User:SkyWriter/GlossaryArchive2
Glossary Tables
[edit]The following sets of tables list terms that can sometimes be understood differently by Christians and Jews. Since Wikipedia articles are written for a universal audience, and not just a single group, it is helpful for editors to be aware of possible misdirection of terms, and to seek, when possible unambiguous language. The following definitions are not to be understood as statements of ultimate truth, but examples of perceived meanings in each group, followed by unambiguous synonyms.
The glossary is in alphabetical order, and the groups are listed in alphabetical order.
A-D
[edit]Term | possible Christian perception | possible Jewish perception | Unambiguous Terms |
---|---|---|---|
The complete and voluntary abandonment of Christian faith whether by embracing another religion or embracing a secular philosophy incompatible with Christian faith.[1]
Theoretically impossible for a "saved" person according to the Calvinistic doctrine of the Perseverance of the Saints, but possible in an Arminian doctrinal system.[2] |
(1) rebellion against God and Torah and/or desertion of the faith of Israel; does not necessarily mean the adoption of a competing religion. The term acquired strongly negative connotations in the Middle Ages when a number of prominent baptized Jews publicly maligned Judaism and facilitated persecution of Jews.[3] (2) Jews converting to another religion and persons of Jewish parentage raised within another religion[4] Apostasy to Christianity or "Messianic Judaism" is considered idolatry.[5] See Jews in apostasy. |
1) Apostasy (when speaking only in terms of the religion being left).
2) Conversion (when also addressing a receiving religion). That is, in an article about only Christianity or Judaism, “Apostate” is unambiguous. But in an article addressing more than one religion, an “Apostate” from one religion could be a “Convert” to the other. | |
As a description, "antichrists" are anyone who denies that Jesus is the Messiah or Christ.[6] As a title, "The Antichrist" is associated with the "False Prophet," a king or leader who makes the world worship "The Beast" and take its mark of 666,[7] beheading others who refuse.[8] He is then defeated by Jesus at the Second Coming.[9] Among Christians there has been much speculation about his true identity.[10][11][12] | Unused term (see Failed Messiah). The closest equivalent to an antagonistic future world power can be found in speculative writings about a future persecutor described by Saadia Gaon as “Armilus.”[13] | Antichrist (when speaking in a Christian context). The term “Anti-Messiah,” however, could misdirect readers. | |
hilasterion selichah mechilah kapparah |
(1) the work of Christ; the benefits of Christ received by believers on account of his death and resurrection.[14] (2) the action by which God and the world are reconciled or made one. This is accomplished through Christ's satisfaction for all offense or injury to God. The specific method by which Christ accomplishes this has been a subject of long term debate among Christians.[15] |
Reconciliation or unification of two estranged parties. The concept has roots in the offering of sacrifices and the provision of ransom. However, the Biblical prophetic tradition and all later Jewish tradition has understood atonement as the process by which a person estranged from God is reconciled with God. Through this process a person experiences full regeneration and renewal of his or her original unbroken relationship with God.[16]
Jewish tradition recognizes a number of different actions and attitudes that have the power to effect this reconciliation and regeneration of spirit: teshuva (repentance), avodah (heartfelt prayer), tzedakah(charity), fasting, the experience of suffering, and the study of Torah. These actions can effect atonement because God is merciful in nature and desires reconciliation more than vengeance or punishment.[16][17][18] |
Atonement (but not to be used as a synonym for sacrifice). |
Avodah zarah | Unknown Term. (cf Idolatry) | Strange Worship / Idolatry. Forbidden for both Jews (as a violation of Torah) and Gentiles (as a violation of the seven Noahide Laws). There is a matter of dispute between Jewish authorities over whether Christianity is idolatry for non-Jews[19][20] however, Orthodox Jewish authorities hold that regardless of its permissibility for Gentiles, it is considered idolatry for Jews[21], even if they profess themselves to be Christian or "Messianic".[22][23][5] | Idolatry (the term Avodah Zara is not understood by most non-Jews). |
Unknown term. | New Covenant between God and Israel. Understood as applied in Jeremiah 31 to the end of time when the covenant at Sinai is reconfirmed.[24] | New Covenant (the term Brit Chadasha is not understood by most non-Jews). | |
1) Covenantal view: those with a saving faith in Jesus Christ who are individually elected to believe. 2) Dispensationalistic view: Israel (although this does not translate into a belief that Jews are “saved”). 3) Dual covenant view: Israel (and this does translate into a belief that Jews are “saved.”)[citation needed] | Phrase indicating that Jews have been chosen to fulfill a mission of proclaiming God's truth among the nations. Implies a greater level of responsibility. Does not imply any form of superiority.[25] | Chosen (when speaking of the view each group has of itself, and not as an absolute term). | |
The Christian Messiah Jesus. | Septuagint translation of the Hebrew word Mashiach (anointed one). Used solely by Christians to describe Jesus of Nazareth.[26] | 1) Christ (when speaking in Christian terms).
2) Messiah (when speaking in absolute terms). That is, the statement “Jews and Christians believe they will one day agree who the true Christ is” is presumptive toward Christianity and not NPOV. | |
Self identification of people who believe in Jesus Christ, the majority of whom will hold a standard of belief in general agreement with the Nicene Creed, regardless of ethnic background. | People (presumed to be Gentiles) who believe in Jesus Christ, regardless of doctrinal content. | 1) Christians (when speaking of the self identified group, regardless of ethnic background).
2) Gentiles (if the presumption in a Jewish context could create confusion in a mixed audience, such as: "although Trinitarianism constituted idolatry for Jews, it did not for Christians" i.e. Gentiles). [27] | |
1) Protestants: the Old and New Testaments. 2) Roman Catholics include the Deuterocanonical books. 3) Eastern Orthodox include the Anagignoskomena of the Septuagint. | Books added by Christians to Tanakh to create their Bible[28] | 1) Protestant Bible (when meaning the Old and New Testaments).
2) Catholic Bible (when also including the basic Apocrypha). 3) Eastern Orthodox Bible (when also including the expanded Apocrypha). 4) New Testament (when only speaking of the New Testament). NOTE: this is primarily a Jewish term, since Christians normally call their own Bible with the simple term "the Bible." | |
b'rit |
Any of the biblically defined relationships between God and his people, unilateral or bilateral. Covenant Theology and Dispensationalism are highly regarded, but idiosyncratic, versions of this thinking. Covenant theology sees all Dispensations as expressions of a single relationship. Dispensationalist theology sees all Covenants as expressions of multiple, successive, relationships. Dual Covenant theology sees Jewish and Christian Covenants as parallel relationships with God. "B'rit" is a familiar term to adherents of British Israelism.[29] | The biblical covenants, especially Sinai.[30] | Covenant (in context of a religion’s self understanding, and not in an absolute sense). |
The wooden structure used for the crucifixion of Jesus. The symbol of Christianity.[31] | A wooden structure used by the Romans to inflict slow, painful, public death, for example after the Third Servile War, 6,000 rebel slaves were crucified along the road between Rome and Capua.[32] The Christian use of the cross as a symbol resulted in the symbol being associated with hundreds of years of persecution.[33] | ||
God-killing, historically used against the Jews, see also Responsibility for the death of Jesus. Considered Anti-Semitic by some Christians when applied to beliefs about Jewish actions against Jesus portrayed in the NT.[34] | Considered Anti-Semitic when applied to beliefs about Jewish actions against Jesus portrayed in the NT.[35] |
E-J
[edit]Term | possible Christian perception | possible Jewish perception | Unambiguous Terms |
---|---|---|---|
People with a saving faith in Jesus Christ, either 1) individually elected to believe (classical Calvinism, Arminianism, Roman Catholicism) or 2) corporately elected by being in the body of believers (Pelagianism, Dispensationalism). | Unusual word for “Chosen.” | ||
False Messiah
|
Associated with False Christs, the Antichrist, and those claiming to be Jesus. | One who claims to be the Messiah (or others claim to be the Messiah) and fails to rebuild the temple, gather all Jews to Israel, set up worldwide peace, and bring knowledge of God to entire world. Commonly held examples are Jesus, Bar Kochba, Shabbatai Z’vi, and Menachem Schneerson, see also Jewish Messiah claimants. Jesus is associated with the opposite of Messianic expectations (his biography is close in time to the destruction of the temple, the scattering of Jews from Israel, catastrophic war, and the founding of a religion that has sometimes been hostile to Jews). | |
A prerequisite for entering the Christian covenant (i.e. state of salvation). Cannot be produced without the Holy Spirit. | Not a prerequisite for entering the Mosaic or Noachide covenant, but a response to God. A reliance that God will do as He promised, which enables and encourages His faithful to do the same in return. | ||
Triune God: The Father, The Son, The Holy Spirit in single essence. This is not a compound unity; each personal dimension is fully God. This is not modalism; God is always Father, Son, and Spirit. This is not tritheism; there is only One God and not two or three. God relates to His faithful as a distant Judge (Father), an ever present Love and Help (Son), and an invisible inspiration (Spirit) – but it is the same God being experienced . | One God: single Infinite Person who is a distant Judge, an ever present Love and Help, and an invisible inspiration – with the multiplicity of experiences being a reflection of mortal limitations, and not of God’s infinite nature. However, Jews do sometimes speak of this single God in different ways: Elohim (when thinking of judgment), the Divine Name (when thinking of mercy). Also, God is seen both in masculine ways (judgment) and feminine ways (shekinah, mercy). | ||
1) the Good News (Greek: Eu-angellion, good-message). Evangelism is bringing someone the Good News of Jesus. Acceptance or belief in the good news essential to becoming a Christian. 2) one of the four books in the New Testament about the life of Jesus. 3) Colloquially, something absolutely certain and trustworthy ("it's the gospel truth!"). | 1) one of the four books in the Christian Scriptures (i.e. New Testament) about Jesus. 2) Something a Christian is preaching. | ||
Grace | charis: Unmerited favor, and the basis of God's mercy (i.e. if "mercy" were earned, it would be unnecessary).[36] | (1) Birchat HaMazon - a prayer of thanks after eating[37] (2) Chen/Chanun - gracefulness, charm (3) Chesed - mercy (4) Rachamim/Rachum - loving kindness kindness.[38] |
|
Unknown term. The Christian equivalent to the Jewish concept is the use of “GOD” or “LORD” when translating the Divine Name. Although sometimes accused of being a “Jewish superstition” (see articles on the American Standard Version and the New World Translation), the Christian practice is based on New Testament translation of the Divine Name in quotations of the Hebrew Bible as kyrios (Lord) or theos (God). The justification is that there are no other gods to distinguish God from, and use of the name is redundant. | Literally “The Name” as a substitute for the Divine Name when not in prayer. When in prayer, “Adonai” (my lord) is substituted. The practice is based on the commandment to “not take the name of the LORD in vain”. If the Divine Name is not used in general practice, it will not be taken in vain. Historically the use was reserved for the High Priest on the Day of Atonement. Tetragrammaton. | ||
Old Testament | Tanakh, specifically the Masoretic Text | ||
Generally an unused term, instead: Jewish Christians or Messianic Jews. | Members of a Christian group who may or may not be Jewish, but who use claims of Jewish identity as a means to convince Jews to convert to Christianity. | ||
Place of eternal punishment, Lake of Fire or "outer darkness." Roman Catholics also believe in Purgatory which is temporary punishment for those already destined for Heaven. | Gehenna is a place of purification for sinners that usually lasts up to a year, though some extremely wicked people may simply cease to exist after that time as Judaism does not typically promote the idea of eternal torment. Similar to Catholic purgatory, prayer from loved ones may speed and ease the process. Sometimes Gehinnom is seen below the earth, sometimes above, sometimes wholly distant.[39] | ||
1) 3rd person of the Triune God, 2) the influence (spirit / wind) of God. | Term generally not used.
(1) English translation for Ruach HaKodesh in the Tanakh[40]. (2) Circumlocution for biblical terms Ruach Elohim (Spirit of God) and Ruach YHWH (Spirit of the LORD) in Talmud and Midrash.[41] Conceived as something distinct from God, associated with noise and light, and speaks in both a feminine and masculine voice. Dwells in generation in proportion to its worthiness. The books of the bible are the visible result of its activity. The gift of prophesy is a sign of its presence.[41] |
||
Term shouted by the crowds to Jesus in Matthew 21:9 as they waved palm branches just before Passover in the spring[42] | "part of the Hallel ... familiar to everyone in Israel."[43] A petition for deliverance spoken as branches are waved during Sukkot in the fall[44] | ||
Generally used against Paganism or non-Abrahamic religions. The worship of multiple beings, or a physical representation of a being, even if that representation were monotheistic. | See Avodah Zara | ||
Latinized and Anglicized transliteration of Koine Greek Ίησους (elsewhere translated: Joshua). The Christian Messiah. | The Greco-Anglicized form of the name Yehoshua, or its shortened form Yeshua, claimed by Christians to be a deity. The Christian Messiah. | ||
1) The Biblical Israelites.[45] 2) People who practice Judaism with or without belief in Jesus.[46] | People who were born Jewish or had a valid conversion to Judaism. Note: valid converts are treated as if they are naturally born Jewish -- even if they later convert to another religion. | ||
Judaizers | Early Christians opposed by Paul, and modern Christians who try to pressure Gentile Christians to more fully observe Torah. | Christians who adopt some Jewish customs for missionary purposes or a slur against Jewish practice in general. |
K-P
[edit]Term | possible Christian perception | possible Jewish perception | Unambiguous Terms |
---|---|---|---|
Christ, Divine, God the Son, eternal king who saves sinners from sin and will judge the living and the dead at the end of time. | Future king who will rebuild the temple, gather all Jews to Israel, set up worldwide peace, and bring knowledge of God to entire world. | ||
Jewish Christians who believe in Jesus, whether or not they worship in Judaic ways. | Having to do with the Messiah. | ||
Messianic Gentiles
|
Generally an unused term: Christians | Generally an unused term: Christians | |
Messianics / Christians | Members of a Christian group who may or may not be Jewish, but who use claims of Jewish identity as a means to convince Jews to convert to Christianity. | ||
The Christian 27-books of Matthew through Revelation, the Greek Orthodox use the term Καινή Διαθήκη. | Term for the Christian books of Matthew through Revelation that implies the Tanakh has been replaced or relegated to a lesser status. Jews often use the term "Christian Scriptures" or “Christian Bible” (see entry for Christian Bible) | ||
See entry for Heaven | The world to come. Speculations are that (with very few exceptions) "all Israel has a share in the world to come." Also, "the righteous of all nations have a share in the world to come." | ||
Protestant: The books of the Hebrew Bible; Roman Catholic include the Deuterocanonicals; Greek Orthodox: Septuagint, see also Template:Books of the Old Testament. | Dismissive term for the Tanakh, implying that it has been replaced. | ||
"The Apostle". Pharisee who converted to Christianity. Understood as an expert scholar in Pharisaic Judaism[47], "Apostle to the Gentiles".[48] | Hellenistic theological founder of Christianity. Understood as being generally ignorant of Judaism. | ||
Pentecost | The day the Holy Spirit descended on the Church.[49] | Greek term for Shavuot.[50] | |
A first century Jewish sect depicted in the N.T. as self-righteous, see also Woes of the Pharisees. The term is generally negative in common English usage.[51] | Predecessors of Rabbinic Judaism, such as Hillel the Elder.[52] |
Q-S
[edit]Term | possible Christian perception | possible Jewish perception | Unambiguous Terms |
---|---|---|---|
Teachings of and related to rabbis.[53] | The body of Rabbis in the 1st to 4th centuries C.E. who created the Talmud. Although there are "Rabbis" in modern Judaism, the self identification is "Judaism" and not "Rabbinic Judaism". | ||
Redemption
ge'ulah |
Christ's sacrifice and intercession for human salvation.[54] Various theologies of redemption within Christian denominations. | A recurrent theme in the Hebrew Bible, especially in respect to land and liberty, underscoring the lasting dignity of individuals and families within the community of Israel. Hebrews could not be kept in debt slavery, nor could family land be sold (rather rented). Guaranteeing the inheritance of future generations. God will bring the ge'ulah through His messiah, which will redeem the Jewish People from exile and oppression. A go'el is the person who is the vehicle of ge'ulah. | |
Religious | A state of belief or practice. | A state of practice according to halakhic standards. | |
Sabbath
|
1) Sunday (for first-day Sabbatarians). 2) Saturday (Friday sundown to Saturday sundown, for seventh-day Sabbatarians). | Saturday (Friday sundown until nightfall on Saturday), the day of rest. | First-day Sabbath, Seventh-day Sabbath, Shabbat. |
Apostle. Name given to Simon by Jesus, meaning “Rock.” The New Testament sometimes uses the Aramaic equivalent of Cephas (also meaning “Rock”). See also Primacy of Simon Peter. | Christian Apostle. | ||
1) Redemption from the penalty of sin (hell). 2) Redemption from the bondage to sin (transformed life) | Not a commonly used term. Since Judaism lacks a concept of Original Sin, there is no use of the term for redemption from the bondage to sin. However, the term is sometimes used in reference to inheritance of the world to come.[55] | ||
The serpent who tempted Adam and Eve and deceives the world into sin,[56] and fallen angel Lucifer[57] also called the Devil.[58] Defeated and cast into the Lake of Fire before the Final Judgment of humanity.[59] Note: Calvinists see Satan as a tool of God, and not as a rival power (compare Jewish view). | 1) Any enemy or accuser (in Job, an angel; in the garden, the serpent; in human relations, any enemy), 2) The embodiment of Yetzer HaRa.[60] Note: Unlike the Christian perception of a rebellious angel, Satan does God's work by revealing hidden character flaws in humans so they may be improved upon in order to strengthen desire to avoid evil and embrace goodness.[61] | ||
The return of Jesus to earth from heaven, to fulfil the rest of Messianic prophecy such as the Resurrection of the dead, last judgment, and full establishment of the Kingdom of God on earth including the Messianic Age.[62] Christians believe Jesus is the prophesied Suffering Servant who is wrongly rejected the first time, thus Christians view the failure to establish Jesus as Messiah as not being his own failure, but of those who refuse to follow him.[63] | Judaism waits for the coming of the Jewish messiah. In the Jewish view there is only one "coming," and a messianic candidate is considered to be a Failed Messiah if he dies before accomplishing his mission. Judaism rejects that Jesus is the "Suffering Servant" and does not view that prophecy as justification for his failed first attempt of being Messiah.[64] | ||
Generally unknown, except to students of the Council of Jerusalem, see also Biblical law in Christianity | Teachings of God applicable to all humanity.[65] | ||
Generally unknown, biblical term used by Jesus, translated "Hear O Israel ..." (Mark 12:28–34).[66] | Considered the most important prayer in Judaism, and its twice-daily recitation is a mitzvah (religious commandment).[67] | ||
Unknown term. See Arianism[68] "There is in the Divine Being but one indivisible essence."[69] "The whole undivided essence of God belongs equally to each of the three persons."[70] | Worship of deities other than God along with God. There are varying views amongst the rabbis as to whether this is considered idolatry for non-Jews. The dominant view is that it is not. However, the unanimous view is that constitutes idolatry for Jews, even if they self-identify as Christian or "Messianic".[5] | ||
Both an action and a state. Humankind commit sins because of being born sinful. The measure is against the sinless perfection of Christ. According to 1 John 3:4, "sin is lawlessness." | Acting in a way that has been forbidden by God, or refusing to act in a way commanded by God. Transgressing against God's commandments. An action, and not a state, and something which may be corrected through repentance. | ||
Catholic term[71], rarely used elsewhere. The state of sinfulness that humankind are born into, making the human condition imperfect, prone to sin, and unworthy to be in the presence of a sinless God. | Not a Jewish term. Known as a Christian idea that people are born inherently with sin. | ||
Blasphemy of the Holy Spirit is unforgivable (Mark 3:28–29).[72] | Any sin (transgression of the torah) is forgivable by God. | ||
A biblical title of Jesus that expresses divinity.[73] | A biblical phrase applied to angels or demigods (see Sons of God) or to the ideal King of Israel or to human beings in general. "Yet the term by no means carries the idea of physical descent from, and essential unity with, God the Father."[74] | ||
The Passion | Israel[75] | ||
The New Covenant between God and Christianity supersedes the Mosaic Covenant between God and Israel. | Cultural imperialism |
T-Z
[edit]Term | possible Christian perception | possible Jewish perception | Unambiguous Terms |
---|---|---|---|
In missionary work, used instead of the term "Old Testament."[76] | An acronym for Torah—Neviim—Kethuvim, i.e. T—N—K, i.e. TaNaKh. | ||
Latin term adopted for the two parts of the Christian Bible, attributed to Tertullian but some propose Marcion[77] | Christian term | ||
The Laws of Moses or Pentateuch.[78] | The teaching, both oral and written, received by Moses from God on the Biblical Mount Sinai. | ||
One God in three Hypostases. Not a partnership or compound unity. Each “person” (the common, but inaccurate, English term) is fully God. | See Shittuf. | ||
Generally unknown, but scholars think Jesus wore the Tzitzit[79][80], see also Christianity and fringed garments | One of the 613 Mitzvot: Tassels worn on the corner of a garment. | ||
1) Christ the Logos -- the eternal Word, Principle, of God. Foundation for all existence. Enfleshed in the person of Jesus Christ. 2) The Bible. | Not a normally used term. The Torah -- the eternal Word, Principle of God. Foundation for all existence. | ||
Good and evil deeds, performance of Christian religious rituals, or observance of Jewish Torah.[81] Major source of division between Catholics and Protestants regarding salvation: Catholics teach Faith and Works, see Epistle of James and The Sheep and the Goats, while Protestants teach Faith Alone. See also Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification, Legalism (theology), Covenantal nomism. | Performing mitzvot, or God's commandments, are encouraged to be an expression of an existing relationship and Covenant with God, and not an attempt to obtain one.[82] | ||
Understood by some Christians as a Hebraic synonym for Jesus. | Word for “salvation” used in many prayers. Also a common name for Jews, and related to “Joshua.” Used without a Christian context, will not be associated with “Jesus”. | ||
Unknown term. | Literally “Evil Inclination.” A part of human nature, which is most commonly understood as a tendency to commit wrongful acts. It is not viewed as a state of being, but as one of two competing tendencies (good and bad). Understood as the animal nature, responsible for desires to eat, procreate, etc. There would be no earthly survival without it, and though Jews are encouraged to rise above it, they are not encouraged to eliminate it. Instead, when a child comes of age (13 for boys and 12 for girls) he is considered to have added the “Yetzer HaTov”; literally “Good Inclination.” As the Yetzer HaRa is responsible for personal survival, the Yetzer HaTov is responsible for helping others to survive. Without the Yetzer HaRa, there would be no sex and no children. Without the Yetzer HaTov there would be no feeding and nurturing of children. Both are essential (and when in harmony, good) aspects of humanity. It cannot be equated with the Christian concept of Original Sin (which has no good aspects). Further, although Original Sin condemns a person to hell without salvation, the Yetzer HaRa does not. The Jew does not need to be saved from his humanity, but instead needs to “grow up” in it. |
References
[edit]- ^ "Apostasy" in the Catholic Encyclopedia
- ^ Louis Berkhof, Systematic Theology, pages 545-549
- ^ Kohler, Kaufman and Richard Gottheil. "Apostasy and Apostates from Judaism" in the Jewish Encyclopedia
- ^ "When we discuss the apostatized Jews, we are talking about Converts Out and Jewish Parentage/Background within other Current Religion" from Elazar, Dan. "Apostasy Among American Jews". Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs - sociological study based on 1990 Jewish population survey
- ^ a b c The Real Messiah, by Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan, pp 7ff: "Worship of any three-part god by a Jew is nothing less than a form of idolatry."
- ^ 1 John 2:22.
- ^ Revelation 13:11-18.
- ^ Revelation 20:4.
- ^ Revelation 19:20.
- ^ There's a New World Coming, Hal Lindsey
- ^ Antichrist: Islam's Awaited Messiah, Joel Richardson
- ^ O'Reilly talks with Falwell.
- ^ Sarachek, The Doctrine of the Messiah in Medieval Jewish Literature, page 43
- ^ McGrath, Alister. Christian Theology, 2nd ed, pp. 341-360. cited by The Biblicist: Glossary of Theological Terms
- ^ "Atonement" in the Catholic Encyclopedia
- ^ a b Kohler, Kaufman. "Atonement" in the Jewish Encyclopedia
- ^ God graciously accepts the little we are able to achieve as if it were much.Morrison, Chanan. Rabbi Kook on Yom Kippur: Attaining Complete Teshuva.
- ^ Jews for Judaism FAQ: Following the Temple destruction in 70 C.E. did rabbinic Judaism substitute a non-biblical atonement system?
- ^ Historically Jews have disagreed over whether or not Christianity is a form of idolatry. The third century rabbi Abahu believed that the Trinity's idea of "The Son" violated the command to have "no God beside me"(Ex 20:3), i.e. a brother.(Ex. R. 29:5). However, Rabbi Menachem Ha-Me'iri argued that Christians believed in God's existance and so were not idolators and in the 18th century a similar opinion was voiced by Rabbi Yehuda Ashkenazi who argued that "In our era . . . when the gentiles in whose midst we dwell . . . [speak of God], their intention is directed toward the One Who made Heaven and Earth, albeit that they associate another personality with God." (Cf. David Ellenson, "A Jewish View of the Christian God: Some Cautionary and Hopeful Remarks" in Christianity in Jewish Terms, ed. Tikva Frymer-Kensky) - source Cunningham, Philip A. and Jan Katzew. Do Christians and Jews Worship the Same God? Institute for Christian and Jewish Studies, Febuary, 2001
- ^ On September 10, 2003, the Institute for Christian and Jewish Studies published a full page ad in the New York Times titled "Dabru Emet", proclaiming that Christians and Jews believed in the same God. It was signed by a number of leading Reform, Reconstructionist, Conservative, and Orthodox Jewish thinkers and scholars, among them Eugene Borowitz (Reform), Tikva Freymer-Kensky (Reconstructionist), Suzanna Heschel (Conservative), Elliot Dorf (Conservative), David Novak (Conservative), and Irving Greenberg (Orthodox) and Barry Freundel (Orthodox). Dabru Emet
- ^ "Throughout the centuries, more than a few Jewish thinkers have argued that the idea of the trinity (the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost) seemed idolatrous. Ultimately, however, the majority of Jewish scholars concluded that although Christianity speaks of a trinity, it does not conceive of the three forces as separate with different and conflicting wills. Rather, the trinity represents three aspects of one God. While Jews are forbidden to hold such a belief, it is not avodah zarah." Telushkin, Jewish Literacy, page 552
- ^ "In a comment upon Sanhedrin 63b, Rabbi Isaac, a medieval authority, spoke of Christians and Christianity in the following terms:
In taking this stance, Rabbi Isaac offered a distinction that was unknown in talmudic Judaism -- that although Trinitarianism constituted idolatry for Jews, it did not for Christians."Although they [Christians] mention the name of Heaven, meaning thereby Jesus of Nazareth, they do not at all events mention a strange deity, and moreover, they mean thereby the Maker of Heaven and Earth too; and despite the fact that they associate the name of Heaven with an alien deity, we do not find that it is forbidden to cause Gentiles to make such an association, ... since such an association (shituf) is not forbidden to the sons of Noah
--Tikva Freymer-Kensky, Christianity in Jewish Terms, pp 73ff - ^ Ohr.edu "Ask the Rabbi"
- ^ Jewish Encyclopedia: New Testament: "The idea of the new covenant is based chiefly upon Jer. xxxi. 31-34 (comp. Heb. viii. 6-13, x. 16). That the prophet's words do not imply an abrogation of the Law is evidenced by his emphatic declaration of the immutability of the covenant with Israel (Jer 31:35–36; comp. 33:25); he obviously looked for a renewal of the Law through a regeneration of the hearts of the people."
- ^ Executative committee of the editorial board and Kaufman Kohler. "Chosen People" in the Jewish Encyclopedia.. See Jews as a Chosen People.
- ^ Jacobs, Joseph and Kaufman Kohler. "Christ" in the Jewish Encyclopedia
- ^ Tikva Freymer-Kensky, Christianity in Jewish Terms, pp 73ff
- ^ Accuracy of Torah Text
- ^ British Israelism
- ^ Jewish Encyclopedia: Covenant
- ^ Catholic Encyclopedia: Archæology of the Cross and Crucifix
- ^ Appian, Civil Wars, 1.120; see also Jewish Encyclopedia: Crucifixion
- ^ Telushkin, Jewish Literacy, page 461
- ^ Nicholls, Christian Antisemitism, pages 178, 364
- ^ Telushkin, Jewish Literacy, page 461
- ^ Berkhof, Systematic Theology, pages 426-431
- ^ Schecter, Solomon. Grace at Meals in the Jewish Encyclopedia
- ^ Kohler, Kaufman. Divine Grace in Jewish Encyclopedia
- ^ Everyman's Talmud, Abraham Cohen: pages 379-383
- ^ cf. Isaiah 63:10,11; Ps 51: 13, Koren translation of Hebrew Bible: The Holy Scriptures. (Jerusalem:Koren Publishers, 1983).
- ^ a b Jacobs, Joseph and Ludwig Blau. "The Holy Spirit" in The Jewish Encyclopedia
- ^ Catholic Encyclopedia: Hosanna
- ^ Bauer lexicon
- ^ Artscroll Siddur
- ^ Jews
- ^ Judaizers
- ^ Acts 22:1–3, Philippians 3:4–6
- ^ Romans 11:13, Galatians 2:8
- ^ Acts 2; Catholic Encyclopedia: Pentecost
- ^ Jewish Encyclopedia: Pentecost
- ^ Catholic Encyclopedia: Pharisees: "In the time of Our Lord such was their power and prestige that they sat and taught in "Moses' seat". This prestige naturally engendered arrogance and conceit, and led to a perversion in many respects of the conservative ideals of which they had been such staunch supporters. In many passages of the Gospels, Christ is quoted as warning the multitude against them in scathing terms."
- ^ Jewish Encyclopedia: Pharisees
- ^ Rabbi
- ^ Redemption
- ^ David Novak, Jewish-Christian Dialogue, page 31
- ^ Revelation 12:9
- ^ Isaiah 14:12
- ^ Matthew 4:1
- ^ Revelation 20:10
- ^ Rabbi Hoffmann
- ^ Rabbi Frand
- ^ Thayer's Lexicon definition of Parousia: "In the N.T. especially of the advent, i.e., the future, visible, return from heaven of Jesus, the Messiah, to raise the dead, hold the last judgment, and set up formally and gloriously the kingdom of God."
- ^ Suffering Servant ...both Jews and Christians have often failed in the mission of servants...
- ^ Jews for Judaism - Suffering Servant
- ^ Jewish Encyclopedia: Laws, Noachian
- ^ Catholic Encyclopedia: Chronology of the Life of Jesus Christ: "At an early age He must have learned the so called Shema (Deuteronomy 6:4), and the Hallel, or Psalms 113-118 (Hebrew)"
- ^ Jewish Encyclopedia: Shema'
- ^ Berkhof, Systematic Theology, pages 82-83
- ^ Berkhof, Systematic Theology, page 87
- ^ Berkhof, Systematic Theology, page 88
- ^ Catholic Encyclopedia: Original Sin
- ^ [1]
- ^ Catholic Encyclopedia: Son of God
- ^ Jewish Encyclopedia: Son of God
- ^ Jewish Encyclopedia: Servant of God
- ^ JewsForJesus
- ^ The Canon Debate, 2002, McDonald & Sanders editors, chapter 18 by Everett Ferguson quoting Tertullian's De praescriptione haereticorum 30: "Since Marcion separated the New Testament from the Old, he is necessarily subsequent to that which he separated, inasmuch as it was only in his power to separate what was previously united. Having been united previous to its separation, the fact of its subsequent separation proves the subsequence also of the man who effected the separation." Footnote 61 of page 308 adds: "[Wolfram] Kinzig suggests that it was Marcion who usually called his Bible testamentum [Latin for testament]."
- ^ http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14779c.htm Torah]
- ^ Matthew 14:36
- ^ Jewish Encyclopedia: Jesus: "Jesus wore the Ẓiẓit (Matt 9:20)"; Bauer lexicon, 3rd ed., 1979: "κράσπεδον: 1. edge, border, hem of a garment - But meaning 2 is also possible for these passages, dependending on how strictly Jesus followed Mosaic law, and also upon the way in which κράσπεδον was understood by the authors and first readers of the gospels. 2. tassel (ציצת), which the Israelite was obligated to wear on the four corners of his outer garment, according to Num 15:37–39; Dt 22:12. ... Of the Pharisees ... Mt 23:5."
- ^ Works
- ^ Maimonides Yad Chapter 10, quoted in Jacobs 1973: 159
See also
[edit]