User:CiderDog06/Choose an Article

Article Selection

Please list articles that you're considering for your Wikipedia assignment below. Begin to critique these articles and find relevant sources.

Judaism Unbound: Judaism Unbound#Format
Article Evaluation

-Content is relevant but incomplete and out of date
-Formatting doesn't match other similar articles (no history section)
-Facts are cited but citations come from a limited range of sources.
-Talk page is very limited
Sources: -https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/02/magazine/israel-american-jews.html:-THE CONVERSATION. (2016). In Moment (New York, N.Y.) (Vol. 41, Number 5, pp. 6-). Moment Magazine.:-https://www.jta.org/2024/07/18/religion/2-incarcerated-men-wanted-to-convert-to-judaism-this-rabbi-helped-them-do-it

Emma (2009 TV serial)
Article Evaluation: -Tone is not neutral in the episode descriptions.:-Some grammatical errors:-There seems to be some opinions and speculation in the content, for example: "She has never married, and now never will." As readers and watchers of Emma, we don't know that. Jane Austin never states that Ms. Bates will never marry, she simply describes her as an old maid. :-Episode summaries are missing significant details.
Sources: -Is it okay to cite the work itself in a wikipedia article since, in this case, it is an article about a piece of media? I would like to cite specific episodes that are summarized poorly (like the timemark for the stuff they missed) and quotes from the original novel.:1. BBC Productions., WGBH, Warner Home Video, et al. Emma. Distributed by Warner Home Video; 2010.; https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/tvandradioblog/2009/oct/04/emma-episode-one

Treeing Walker Coonhound:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Treeing_Walker_Coonhound
Article Evaluation

-Content is relevant but there are some grammatical errors.
-Some facts are not cited.
-Fighting over whether certain images should be included on the Talk Page
-Most recent talk topic was in 2015
Sources: Treeing Walker Coonhound climbs into AKC’s breed list. (2012). DVM, 43(4), 28-.:https://www.akc.org/dog-breeds/treeing-walker-coonhound/ McLoughlin P. Coonhounds Find Safe Haven in State. Tribune Content Agency LLC; 2006:1-.