User:Spike 'em/sandbox/Top all-rounders by rating

This are lists of the all-time top-rated Test and ODI all-rounders, similar to the peak batting and bowling lists and the current all rounder list (transcluded below).

p.s. The rankings page has now been updated to include the top-10 of the Test list below.

This probably counts as WP:OR and may be incomplete.

Method

Test

The player's maximum rating is shown, along with their maximum batting and bowling rating, and a calculated tentative "theoretical maximum" rating. The all-rounder rating is calculated as batting * bowling⁄1000 at a given date, so the "theoretical max" shows what rating they would have if they reached their maximum batting and bowling ratings at the same time. The top 10 on the list all have a maximum rating of over 500 (good for a batting and bowling rating of about 707), the rest of the main list are between 400 and 500 (individual ratings of 630ish), and the "Others" are those above about 340.

To get the lists 2 searches were performed:

Pass 1: In 2016ish, ratings website was checked for the 47 Test players with at least 75 wickets and 1500 runs.
Pass 2: In Jan 2018 the year-end top-10 for each year since Tests started was checked. This relies on players being in the top-10 for at least one end of year. It is possible that there are players who had a fleeting high rating that were missed.

Players added by second pass include : Giffen, Mankad, Shakib, Jadeja, Moeen, Stokes and most of the additional list (it missed Philander and Starc though). The last 4 of these have achieved their highest rating since the list was started. Jason Holder has subsequently been added (and Cummins to bottom list).

ODI

At the end of 2019 similar end-of-year searches for ODIs was done to create a second list.

All-time top-rated Test all-rounders

Players in italics are still active in Tests (as of Oct 2021).

Top Test all-rounder ratings
Player	Rating	Rebased ^[a]	Date	link / id	Max Bat	Max Bowl	Pot. Max	Rebased ^[a]
Garfield Sobers	669	818	4/1/1967	943	938	715	671	819
Ian Botham	646	804	19/2/1980	1508	811	911	739	860
Jacques Kallis	616	785	30/12/2002	2125	935	742	694	833
Keith Miller	573	757	29/1/1952	725	681	862	587	766
Richie Benaud	532	729	17/11/1959	566	623	863	538	733
Imran Khan	518	720	18/1/1983	1803	650	922	599	774
Tony Greig	509	713	4/3/1975	244	750	702	527	726
Aubrey Faulkner	501	708	11/1/1911	1329	877	639	560	749
Andrew Flintoff	501	708	16/11/2005	2230	645	810	522	723
Chris Cairns	500	707	23/9/2000	1772	699	734	513	716

Ben Stokes	498	706	20/7/2020	7189	827	606	501	708
Ravichandran Ashwin	493	702	29/10/2016	7103	553	904	500	707
Shaun Pollock	490	700	12/9/2003	2120	565	909	514	717
Shakib Al Hasan	489	699	30/8/2017	6740	694	705	489	699
Jason Holder	485	696	12/7/2020	2878	581	862	501	708
Richard Hadlee	483	695	20/4/1987	1743	562	909	511	715
Alan Davidson	474	688	3/1/1961	601	526	908	478	691
Trevor Goddard	469	685	28/2/1967	1344	659	794	523	723
Monty Noble	451	672	9/3/1904	738	586	808	473	688
Brian McMillan	449	670	6/1/1997	2012	703	642	451	672
Ravindra Jadeja	438	662	7/8/2017	6985	584	899	525	725
Kapil Dev	433	658	6/1/1981	1850	598	877	524	724
George Giffen	418	647	20/7/1896	629	595	741	441	664
Vinoo Mankad	417	646	17/11/1952	1206	590	811	478	692
Trevor Bailey	417	646	24/6/1957	117	607	744	452	672
Daniel Vettori	412	642	15/12/2009	2172	672	681	458	676
Moeen Ali	409	640	7/8/2017	7370	655	633	415	644

Others : Jack Gregory 399 (403), Watson 394 (461), Billy Barnes 392 (397), Ted Dexter 391 (422), Mushtaq Mohammad 386 (452), Hammond 386 (400), Mitchell Johnson 384,Stuart Broad 382 (444),Vernon Philander 378 (417),Bobby Simpson 377,Reid 377, Armstrong 375, Lindwall 374, Trumble 366, Gomez 365, Nadkarni 360, Wasim Akram 355, Steve Waugh 350, Wolley 349, Mitchell Starc 347 (359), Verity 344, Marshall 341, Pat Cummins 339 (343)

^ ^a ^b Attempt to convert rating to similar scale to batting and bowling. If a player has both a batting and bowling rating of 700, for example, his all-rounder rating would be 490 rather 700. This is done by taking the geometric mean of his two other ratings.

Current List

ICC Top 10 Test All-Rounders v t e
Rank	Name	Rating
1	Ravindra Jadeja	432
2	Ravichandran Ashwin	296
3	Shakib Al Hasan	274
4	Jason Holder	270
5	Joe Root	262
6	Mehidy Hasan Miraz	261
7	Pat Cummins	245
8	Axar Patel	244
9	Chris Woakes	229
10	Ben Stokes	218
Reference: ICC Rankings, 5 November 2024

ODI

Players in italics are still active (as of Nov 2021). year-end top-10s

Top ODI all-rounder ratings
Player	Rating	Rebased^[a]	Date	link / id	Max Bat	Max Bowl	Pot. Max	Rebased^[a]
Kapil Dev	632	795	1985	1850	777	845	657	810
G Chappell	569	754	1982	1623	921	642	591	769
Flintoff	544	738	2004	2230	749	755	565	752
Richards	533	730	1985	1682	935	571	534	731
Klusner	522	722	1999	2163	824	657	541	736
Gayle	510	714	2003	2303	804	655	527	726
Kallis	506	711	2001	2125	817	641	524	724
S Waugh	502	709	1988	1644	784	680	533	730

S Pollock	494	703	2008	2120	589	917	540	735
Imran Khan	480	693	1983	1803	694	780	541	736
Shastri	480	693	1986	1849	671	738	495	704
Cronje	479	692	1999	1975	833	615	512	716
Hadlee	471	686	1986	1743	544	923	502	709
Botham	469	685	1983	1508	682	705	481	693
Lance Cairns	465	682	1983	1744	615	784	482	694
Carl Hooper	462	680	1999	1706	765	679	519	721
Jayasuriya	462	680	1997	1960	838	591	495	704
Shakib	453	673	2009	6740	692	717	496	704
Hafeez	438	662	2013	6476	665	769	511	715
Watson	433	658	2012	6395	773	621	480	693
Mathews	427	653	2014	6962	707	649	459	677
Dilshan	415	644	2015	2283	802	529	424	651
I Pathan	413	643	2006	9999	540	772	417	646
Astle	409	640	1997	2128	772	580	448	669
Coney	409	640	1985	1734	687	634	436	660
Tendulkar	407	638	1999	9999	887	492	436	661
O'Donnell	403	635	1991	9999	591	688	407	638
Malik	402	634	2005	9999	685	658	451	671
Sohail	401	633	1996	9999	766	558	427	654

Marshall, 399; Symonds, 398; Chris Cairns, 392; Razzaq, 387; Afridi 383, Jadeja, 378 (407); Wasim, 376; Rashid Khan, 359 (385); Vettori, 353; Styris, 350;.......

England others

Stokes 319 (694, 474)

Gooch 334 (1991)

Ali 306 (2018)

Woakes 313 (2018)

Daffy

Current List

ICC Top 10 ODI All-rounders v t e
Rank	Name	Rating
1	Mohammad Nabi	318
2	Sikandar Raza	288
3	Rashid Khan	254
4	Mehidy Hasan Miraz	252
5	Gerhard Erasmus	245
6	Brandon McMullen	240
7	Glenn Maxwell	233
8	Mitchell Santner	225
8	Azmatullah Omarzai	225
10	Zeeshan Maqsood	204
Reference: ICC Rankings, 19 November 2024

Useful link

Psuedo templatate
Cite error: There are <ref group=lower-alpha> tags or {{efn}} templates on this page, but the references will not show without a {{reflist|group=lower-alpha}} template or {{notelist}} template (see the help page).

[rb-1] Attempt to convert rating to similar scale to batting and bowling. If a player has both a batting and bowling rating of 700, for example, his all-rounder rating would be 490 rather 700. This is done by taking the geometric mean of his two other ratings.

[a]

[a]