User:Imsiddkidd/sandbox
Article Critique: The grade that the article has is S or Stub. It has this grade because it as a Stub article with not very much in it.
The article's indicated importance is to talk about relizational Morphology and present all of it's different aspects of it.
Not every fact in the article is referenced with an appropriate reference, however there were four different links to other wiki articles when discussing certain concepts.
Everything in the article appears to be relevant to the topic, however it is very short.
Nothing distracted me aside from the fact that it was a stub article which I found slightly disconcerting.
The article is neutral so far as I can tell. There were no claims made that appeared biased. The facts were presented quite neutrally.
The information seems to have all come from a single, the source that was cited.
The source cited was a neutral source and it came from a peer reviewed article from Stanford University.
There was only one source cited, which I mentioned above. However the other four references I was able to find as well and they led to other wiki pages about them.
The viewpoints of relizational morphology, also called Word and Paradigm in the article are underrepresented.
I come to this conclusion based on the fact that pretty much everything in this article is underrepresented given the fact that it is a Stub.
Of the one citation, the link does work and of the four references or links to other wiki pages they also work.
There does not appear to be any close paraphrasing or plagiarism in the article. It is evident which areas of the source article the author has borrowed form, however they worded in their own words.
One issue that is raised on the talk page is that the article was migrated there from Wiktionary where it did not belong,
another issue is that no attempt has been made to edit or verify it.
I agree with what the contributors say, the biggest issue with the article is that it is a Stub.
Added Sentences: This segment discusses Case Stacking in Relizational Morphology Case stacking can be defined as when one word contains multiple cases which show it's relation to multiple syntactical elements. It occurs within the framework of Relizational Morphology and it represents another aspect of it. It looks to explain and explore the complexities of words with multiple cases and bridge the gap between Morphology and Syntax. 1 [1]
- ^ Sadler, L. , & Nordlinger, R. (2006). Case stacking in realizational morphology. Linguistics, 44(3), 459-487.