User:Pigsonthewing/Citations - the future

This is an essay.

It contains the advice or opinions of one or more Wikipedia contributors. This page is not an encyclopedia article, nor is it one of Wikipedia's policies or guidelines, as it has not been thoroughly vetted by the community. Some essays represent widespread norms; others only represent minority viewpoints.

This is a sketch of how I envisage citations might operate, in the long term.

For each work, create a Wikidata¹ entry, Qnnnnn
- This will include author(s) (and possibly their ORCID(s), if there is no separate item), title, publisher/journal, ISBN/ISSN/DOI, etc. Maybe also translations of the title.
- Perhaps initially, only for works with ISBNs or DOIs
- Editors will be able to enter a citation as they do now, or using a simple wizard, in the manner of Citoid, and the tool will then create the Wikidata item, if none already exists
To cite a work use a template like <ref>{{Cite Q|Qnnnn}}</ref>
- To cite a specific page, use <ref>{{Cite Q|Qnnnn|page=34}}</ref>
- To cite with a quotation, use <ref>{{Cite Q|Qnnnn|page=34|quote="Hello, World"}}</ref>
- To cite with a note, <ref>{{Cite Q|Qnnnn|page=34|note=Later disproved}}</ref>
- For clarity, use meaningful reference names, like <ref name="Smith-2015">
- Alternatives like <ref>{{Cite Q|isbn=FOO}}</ref> or <ref>{{Cite Q|doi=FOO}}</ref> should also work. A bot can later substitute the equivalent QID
Each signed-in reader can then set, under "preferences", the format in which they wish to see citations rendered - no more WP:CITEVAR arguments!
A gadget will display full citation metadata during subsequent editing
There will be "Special:" pages showing the articles in which any given work, or any given author, is cited.
- See a mock-up of the latter.

[1] Or in a parallel Wikibase instance.

Updates

2017-05: Demonstrator template at {{Cite Q}}.
2017-09: Bots are creating, in bulk, Wikidata items for works cited (ongoing)

Updates

See also