Jump to content

User:Sirdog/Articleworkshop/Archives

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

July 2023

[edit]
☒N Note card confessions —Sirdog (talk) 11:10, 19 July 2023 (UTC)

According to Kelli Fowlds, note card confessions are "confessional YouTube videos in which producers use note cards in order to disclose personal information about themselves to the public. These videos vary in topic, but often contain many similarities that constitute them as their own genre. The standard note card confession video contains a single person in front of a camera, generally with a medium to close-up camera framing. The person on screen plays a song and then proceeds to confess something personal about her or his life by flipping through a stack of note cards. Topics include bullying, problems with family members, and even suicidal thoughts or actions. Each note card displays writing that tells a piece of the story. These videos normally last between two and ten minutes, and the person in the video remains silent the entire time." Note card confessions rose to prominence in 2011 and 2012, with the respective deaths of Ben Breedlove by heart disease and Amanda Todd by suicide, shortly after publishing their confession videos. Note card confessions are also known as note card videos, note card stories, index card confessions, index card videos, index card stories, flash card confessions, flash card videos, and flash card stories.

Source Summary Independent? Reliable? Significant Coverage? GNG Compliant?
https://blogs.voanews.com/digital-frontiers/2012/01/05/the-note-card-confessional/ Writer presents various stories of note card confessions, includes excerpts from clinical psychologists, and comments on the phenomenon. checkY Nota bene* Organization is generally reliable per WP:RSP, but article being in a section titled "blog" is suspect, and I cannot find credentials on the article author or editorial guidelines in general. checkY Yes, the article discusses the topic from start to finish. Orange tickY
https://medium.com/@ciaraandrews/note-card-confessions-8aef9b842860 Writer discusses why teens and young adults may use note card confessions and how they may be helpful in some situations but not in others. checkY Red X symbolN Medium is generally unreliable per WP:RSP, article is user generated with the author having seemingly no editorial oversight.

Article appears very well written, as an aside.

checkY Yes, the article discusses the topic from start to finish. Red X symbolN
https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/147242882.pdf Deemed unreliable before reviewed. checkY Red X symbolN Source is a thesis written by a college student with no editorial oversight or any peer review. Blue question mark? Deemed unreliable before reviewed. Red X symbolN
https://www.cogitatiopress.com/mediaandcommunication/article/view/16/44 Deemed unreliable before reviewed. checkY Red X symbolN Source is a full paper written by a student (I think?) with the only oversight being professors of an academic institution. Article abstract gives doubts to thoroughness or reliability (a qualitative and exploratory study with a sample of 25 card story videos... visual analysis revealed... videos are bound to very specific frame[s] of presentation... they deal with specific topics... presenter does not remain (visually) anonymous). It appears to just be visual observations of relevant videos stated in an overly scientific way.

Entire paper is released under CC-BY 4.0, as an aside.

Blue question mark? Deemed unreliable before reviewed. Red X symbolN
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1527476415591221 Blue question mark? Cannot access material. checkY Blue question mark? Cannot access material. Blue question mark? Cannot access material. Blue question mark?

Could not find additional material to review.

☒N Apology video —Sirdog (talk) 08:59, 12 August 2023 (UTC)
Added 07:31, 18 July 2023 (UTC)

A video posted by an online creator to apologize for some kind of misbehavior, whether intentional or not.

Source Independent? Reliable? Significant Coverage? GNG Complaint?
https://platformmagazine.org/2021/03/05/the-power-of-the-apology-video-and-why-so-many-fail/ checkY checkY Source appears to have editorial oversight, though they allow blogs and user generated content, and they don't appear to identify which-is which. Very annoying. That said, word count would seem to suggest it is an actual article per [1]. It appears well written. checkY checkY
https://www.vice.com/en/article/ywykzb/how-youtubers-james-charles-jaclyn-hill-pewdiepie-turned-the-apology-video-into-a-genre checkY checkY Wikipedia cannot seem to come to consensus on Vice's reliability per WP:RSP, but given the subject matter, the fact the article was written by a staff writer, there is not branding or wording that insinuates it is sponsored, and it doesn't read promotional, I think this is a genuine article with oversight and is probably reliable for the content it's describing. checkY checkY
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-10994837/YouTubers-appear-natural-say-sorry-four-times-apology-videos.html checkY ☒NDaily Mail is generally unreliable deprecated per RSP. Blue question mark? Deemed unreliable before reviewing. ☒N
https://www.ft.com/content/09d1b887-7ba3-468e-8998-695172586e01 checkY ☒NOpinion piece. User generated. Blue question mark? Deemed unreliable before reviewing. ☒N
https://bdnews24.com/stripe/entertainment/3f54gtpue1 checkY Nota bene* About section for website is drowning in puffery, I cannot find anything involving editorial policies aside from the puffery, no listings of editorial staff, nobody has ever discussed this source at RSP. Article appears to be written in an okay fashion, but focuses heavily on the opinion of the writer, and doesn't really discuss apology videos as a concept. checkY ☒N

Useful search term(s)

[edit]

"apology video" -en.wikipedia.org -youtube.com -colleen -jake -smith -urbandictionary.com

Notes

[edit]
  • It's very difficult to find articles discussing apology videos as it's own phenomena; searches are over-saturated with news organizations reporting on specific apologies. I'm half-surprised I found the 2 sources I did.
  • Damn, even the Dalai Lama had to submit an apology video: [2]

August 2023

[edit]
☒N Emet-Selch —Sirdog (talk) 08:59, 12 August 2023 (UTC)
Added 21:27, 3 August 2023 (UTC)
Character and primary antagonist in Final Fantasy XIV.
Source Independent? Reliable? Significant Coverage? GNG Complaint?
https://gamerant.com/final-fantasy-14-emet-selch-lore-backstory-ascians-solus-the-source-shadowbringers-endwalker/ checkY checkY ☒N Does not discuss the character at all, really, just summarizes the events of the back-half of Endwalker. ☒N
https://ftw.usatoday.com/2022/05/final-fantasy-nier-reincarnation-emet-selch checkY checkY ☒N Irrelevant commentary and discussion regarding his presence in another game. ☒N

Notes

[edit]
  • This'll probably be a massive long-shot, but no harm no foul, eh?
  • As I expected... a long shot. I can only really find cruft and listicles regarding him. A shame.