User:Indubitably/Notebook
Appearance
Default to delete
[edit]Non BLP
[edit]- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Björn Söderberg: not a BLP; Swedish trade unionist killed by neo-Nazis, three deletes and 9 or 10 keeps (not sure about one or two of the redirect comments), seems to be notable, deleted by Lar.
BLPs, regular deletions
[edit]- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Brown (sports broadcaster), BLP, radio producer, one delete, no independent sources, deleted by Lar.
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qu Xin, BLP, Chinese actor, five deletes, no sources, deleted by Lar and again by Dlohcierekim.
BLPs, no consensus, has independent sources, deleted
[edit]- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Lynch: BLP, lawyer, two deletes and one keep; no indication subject requested deletion, deleted by Lar, restored by Davewild.
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Putnam, BLP, film director, five deletes, five keeps; no indication subject requested deletion, deleted by Lar.
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Tsai, BLP, businessman, three deletes, five keeps; no indication subject requested deletion, deleted by Lar, has been recreated.
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Schoep, BLP, American neo-Nazi, two deletes, three keeps; no indication subject has requested deletion, deleted by Lar.
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caroline Dunsmore, BLP, criminal conviction, three deletes, four keeps, deleted by Fritzpoll.
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Theon, BLP, scientist, 10 deletes, 10 keeps; deleted by MZMcBride.
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Waddle, BLP, US Naval officer, six deletes, nine keeps, five merges; deleted then redirected to article that already contained the information by Xymmax, who shortly after restored the non-vandalism history by request.
BLPs, no consensus, no independent sources, deleted
[edit]- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earl J. Field, BLP, village mayor, one delete, two keeps, one merge, no independent sources, deleted by Lar.
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khristine Hvam, BLP, actress, three keeps, three deletes, no independent sources, was deleted by Stifle.
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soundman, BLP, musicians, two deletes, other comments inclining toward delete, lacks independent sources, deleted by Backslash Forwardslash.
BLPs, no consensus, deleted, subject didn't want bio
[edit]- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fred Shapiro, BLP, fraud conviction. 10 clear keeps, four deletes, subject appears not to want a bio, deleted by Fritzpoll.
- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ginger Jolie, BLP, pornstar. 22 keeps, 23 deletes, subject apparently did not want a bio, deleted by Wizardman. Went to DRV and was endorsed.
Wikipedia-related BLP
[edit]Related comments of interest
[edit]- Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lily Thai
- From the DRV:[1] Endorse closure, AfD is not a vote. Weak arguments will not be considered as much as well reasoned comments; Tabercil's comment quite firmly counters the comment made by SPNic, and "Article shows notability" shows very little knowledge about policy or the article, and gives no insight as to how notability is shown. This was a proper deletion, and even if closed as "no consensus," BLP's default to delete; the result would have been the same. Hersfold (t/a/c) 7:31 pm, 13 June 2009, Saturday (4 months, 17 days ago) (UTC−4)
Things that make baby Jesus cry
[edit]The number of BLPs (as categorized in Category:Living people) that have five or fewer watchers:[2]
- 56490 0
- 104664 1
- 80536 2
- 51603 3
- 32065 4
- 20376 5
- Approximately 330,000 of 413,655. Horrible.
- As of October 27, 2009.
Examples of the ridiculous
[edit]Almost entirely negative biographies
[edit]For AFD
[edit]- http://losangeles.metromix.com/restaurants/spanish/cobras-and-matadors-park-la-brea/95985/content
- http://www.calendarlive.com/dining/81157,0,6158202.venue
- http://theguide.latimes.com/los-feliz/restaurants/cobras-matadors-venue
- http://www.losangelesrestaurants.com/restaurant.cfm/restaurant/679/CobrasandMatadors
- http://events.dailynews.com/los-angeles-ca/venues/show/1014628-cobras-matadors
- http://www.laweekly.com/locations/cobras-and-matadors-112994/