User:Plenipotentiarian/sandbox
2018 British cabinet reshuffle
Theresa May carried out the first major reshuffle of her minority government in January 2018. Following the sacking of Damian Green as First Secretary of State in December 2017, the reshuffle had been highly anticipated and briefed in the press. There were reports of "up to a quarter" of her cabinet ministers who might lose their positions, including Boris Johnson, who had been seen to cause a number of political gaffes during his term as Foreign Secretary.[1][2] The reshuffle was seen as an opportunity for the Prime Minister to reassert her authority, greatly diminished following the result of the snap general election in the previous summer. Despite being described by 10 Downing Street as a chance to "refresh" the Cabinet,[3] few changes were made to the ministerial line-up. On 9 January, newspaper headlines reflected the chaotic nature of May's reshuffle, with The Daily Telegraph describing it as, "The Night of the Blunt Stiletto",[4] a reference to the 1962 reshuffle carried out by Harold Macmillan.
It was widely reported that Jeremy Hunt was due to be moved from the Department for Health to become Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, but refused. Instead he defended his position as Health Secretary and convinced May to allow him to remain in post, and for "Social Care" to be added to the name of his department.[5] After considerable speculation that Justine Greening would lose her job as Education Secretary, she refused the offer of Secretary of State for Work and Pensions and chose instead to resign from the government.[6][7]
Cabinet-level changes
[edit]| Colour key |
|---|
Joined the Cabinet
Left the Cabinet
Portfolio renamed
|
Junior ministerial changes
[edit]| Colour key |
|---|
Promoted[note 2]
Left the government
|
.jpg)
Whips' Office appointments
[edit]| Whip | New position | |
|---|---|---|
|
Christopher Pincher MP | Deputy Chief Government Whip Treasurer of the Household |
|
Kelly Tolhurst MP | Assistant Government Whip |
|
Mims Davies MP | |
|
Amanda Milling MP | |
|
Jo Churchill MP | |
|
Wendy Morton MP | |
|
Nus Ghani MP | |
Conservative Party appointments
[edit]As well as appointing Brandon Lewis to become Chairman of the Conservative Party, May also announced a new Deputy Chairman and nine Vice Chairmen.
| Appointee | Position before appointment | New party position | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
James Cleverly TD MP | Parliamentary Private Secretary to the Minister of State for Immigration | Deputy Chairman of the Conservative Party |
|
Chris Skidmore FRHistS FSA FRSA MP | Minister for the Constitution | Vice Chairman for Policy |
|
Kemi Badenoch MP | Backbencher (elected in 2017) | Vice Chairman for Candidates |
|
Ben Bradley MP | Backbencher (elected in 2017) | Vice Chairman for Youth |
|
Maria Caulfield MP | Backbencher (elected in 2015) | Vice Chairman for Women |
|
Rehman Chishti MP | Backbencher (elected in 2010) | Vice Chairman for Communities |
|
Helen Grant | Backbencher (elected in 2010) | |
|
Andrew Jones MP | Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury | Vice Chairman for Business Engagement |
|
Marcus Jones MP | Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government | Vice Chairman for Local Government |
|
James Morris MP | Backbencher (elected in 2010) | Vice Chairman for Training and Development |
Reaction
[edit]The reshuffle was widely considered a political failure, falling short of the expectation for a radical shake-up. The Guardian called it a "pointless luxury" that would cost the government,[8] and Gary Gibbon of Channel 4 News noted that it had revealed the Prime Minister's weakened position, naming the reshuffle as the "Night of the Long Plastic Forks."[9] Writing his editorial in the London Evening Standard, George Osborne credited May with orchestrating "the worst reshuffle in modern history."[10][11]
Resignation of Justine Greening
[edit]Justine Greening was reported to have spent over three hours inside 10 Downing Street, discussing her political future with the Prime Minister. Despite being offered the position of Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, Greening refused to leave the Department for Education, describing it as being her "dream job." Soon after she emerged from Number 10, her formal resignation was announced and May expressed her disappointment at the decision.[12] In a statement on Twitter, Greening wrote: "Social mobility matters to me & our country more than my ministerial career." – some thought this to be alluding to her criticism of May's grammar schools policy.[13]
Many commentators wrote of their dismay at Greening's resignation. Melissa Benn, founder of the Local Schools Network, described her departure as "bad news for anyone who cares about education,"[14] and Stephen Bush wrote in the New Statesman that May's treatment of her Education Secretary "makes no sense at all." Bush reasoned that Greening was a successful minister who didn't deserve demotion to Work and Pensions, and that her return to the backbench could add a vote to the bloc of anti-Brexit Tory MPs, given that she represents Putney, a heavily pro-Remain constituency.[15] Ruth Davidson, leader of the Scottish Conservatives, praised Greening as "a real role model for LGBT+ Conservatives,"[16] and Labour MP Jonathan Reynolds tweeted that: "A Conservative Party which can find a role for Toby Young but not for Justine Greening is one that can be beaten."[17]
Faisal Islam of Sky News reported that a number of Conservative MPs had privately expressed their anger at Greening's treatment, calling it a "dreadful error."[18]
Failure to move Jeremy Hunt
[edit]Jeremy Hunt's meeting with the Prime Minister lasted over an hour, during which time Greg Clarke, the Business Secretary, had arrived. Hunt and Clarke were expected to swap jobs but Hunt refused, convincing Theresa May to allow him to stay at the Department and to widen his brief to include social care.[19] May's willingness to accept Hunt's request was seen as a sign of her diminished authority, which she had hoped to improve by carrying out such a reshuffle.[7] An editorial in The Sun newspaper praised Hunt for showing his "dedication" to the National Health Service, though it admitted that he had "reduced the Cabinet reshuffle to chaos."[20]
Comparison were drawn between Hunt's success at persuading May to allow him to continue in his role, and Justine Greening's failure to do so. Anonymous Tory MPs were quoted as saying that the Prime Minister had "caved into boys but not a woman," expanding the brief of a disloyal minister while forcing a loyal one to resign.[18]
Renamed government departments
[edit]In the reshuffle, the Department of Health (DH) became the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC), and the Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG) became the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG). It was stated by the government that these changes had been made in order to reflect the government's renewed focus on housing and social care issues.[21] Crisis, the national charity for single homeless people, tweeted its approval of the change,[22] though others have criticised it as a rebranding exercise. It transpired that the DH's name change only related to the department taking responsibility for the social care green paper that had been overseen by the Cabinet Office, rather than any representing any meaningful structural change.[23] Leader of the Opposition Jeremy Corbyn called rebranding the departments a "pointless and lacklustre PR exercise" that would not deliver real change. He stated: "You can’t make up for nearly eight years of failure by changing the name of a department."[24][25]
Controversy over Maria Caulfield's appointment
[edit]The British Pregnancy Advisory Service tweeted a statement in the wake of Maria Caulfield's appointment as Vice Chairman of the Conservative Party for Women, saying that they were "incredibly disappointed," due to her anti-abortion voting record.[26][27] They referred specifically to her opposition to the Reproductive Health (Access to Terminations) Bill, a Ten Minute Rule bill put forward by Diana Johnson in March 2017, which proposed to end prosecutions against women who terminated their pregnancies without permission.[28] Caulfield's appointment was also criticised by actor and activist Gillian Anderson[29] and the leader of the Women's Equality Party, Sophie Walker, who stated that: "Someone who believes (abortion rights) should be restricted can never advocate effectively for (women)."[30]
Nadine Dorries defended her parliamentary colleague, tweeting her support and criticising those that she claimed had attacked Caulfield for "holding a different point of view."[31]
Notable media gaffes
[edit]Even before any official announcement had been issued by Downing Street, there was criticism about the organisation and handling of the reshuffle. This narrative began with a tweet sent out by the Conservative Campaign Headquarters account, congratulating Chris Grayling on his appointment as Chairman of the Conservative Party. Although it was quickly deleted, the error soon caught the media's attention.[32] Some mockingly suggested that Grayling had broken the record for the shortest tenure as Party Chairman.[33]
Jeremy Hunt 'liked' a tweet from Paul Staines, breaking the news of Justine Greening's resignation.[34] Hunt swiftly apologised and insisted that he had accidentally pressed the 'like' button, adding his admiration for Greening.[35]
See also
[edit]Notes
[edit]- ^ a b Non-ministerial position
- ^ According to the ministerial pay scale (Parliamentary Private Secretary < Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State < Minister of State)
References
[edit]- ^ Dan Bloom (31 December 2017). "Theresa May 'set to sack up to a quarter of her Cabinet within weeks'". Daily Mirror.
- ^ Catherine Neilan (1 January 2018). "Boris Johnson, Chris Grayling, Patrick McLouglin, Justine Greening and Andrea Leadsom face sack as Theresa May mulls New Year Cabinet reshuffle". City A.M.
- ^ "Theresa May's cabinet reshuffle to reflect diverse UK — but Boris Johnson will stay in post". Sunday Times. 7 January 2018.
{{cite news}}: Unknown parameter|authors=ignored (help) - ^ Gordon Rayner (9 January 2018). "Night of the blunt stiletto". Daily Telegraph.
- ^ Mikey Smith (8 January 2018). "Jeremy Hunt has got a new job in Theresa May's Cabinet reshuffle after an hour inside Number 10". Daily Mirror.
- ^ Jason Groves (9 January 2018). "No Prime Minister! Theresa May sacks Justine Greening after she refuses new Cabinet job in clash at No 10 while Health Secretary turns down move on a day of reshuffle chaos". Daily Mail.
- ^ a b "Theresa May's chaotic Cabinet reshuffle: Jeremy Hunt refuses job as business secretary as Justine Greening quits". Daily Telegraph. 8 January 2018.
{{cite news}}: Unknown parameter|authors=ignored (help) - ^ "The Guardian view on the reshuffle: a pointless luxury". The Guardian. 9 January 2018.
- ^ Gary Gibbon (8 January 2018). "Reshuffle: night of the long plastic forks". Channel 4 News.
- ^ "Evening Standard comment: Reshuffle farce shows PM's essential weakness". London Evening Standard. 9 January 2018.
- ^ Emilio Casalicchio (9 January 2018). "George Osborne: Theresa May's Cabinet reshuffle is the worst in modern history". PoliticsHome.
- ^ Joshua Taylor (8 January 2018). "Justine Greening quits Theresa May's government after being offered humiliating step down". Daily Mirror.
- ^ George Parker (8 January 2018). "Theresa May's cabinet reshuffle goes off course". Financial Times.
- ^ Melissa Benn (9 January 2018). "Justine Greening's departure is bad news for anyone who cares about education". The Guardian.
- ^ Stephen Bush (8 January 2018). "Theresa May's treatment of Justine Greening makes no sense at all". New Statesman.
- ^ Tom Powell (8 January 2018). "Theresa May's Cabinet reshuffle backfires as education secretary Justine Greening refuses new role and quits". London Evening Standard.
- ^ "Jonathan Reynolds on Twitter". 8 January 2018.
- ^ a b Faisal Islam (9 January 2018). "'A dreadful error': Tories lament May's reshuffle as Greening departs". Sky News.
- ^ Paul Waugh (9 January 2018). "Greg Clark Was 'Set For Health Secretary Job' Until Jeremy Hunt Insisted On Staying". Huffington Post UK.
- ^ "Jeremy Hunt's refusal to leave Health Secretary shows his dedication to NHS". The Sun. 9 January 2018.
- ^ "Government renews focus on housing with Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government". Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government. 8 January 2018.
- ^ Sophie Barnes (8 January 2018). "DCLG renamed Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government". Inside Housing.
- ^ "'Nothing has changed!': The rebranding reshuffle". Local Government Chronicle. 8 January 2018.
{{cite news}}: Unknown parameter|authors=ignored (help) - ^ Paul Waugh (8 January 2018). "Jeremy Corbyn Slams May's Reshuffle As 'Pointless PR Exercise' Out Of Touch With Real Britain". Huffington Post.
- ^ Harry Cockburn (8 January 2018). "Jeremy Corbyn brands Theresa May's Cabinet reshuffle 'pointless and lacklustre PR exercise'". The Independent.
- ^ Lizzy Buchan (8 January 2018). "Maria Caulfield: Abortion rights campaigners condemn appointment of pro-life MP as Tory vice chair for women". The Independent.
{{cite news}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter:|1=(help) - ^ Emilio Casalicchio (8 January 2018). "Labour fury as anti-abortion MP is made Conservative vice-chair for women". PoliticsHome.
- ^ "Maria Caulfield: MP's new women's role sparks backlash". BBC News. 8 January 2018.
- ^ "Gillian Anderson: Maria Caulfield's appointment 'devastating step backwards'". Belfast Telegraph. 8 January 2018.
- ^ "Cabinet reshuffle: Abortion rights activists 'appalled' as May appoints pro-life Maria Caulfield to women's role". London Evening Standard. 8 January 2018.
{{cite news}}: Unknown parameter|authors=ignored (help) - ^ Steve Hawkes (8 January 2018). "'PRO-LIFE' ROW: Theresa May blasted after appointing anti-abortion MP Maria Caulfield as new vice-chair for women". The Sun.
- ^ Joe Murphy (8 January 2018). "Conservative Party Cabinet reshuffle farce as Chris Grayling is wrongly named Tory party chairman instead of Brandon Lewis". London Evening Standard.
- ^ David Singleton (8 January 2018). "Chris Grayling gets to be Tory party chairman… for all of 27 seconds". TotalPolitics.
- ^ Amanda Devlin (9 January 2018). "WHAT A TWIT: Jeremy Hunt accidentally 'liked' a tweet about Justine Greening quitting the cabinet". The Sun.
- ^ Jen Mills (8 January 2018). "Jeremy Hunt sorry for 'accidentally' liking tweet about Justine Greening quitting cabinet". Metro.