Jump to content

User:Benjah-bmm27/degree/3/GCLJ1

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Mechanisms, GCLJ1

[edit]

The philosophy behind reaction mechanism determination

[edit]
According to Buskirk and Baradaran:
Yet textbooks continue to teach that mechanisms can only be proven false...
Chemists should be free to use evidence to either support or disprove mechanistic hypotheses...
Mechanisms can be proven on a practical basis to the same extent as other scientific theories can be.
The article's reviewers were divided on whether this is true, and most of them have published their views alongside the article itself
"Can Reaction Mechanisms Be Proven?", J. Chem. Ed. (2009) 86, 551–558

See User:Benjah-bmm27/degree/hps.

Isotopic labelling

[edit]
  • Solvolysis of phenethyl tosylate, Ph-CH2-CH2-OTs, to phenethyl acetate with acetic acid
    • Simple SN2 with EWGs in the para position on the benzene ring (e.g. p-NO2): ρ ≈ −1.5 (no significant accumulation of charge)
    • EDGs allow a symmetrical phenonium ion intermediate to form: ρ ≈ −1.5 (no significant accumulation of charge)
    • So-called assisted SN1
    • Evidence for symmetrical intermediate comes from scrambling of 13C label (C) on the α-carbon of phenethyl tosylate:
Ar-CH2-CH2-OTs → Ar-CH2-CH2-OAc + Ar-CH2-CH2-OTs

Kinetic isotope effects

[edit]