Jump to content

User:Fireflysummers/Choose an Article

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Article Selection

[edit]

Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Option 1

[edit]
+Anima
Article Evaluation
This article is of low-importance and start-class. :I believe the American localization is out of print, due to legal and financial troubles at the publisher, Tokyopop.:The most recent notifications on the page were from 2011, indicating dead links in the bibliography. :The most recent discussions happened circa 2009, when the series was wrapping up its western serialization.:The writing is comprehensive but amateur and would benefit from another editing pass to streamline the ideas and information.:The formatting is outdated, or at least out of sync with similar pages.:I'm not sure if this article should exist, but it does and I'd like to pay it back to my middle school self by conducting maintenance.:
Sources

Option 2

[edit]
TopatoCo
Article Evaluation
This article is Bottom- and Low- Importance, Start-class.:Information on this page is outdated, and does not include major clients in their catalog (such as Welcome to Night Vale).:Based on the Talk channels, the page hasn't seen any major activity since 2018.:Honestly at the least, I'd propose making a table of their notable clients.:
Sources

Option 3

[edit]
Indie Game
Article Evaluation
This article is of high importance and B-class.:The writing seems relatively consistent. Based on the Talk channels, the discussion seems to focus on what is defined as indie and at what point an indie game becomes significant enough to add to the page.:I believe that their current definition of indie game is incomplete, unable to come to a consensus on boundaries such as number of people working on it, the involvement of publishers, or the level popularity. :I would like to submit a humanities-based sociological definition, which frames "indie game" as a specific cultural narrative and proposes the existence of the "Queer Indie Game Avant-Garde.":In general there doesn't seem to be a space for the counter-cultural aspects of indie games.:
Sources

Option 4

[edit]
Unfiction
Article Evaluation
If I was feeling really ambitious, I'd attempt to launch a new page for the unfiction genre. However, I don't have the literature to back it up and also I am very tired.:
Sources

Option 5

[edit]
Article title
Article Evaluation
Sources