User:Lizrileymga/Bibb Manufacturing Company/Dcb1986 Peer Review
Peer review
[edit]This is where you will complete your peer review exercise. Please use the following template to fill out your review.
General info
[edit]- Whose work are you reviewing? Lizrileymga
- Link to draft you're reviewing: Bibb Manufacturing Company
Lead evaluation
[edit]The lead states the topic clearly, and does a good job describing the article's major sections.
Content evaluation
[edit]The content is all relevant to the topic, and up to date.
Tone and Balance evaluation
[edit]It looks fairly neutral and unbiased, and does not attempt to persuade in any way.
Sources and References evaluation
[edit]There are a multitude of sources, almost every sentence in the article features a citation. The ones I clicked on worked, and seemed to be decently related to the topics.
Organization evaluation
[edit]The article is organized very well, and is easy to read. I did not notice any blatant grammatical or spelling errors.
Images and Media evaluation
[edit]There were three images, I think the placement is good and the images do a good job representing the context of the article. They had good captions.
New Article Evaluation
[edit]The article is notable, there is a large list of qualifying sources. The article is laid out well, and has numerous other embedded wiki subject links.
Overall impressions
[edit]Guiding questions:
- Has the content added improved the overall quality of the article - i.e. Is the article more complete?
- What are the strengths of the content added?
- How can the content added be improved?
Overall evaluation
[edit]The article is fairly complete, and had good sources. One small possible improvement I noticed could be the Plants/locations header, it might possibly look better by removing the / and replacing it with text, something like "Plants and Locations".