User:Slrubenstein/MathSci unblocked

(1) the aggrieved party

(2) AN/I thread in which many people debate Mervyn's use of sources

• • Mervyn is criticized for inappropriate use of sources
  • MathSci names the book that Mervyn is using as a source, names the author, and the author's credentials

(3) Another editor accuses Mervyn of a conflict of interest, thus linking the description of the author of the book to Mervyn's description of himself

(4) MatchSci's 14:17 comment on Oct. 16 is Charles's evidence of outing

But you need to read the whole thread because context is everything.

(5) MathSci leaves messages for Mervyn - is his intention malicious or constructive?

• • first message
  • second message
  • third message

note: these three comments are important as Mervyn considers them evidence of outing.

(6) Charles Matthews blocks mathSci for one week; note evidence provided

(7) there is much discussion at MathSci's page about the block

(8) I unblock

(9) I inform Charles Matthews; intention - to be respectful

(10) I leave a message for Mervyn; intention - to be supportive

(11) The AN/I saga continues - discussion of Charles's block and my unblock and AN/I

(12) back to MathSci's talk page, FT2 criticizes my unblock

(13) I leave advice for mathScie; intention - to be strict and constructive. Paul August and Charles Matthews criticize my unblock

(14) a helpful comment by a third party

(15) Mervyn and Elonka leave messages for me

(16) My last conversation with Charles Matthews