (ECP), Short description change (ECP), Formatting tweak to references (ECP), Formatting tweaks (ECP), Rewording (ECP), Decapitalization (ECP)
• 1940 Mandatory Palestine v Lebanon football match (Sept 26)
  • 15 edits total, Final diff
  • Vandalism: None
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Citation bot edit, Incorrect link change (autoconfirmed), Link change (autoconfirmed)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Protection template addition (ECP), clarification (ECP), Series of minor changes (ECP), Category change (ECP)
• Truce of Calais (Sept 28)
  • 20 edits total, final diff
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Template change (ECP), Grammar change (autoconfirmed)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Citation bot edit, Template change (ECP), Link removal (ECP), Comma addition (ECP), Formatting changes (ECP), Grammar change (ECP), Reference formatting (admin)
• First Battle of Newtonia (Sept 30),
  • 23 edits total, final diff
  • Extended confirmed protected 1 hour after it was off TFA for 2 days, citing "Persistent vandalism from (auto)confirmed accounts".
  • Vandalism: 2 consecutive edits by the same LTA, 2 other vandalism edits
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Content addition (autoconfirmed), Link removal (ECP)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Date format change (ECP), Hatnote removal and minor changes (ECP), Minor reformatting (ECP), Formatting tweaks (ECP), Rewording and content addition (autoconfirmed), Formatting tweaks (ECP), Link addition (autoconfirmed)
• Hurricane Sergio (2018) (Oct 2)
  • 19 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: None
  • Good-faith reverted edits: None
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Breaking up paragraph (ECP), Link changes (ECP), Whitespace removal (Autoconfirmed), Change to American English (ECP), Spacing and convert tag addition (ECP), Link change (ECP), Typo fix (ECP - implemented per edit request from non-autoconfirmed user on talk page), Series of minor changes (ECP), Link change (ECP)
• Banded broadbill (Oct 4)
  • 16 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: None
  • Good-faith reverted edits: None
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Series of minor cleanups (ECP), Formatting (ECP), Date formatting (ECP), Series of minor changes (ECP), Spelling (ECP), Rewording (autoconfirmed), Rewording (ecp)
• Chicxulub crater (Oct 6)
  • 71 edits total, final diff
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 15:30 until the end of the TFA period
  • Vandalism: 7 oversighted edits, 18 other vandalism edits
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Reorganization (autoconfirmed),
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Rewording (ECP), Series of minor changes (ECP), Spelling fix (ECP), Series of minor changes continues (ECP), Link change (ECP), Redlink removal (autoconfirmed), Rewording (ECP), Citation bot edit, Grammar (ECP), Removing space (ECP), Wording change (ECP), Adding "non-avian" (ECP), Tense change (ECP), "fix excessive precision" (ECP), "typing error" (ECP), Script cleanup (ECP), changing hyphen to dash (ECP), wording simplification (ECP), change convert to abbreviate units (ECP), Prorection template addition (ECP), Comma removal (admin), combining refs (admin), copyedit and link fix (ECP)
• Alexander Hamilton U.S. Custom House (Oct 8)
  • 24 edits total, final diff
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 01:54 to after the end of the TFA period
  • Vandalism: 8 revdeled edits, 1 other vandalism edit
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Series of minor cleanups (ECP), Clarification (admin), Protection template addition (admin), change to active voice (ECP), content addition (ECP), capitalization/linking (ECP), capitalization (ECP)
• Fort Vancouver Centennial half dollar (Oct 10)
  • 8 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: None
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Protection template addition (ECP), Protection template moved (ECP), Script-assisted cleanup (ECP), Series of minor changes (ECP), formatting (ECP)
• Operation Sandwedge (Oct 12)
  • 62 edits total, final diff
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 00:56 to after the end of the TFA period
  • Vandalism: 17 vandalism edits
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Series of minor cleanups (ECP), Protection template addition (admin), Series of minor changes continued (ECP), image change (ECP), copyediting (ECP), Link changes (ECP), Short description change (ECP), Minor additions (ECP), Linking (ECP), Fixing name (ECP), wording fix (ECP)
• Borodino-class battlecruiser (Oct 16)
  • Vandalism: 2 vandalism edits
  • 23 edits total, final diff
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 00:12 to after the end of the TFA period
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Date/style fixes (ECP), condensing (ECP), reverting vandalism to short description (ECP), Series of formatting changes (ECP), bot substing template, hatnote formatting (ECP), unit formatting (ECP), category reordering (ECP), hatnote formatting (ECP), series of minor cleanups (ECP)
• Offham Hill (Oct 18)
  • 22 edits total, final diff
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 00:09 to after the end of the TFA period
  • Vandalism: 1 oversighted edit
  • Good-faith reverted edits: rewording (admin), Removing double spaces (ECP)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Protection template addition (admin), changing to British English (ECP), bot dating maintenance template, changing tense (ECP), script-assisted date formatting (ECP), Changing coordinates (ECP), copyedit (ECP), linking and wording (ECP), Spelling (ECP), Series of minor changes (ECP), reference formatting (ECP), Archiving references (ECP)
• Amador Valley High School (Oct 20)
  • 41 edits total, final diff
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 00:29 to after the end of the TFA period
  • Vandalism: 5 vandalism edits
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Protection template addition (admin), infobox/references (ECP), copyediting (ECP), layout cleanup (ECP), uses American English (ECP), grammar fix (ECP), grammar fix (admin), wording change and adding comment (ECP), copyedits (ECP), wording changes (ECP), formatting fix (ECP), hatnote change (ECP), copyedit (ECP), series of minor changes (ECP), reference fixes (ECP), minor rewording (ECP), reference addition (admin)
• Weardale campaign (Oct 22)
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 01:15 to after the end of the TFA period
  • 22 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 5 vandalism edits
  • Good-faith edits: Protection template addition (admin), EngvarB (ECP), content addition (ECP), image addition (ECP), formatting (ECP), spacing (ECP), content correction (ECP), text edits (ECP), capitalization/linking (ECP), grammar (ECP)
• Mischief Makers (Oct 26)
  • 17 edits total, final diff
  • Good-faith edits: short description change (autoconfirmed), copyedits (ECP), rewording first paragraph (ECP), copyedits (ECP), hatnote formatting (ECP), spacing (ECP), tense change (ECP), external link addition (ECP), quote change (ECP), protection template addition (ECP), delinking (ECP), hyphenation (ECP), rewording (ECP), copyedit (ECP)
• Head over Heels (American TV series) (Oct 28)
  • 19 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: None
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Reference addition (autoconfirmed), Reinstating that addition after it was reverted (autoconfirmed)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Protection template addition (ECP), Capitalization (ECP), Series of fixes (ECP), Formatting (ECP), Category addition (ECP), Link addition (autoconfirmed), Copyedit (ECP), Hatnote removal (ECP), Minor formatting (ECP), Minor formatting (autoconfirmed), Comma addition (ECP)
• Philip I Philadelphus (Oct 30)
  • 9 edits total, final diff
  • Good-faith edits: Protection template addition (ECP), Rearranging (ECP), Script-assisted date formatting (admin), Copyedit (ECP), Heading capitalziation (ECP), Capitalization and linking (ECP), copyedits to lead (ECP), formatting (ECP)

Left unprotected

• Alexander Cameron Rutherford (Sept 21)
  • Semi-protected for 3 hours from 1:05-4:05.
  • 99 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 15 LTA-type attacks, 24 general vandalism edits
  • Good-faith reverted edits:
  • Good edits: copyedit (autoconfirmed), reverting vandalism (IP address), whitespace (ECP), cropping image (admin), copyedit (ECP), template change (ECP), copyedit (ECP), copyedit/numbers (ECP), wording change (non-autoconfirmed), reverting vandalism (IP address), reworking of lead (autoconfirmed), infobox additions (ECP), MOS and overlinking fixes and again (autoconfirmed), infobox changes (ECP)
• Jason Sendwe (Sept 23)
  • 30 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 1 article overwrite, 2 general vandalism edits
  • Good faith reverted edits: Overlinking (autoconfirmed), Overlinking (non-autoconfirmed account), Bad formatting changes (autoconfirmed), Punctuation tweak that got lost in the crossfire of the above (ECP), Formatting tweak (autoconfirmed), Bold removal (ECP)
  • Good faith non-reverted edits: Series of copyedits (autoconfirmed), Infobox tweak (ECP), , Link removal (IP), Link addition and wording tweaks (ECP), Copyedit, (ECP), Infobox change (ECP), Vandalism revert (IP), Infobox tweak (ECP), Link addition (ECP), Category reordering (ECP)
• Red warbler (Sept 25)
  • 33 edits total, Final diff
  • Vandalism: 2 sets of 2 immediately self-reverted edits, 5 general vandalism edits
  • Good faith reverted edits: Overlinking (autoconfirmed), Overlinking and capitalization of headers (IP)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Formatting and citation tweaks (ECP), Date style template addition (ECP), Citation bot edit, Template rearranging (ECP), [1], Series of copyedits (ECP)
• Boroughitis (Sept 27)
  • Semi-protected for 3 hours from 18:59 to 21:59
  • 57 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 18 general vandalism edits
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Short description change (unconfirmed) , Section header capitalization (autoconfirmed), Protection template addition (admin)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Rewording (ECP), Addition of comma (autoconfirmed), Script-assisted formatting (ECP), Partial vandalism revert (IP), Rest of vandalism revert (admin), Formatting changes (ECP), Copyedit (IP), Removal of redundant word (admin), Comma addition (ECP), Rewording (autoconfirmed), Rewording (admin), Minor copyedit (ECP)
• Operation Hurricane (Oct 3)
  • Semi-protected for 3 hours from 02:15 to 05:17
  • Semi-protected again for 2 days from 16:26 to after the end of the TFA period
  • 95 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 1 set of 2 immediately self-reverted edits, 26 general vandalism edits.
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Link change (IP), Link addition (unconfirmed), Link addition (unconfirmed), Link addition (ECP), Link addition (ECP), Markup fix (autoconfirmed), Link addition (ECP)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Infobox reformatting (ECP), Protection template addition (admin), Link change (ECP), Formating and URL archive (ECP), Short description change (IP), Grammar change (autoconfirmed), Template change (ECP), Word removal (ECP), Cleanup (ECP), Short description change (ECP), Rewording (ECP), Rewording (ECP), Rewording (ECP), Link removal (ECP), Comma removal (IP), Vandalism revert (IP), Link removal (ECP), removal of overlinking and vandalism (ECP), Protection template addition (admin), Series of minor tweaks (ECP), Series of link changes (ECP), Link addition (ECP)
• Rachel Dyer (Oct 5)
  • Semi-protected for 1 day from 10:29 to after the TFA period
  • 50 edits total, final diff
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Link addition (ECP)
  • Vandalism: 1 set of 2 immediately self-reverted edits, 3 oversighted edits, 18 other vandalism edits (4 of which were during the semiprotection)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Comma fixes (IP), Grammar fix (ECP), Spelling fix (ECP), Link removal (ECP), Vandalism revert (unconfirmed), Grammar change (ECP), Rewording (ECP), Protection template addition (admin), Reference change (ECP), vandalism revert (autoconfirmed), formatting changes (ECP), Infobox change (ECP), Wording change (autoconfirmed)
• First homosexual movement (Oct 7)
  • Semi-protected from 00:30 to 01:06
  • Extended confirmed protected from 01:06 to after the end of the TFA period
  • 60 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 5 revdeled edits, 13 other vandalism edits. 11 of these were after the semi-protection
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Rewording lead to remove bold (ECP)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Overlinking removal (ECP), Series of copyedits (IP), Copyedit (IP), Copyedit (IP), Protection template addition (admin), Protection template addition (admin), script cleanup (ECP), Category sorting (ECP), typo fix (ECP), Typo fix (ECP), style fix (ECP), script cleanup (ECP), "fixed detail" (ECP), content change (ECP), reflist formatting (ECP), script and language cleanup (ECP)
• Daglish railway station (Oct 9)
  • 53 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 20 vandalism edits
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Overlinking (IP)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: "slight change to increase accuracy" (ECP), Series of minor changes (ECP), rewording for conciseness (IP), addition to infobox (IP), infobox formatting (autoconfirmed), infobox change (ECP), wording change (ECP), link addition (ECP), line break removal (ECP), Infobox fix (ECP)
• Delicate (Taylor Swift song) (Oct 11)
  • 46 edits total, Final diff
  • Vandalism: 14 vandalism edits
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Rewording (unconfirmed)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Series of minor cleanups (ECP), Archiving references (ECP), Minor tweak (ECP), Minor tweak (ECP), Typos/grammar (IP), Adding to credit list (unconfirmed), Fixing citation (IP), Adding space (IP), Typo and link fix (unconfirmed)
• Adiantum viridimontanum (Oct 13)
  • 56 edits total, final diff
  • Semi-protected from 00:40 to 01:39
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 01:39 to after the end of the TFA period
  • Vandalism: 28 revdeled edits, 2 other vandalism edits. 4 of them were after the semi-protection
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Protection template addition (admin)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Protection template addition (admin), Link change (admin - implemented through RFPP request), Removing "rare" (ECP), copyedit (ECP), removing explanation following link (ECP), copyedit (ECP), link addition (ECP), Series of minor changes (ECP), removing repeated explanation (ECP)
• Second Punic War (Oct 15)
  • 40 edits total, final diff
  • Semi-protected from 00:07 to 00:47
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 00:47 to after the end of the TFA period
  • Vandalism: 5 revdeled edits, 10 other vandalism edits. 4 of these were after the semi-protection
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: link removal (ECP), redlink removal (ECP), Protection template addition (admin), copyedit (ECP), formatting (ECP), comma edition (ECP), wikilink change (ECP), rewording (ECP), copyedit (ECP), moved protection template (ECP), Short description change (ECP), Series of minor changes (ECP)
• Megalograptus (Oct 17)
  • 30 edits total, final diff
  • Semi-protected from 00:03 to 00:55
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 00:55 to after the end of the TFA period
  • Vandalism: 7 vandalism edits. 5 were after the semi-protection
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Protection template addition (admin), script-assisted cleanup (ECP),
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Protection template addition (ECP), category addition (ECP), series of formatting and cleanup (ECP), Series of minor changes (ECP)
• Yusuf I of Granada (Oct 19)
  • 38 edits total, final diff
  • Semi-protected from 00:04 to 00:06
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 00:06 to after the end of the TFA period
  • Vandalism: 6 oversighted edits, 2 were after the semi-protection
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Protection template addition (admin), Breaking up long paragraphs (ECP),
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Protection template addition (admin), Link addition (ECP), Typo fix (ECP), Dash fix (ECP), Image change (ECP), Copyedit (admin), moving hatnote (ECP), Series of mostly formatting edits (ECP), Changing image size (ECP), Dates in succession box (ECP), Adding DOIs to citations (ECP), Removing space (ECP), script-assisted date formatting (admin), link fix (ECP), Series of minor cleanups (ECP), Adding "see next paragraph" (ECP)
• Streets (song) (Oct 21)
  • 31 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 6 revdeled edits before the semi-protection, 1 revdeled edit and 2 other vandalism edits after the semi-protection
  • Semi-protected from 00:01 to 00:09
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 00:09 to after the end of the TFA period
  • Good-faith edits: Protection template addition (admin), Protection template change (admin), change to American English (ECP), diction/syntax (ECP), series of minor changes (ECP), hatnote fix (ECP), series of minor changes (ECP - partly reverted after the TFA period)
• Ich will den Kreuzstab gerne tragen, BWV 56 (Oct 23)
  • 48 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 11 vandalism edits
  • Good-faith reverted edits: changing translation (IP), WP:NOPIPE (IP), list formatting (IP), grammar fix (unconfirmed - reverted by IP), spacing (ECP),
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: MOS:ORDER (ECP), series of copyedits (IP), reinstating previous spacing edit (ECP), vandalism revert (IP), reinstating previous reverted edits (IP), punctuation (unconfirmed), removing quotation marks (ECP), syntax (ECP), grammar (ECP)
• Second Battle of Cape Finisterre (Oct 25)
  • 72 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 12 vandalism edits
  • Semi-protected for 1 hour from 09:19 to 10:19
  • Good-faith reverted edits: protection template addition (admin), typo/grammar fixes (unconfirmed), adding period (unconfirmed), delinking (IP), self-reverted date change (IP)
  • Good-faith edits: grammar/punctuation (unconfirmed), capitalization (IP), spacing (IP), date clarification (IP), category changes and copyedits (IP), coordinates/formatting (ECP), copyedit/formatting (ECP), ">des Herbiers" (ECP), map addition (ECP), script cleanup (ECP), copyedits (ECP), series of minor cleanups (ECP), copyedit (autoconfirmed), concision (IP), wording change (IP), Hyphenated ISBNs (admin), rewording (IP), adding comma (ECP)
• Mini scule (Oct 27)
  • 65 edits total, final diff
  • Semi-protected from 21:37 to the end of the TFA period
  • Vandalism: 18 vandalism edits
  • Good-faith reverted edits: Adding wikilink (ECP), Clarifying caption (IP), Attempted fix of deliberate typo (IP), Same (IP), Overlinking (autoconfirmed), Same typo fix for a third time (IP), Link addition (ECP)
  • Good-faith non-reverted edits: Adding "The" (autoconfirmed), Adding hatnote (IP), MOS:ORDER (ECP), , Copyedit (ECP), Tidied (admin), Grammar and formatting (ECP), Formatting (ECP), Copyedit (ECP), Copyedit (IP), Category addition (ECP), Short description change (ECP), Link removal (ECP), Protection (admin)
• History of Burnley F.C. (Oct 29)
  • Extended-confirmed protected from 01:57 to after the end of the TFA period
  • 18 edits total, final diff
  • Vandalism: 8 vandalism edits
  • Good-faith edits: Overlinking removal (ECP), Link changes (ECP), Protection template addition (ECP)

No change

• Elizabeth II (Sept 19) - already indefinite extendedconfirmed
• Super Mario 64 (Sept 29) - already indefinite autoconfirmed
• Momčilo Đujić (Oct 1) - semi-protected manually by a human admin claiming Upcoming TFA Highly likely to be subjected to disruption for the duration of the TFA period
• Sayfo (Oct 14) - already indefinite autoconfirmed (this protection got lost after the TFA period when a LTA caused the page to be ECP-ed)
• Oryzomys antillarum (Oct 24) - already indefinite autoconfirmed