User:A Nobody/Deletion discussions
Appearance
This page charts my participation in deletion discussions since my rename (13 October 2008). This page lists completed discussions, i.e. it does not list any active or ongoing discussions, any ones that I plan to take to deletion review, or any one for userfied articles for which another discussion is also likely down the road.
My approach to deletion discussions
[edit]- I always look at the actual article under discussion as well as look for sources. In some instances, I am the only person in a discussion to actually bring specific sources to light.
- While these are indeed discussions and not votes, my current approach is to avoid replying to or commenting directly to anyone else until/unless someone responds to my initial post or alludes to me in their initial post. Once someone engages directly with me, then I will do the same.
List of discussions
[edit]Discussion | My stance | Result | Current status |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abattoir (comics) | Keep | merge to List of Batman Family enemies | Abattoir (comics) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Addictem | Keep | Redirect | Addictem |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Farooj Fresh | Keep | keep | Al Farooj Fresh |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Corvinus | Keep | merge to Underworld (film series) | Alexander Corvinus |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anastasia Tremaine | Keep | merge | Anastasia Tremaine |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annabeth (Percy Jackson) (2nd nomination) | Keep | no consensus to delete | Annabeth (Percy Jackson) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anya/Anastasia (character) | Keep | no consensus | Anya/Anastasia (character) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apocalypse War | Speedy keep all | keep | Apocalypse War |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Argentina–Greece relations | Keep | keep | Argentina–Greece relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armenia–Portugal relations (2nd nomination) | Keep | no consensus | Armenia–Portugal relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Auraya of the White | Keep | merge to Age of the Five | Auraya of the White |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avatar (Ultima) | Keep | keep | Avatar (Ultima) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Warriors Trial | Delete | delete | A Warriors Trial |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baba Shanti Giri | Nominated | delete | Baba Shanti Giri |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bao Jhi Ling | Delete | delete | Bao Jhi Ling |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barbados–Germany relations | Keep | no consensus | Barbados–Germany relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of the Windmill (Animal Farm) | Keep | merge to Animal Farm | Battle of the Windmill (Animal Farm) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Berserko | Keep | Redirect | Berserko |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Boss (C.O.P.S.) | Keep | No consensus | Big Boss (C.O.P.S.) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black holes in fiction | Keep | keep | Black holes in fiction |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blade (Masters of the Universe) | Keep | redirect to Masters of the Universe (film) | Blade (Masters of the Universe) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blah (2nd nomination) | Keep | no consensus | Blah |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blast-Attak | Keep | merge to List of Masters of the Universe characters | Blast-Attak |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bowser and Blitz | Keep | redirect to C.O.P.S. | Bowser and Blitz |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Broda Otto Barnes | Keep | no consensus | Broda Otto Barnes |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bulgaria–Indonesia relations | Keep | no consensus | Bulgaria–Indonesia relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carrie Petrelli | Delete | delete | Carrie Petrelli |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Champion X-men | Delete | delete | Champion X-men |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Characters and wildlife in Avatar | Strong keep | Keep | Characters and wildlife in Avatar |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlie Harper (Two and a Half Men) | Speedy keep | keep | Charlie Harper (Two and a Half Men) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chihuahua heights | Delete | delete | Chihuahua heights |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christine White | Keep | keep | Christine White |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chronology of Star Wars (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | no consensus | Chronology of Star Wars |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C.J. Stryver | Keep | keep | C.J. Stryver |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claire Redfield (Character) | Speedy keep | Keep | Claire Redfield (Character) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clamp Champ | Keep | redirect to Masters of the Universe | Clamp Champ |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of vampire traits | Keep | no consensus | Comparison of vampire traits |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Complete list of downloadable songs for the Rock Band series | Keep | keep | Complete list of downloadable songs for the Rock Band series |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corruption in Ghana | Keep | keep | Corruption in Ghana |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Countdown to Destruction | Keep | keep | Countdown to Destruction |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Croatia–Mongolia relations | Keep | keep | Croatia–Mongolia relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cutler Beckett | Keep | keep | Cutler Beckett |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D. B. Cooper in popular culture | Keep | keep | D. B. Cooper in popular culture |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DG (character) | Keep | keep | DG (character) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dorian Tyrell (2nd nomination) | Keep | keep | Dorian Tyrell |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drizella Tremaine (2nd nomination) | Keep | no consensus | Drizella Tremaine |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earth (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | Okay kids | Earth |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eastern Alliance | Keep | keep | Eastern Alliance |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eddie Quist | Keep | keep | Eddie Quist |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elaine Marley | Keep | Keep | Elaine Marley |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Extendar | Keep | merge to List of Masters of the Universe characters | Extendar |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faux Cyrillic (2nd nomination) | Keep | keep | Faux Cyrillic |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ferris Bueller's Day Off in popular culture | Keep | no consensus | Ferris Bueller's Day Off in popular culture |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fire lizard | Keep | no consensus | Fire lizard |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flatpoint High School (Strangers with Candy) | Keep | no consensus | Flatpoint High School (Strangers with Candy) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/France – Trinidad and Tobago relations | Keep | no consensus | France – Trinidad and Tobago relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gamorrean (2nd nomination) | Keep | keep | Gamorrean |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/German-Libyan relations | Keep | keep | German-Libyan relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geometric Negative Value Theorem | Delete | speedy delete | Geometric Negative Value Theorem |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glitch (character) | Keep | no consensus | Glitch (character) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graboid | Keep | no consensus | Graboid |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grail (DC Comics) | Speedy keep | no consensus | Grail (DC Comics) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grail (DC Comics) (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | speedy close...Speedily Closed[1] | Grail (DC Comics) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greece-Kyrgyzstan relations | Keep | no consensus | Greece-Kyrgyzstan relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gwen Grayson | Keep | redirect to Sky High (2005 film) | Gwen Grayson |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gwildor | Keep | keep | Gwildor |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haya Hisayo | Delete | speedy delete | Haya Hisayo |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/High culture | Keep | keep | High culture |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugo Austin | Speedy keep all | Keep without prejudice to opening more controlled AFD's | Hugo Austin |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human disguise | Keep | no consensus - default to delete...no consensus, deletion overturned | Human disguise |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human disguise (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | Keep | Human disguise |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illuminati in popular culture (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | keep | Illuminati in popular culture |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/India–Malta relations | Keep | keep | India–Malta relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indonesia and Papua New Guinea | Keep | keep | Indonesia and Papua New Guinea |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isla Nublar (3rd nomination) | Speedy/strong keep | keep | Isla Nublar |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isla Sorna (3rd nomination) | Speedy/strong keep | no consensus | Isla Sorna |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isola (fictional island) | Keep...Update...Update: Merged | no consensus | Isola (fictional island) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Scott Hilk | Delete | delete | James Scott Hilk |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Mui | Keep | no consensus | Jennifer Mui |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy the jellyfish | Delete | delete | Jeremy the jellyfish |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jimmy Patterson | Keep | no consensus | Jimmy Patterson |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jitsu (Masters of the Universe) | Keep | merge to List_of_Masters_of_the_Universe_characters#Jitsu | Jitsu (Masters of the Universe) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joachim Cronman (2nd nomination) | Keep | no consensus | Joachim Cronman |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joachim Cronman (3rd nomination) | Keep | no consensus | Joachim Cronman |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keith Starr | Delete | delete | Keith Starr |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Brooks | Keep | no consensus | Laura Brooks |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laws of compression | delete | delete | Laws of compression |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Life Mel honey | Keep | Keep | Life Mel honey |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lila Sawyer | keep | Redirect all | Lila Sawyer |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of characters in Skulduggery Pleasant | Keep | no consensus | List of characters in Skulduggery Pleasant |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of characters in Tin Man | Keep | keep | List of characters in Tin Man |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of chemical compounds with unusual names (3rd nomination) | Speedy keep | keep | List of chemical compounds with unusual names |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of common misconceptions (2nd nomination) | Speedy/strong keep | keep...no consensus | List of common misconceptions |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of creatures in the Resident Evil series (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep...Update | no consensus | List of creatures in the Resident Evil series |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of female stock characters (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep...Update | no consensus | List of female stock characters |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional computers | Keep | keep | List of fictional computers |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional swords (2nd nomination) | Keep | no consensus | List of fictional swords |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional television shows (3rd nomination) | Speedy keep | no consensus | List of fictional television shows |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of honorific titles in popular music (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep...merged | Keep | List of honorific titles in popular music |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of locations in the StarCraft series | Keep | no consensus | List of locations in the StarCraft series |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of one-time characters in The Simpsons (7th nomination) | Speedy keep | keep | List of one-time characters in The Simpsons |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Paper Mario series characters | Keep | no consensus | List of Paper Mario series characters |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Paper Mario series characters | Keep | no consensus | List of Paper Mario series characters |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Paper Mario series characters (2nd nomination) | Keep...Update | no consensus | List of Paper Mario series characters |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of problems solved by MacGyver (3rd nomination) | Keep | Delete...NOTE | List of problems solved by MacGyver |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pulp Fiction characters | Strong keep | Withdrawn by nominator | List of Pulp Fiction characters |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Rock Band track packs | Keep | keep | List of Rock Band track packs |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of SD Gundam G-Generation F mobile suits | Keep/merge/redirect...speedy close...redirect | redirect to SD Gundam G Generation | List of SD Gundam G-Generation F mobile suits |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs in Rock Band | Speedy keep | keep | List of songs in Rock Band |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs in Rock Band 2 | Speedy keep | keep | List of songs in Rock Band 2 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of terms of endearment (3rd nomination) | Speedy keep | Merge...reliable, sourceable | List of terms of endearment |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of units in the Age of Mythology series (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | delete...Post-close note | List of units in the Age of Mythology series |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of unusual deaths (fourth nomination) | Speedy keep | keep | List of unusual deaths |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of YouTube celebrities (4th nomination) | Speedy keep | keep | List of YouTube celebrities |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of zombie novels | Keep | keep | List of zombie novels |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loew's Cemetery | Keep | Keep | Loew's Cemetery |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LongArm | Keep | merge to C.O.P.S. | LongArm |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lord Nog | Delete | Speedy/Snow delete | Lord Nog |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucifer in popular culture | Keep | keep | Lucifer in popular culture |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mangle Time | Delete | speedy delete | Mangle Time |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manon Batiste | Keep | no consensus | Manon Batiste |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manon Batiste (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | keep | Manon Batiste |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marissa Moore | Comment...kept | result...withdrawn by nom | Marissa Moore |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Ellis (spinster) | Keep | Speedy Keep | Mary Ellis (spinster) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Master Shake (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | keep | Master Shake |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mesogog | Keep | no consensus | Mesogog |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/METRO CITY | Delete | delete | METRO CITY |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Corvin | Keep | keep | Michael Corvin |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mimic (Dungeons & Dragons) | Keep | keep | Mimic (Dungeons & Dragons) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minor characters of Days of our Lives | Keep | no consensus | Minor characters of Days of our Lives |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mirage (Aladdin) | Keep | no consensus | Mirage (Aladdin) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moldova–Switzerland relations | Keep | keep...keep | Moldova–Switzerland relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monorangeosis | Delete | speedy delete | Monorangeosis |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr. Skullhead | Strong keep | keep | Mr. Skullhead |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Munchie Strikes Back | Keep | Article has been substantially improved; there are no more delete votes. | Munchie Strikes Back |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Gaupher Eels | Delete | Delete | New Gaupher Eels |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Falco | Keep | keep | Nick Falco |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Once a Ranger (2nd nomination) | Keep | no consensus | Once a Ranger |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parkour in popular culture (3rd nomination) | Speedy keep | keep | Parkour in popular culture |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Hanley (Peyton Place) | Keep | no consensus | Paul Hanley (Peyton Place) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peggy Jean | Keep | keep | Peggy Jean |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip R. Bjork | Keep | keep | Philip R. Bjork |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plains of the Paynims | Keep | merge to Flanaess | Plains of the Paynims |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qwghlm | Keep | keep | Qwghlm |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rape and revenge films | Keep | Keep | Rape and revenge films |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebecca Hendrix | Keep...merge...General comment | merge to List of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit characters | Rebecca Hendrix |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Recurring characters in the Tomb Raider game series | Speedy keep | no consensus | Recurring characters in the Tomb Raider game series |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Republic of Ireland vs France (2010 FIFA World Cup Play-Off) | Keep | keep | Republic of Ireland vs France (2010 FIFA World Cup Play-Off) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reptar | Keep | keep | Reptar |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rock People | Keep | delete[2] | Rock People |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rusty Ryan (2nd nomination) | Keep | keep | Rusty Ryan |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sacred Heart Hospital (Scrubs) | Keep | keep, consider merging | Sacred Heart Hospital (Scrubs) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandor (fictional character) (2nd nomination) | Keep | merge to Dracula's Daughter | Sandor (fictional character) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salvation, Texas (book) | Keep | keep | Salvation, Texas (book) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S Gundam | Keep | keep | S Gundam |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shek Yam East Estate | Keep | redirect to Public Housing Estates in Kwai Chung | Shek Yam East Estate |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sisters of the Poor Child Ziko | Delete | delete | Sisters of the Poor Child Ziko |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solstice (film) | Keep | Keep | Solstice (film) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suicide (character) | Keep | speedy keep | Suicide (character) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sundown (C.O.P.S.) | Keep | merge to C.O.P.S. | Sundown (C.O.P.S.) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Switzerland–Uruguay relations | Keep | keep | Switzerland–Uruguay relations |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terran Federation (Starship Troopers) | Speedy keep | keep | Terran Federation (Starship Troopers) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bugman and Gaylord | Keep | Redirect | The Bugman and Gaylord |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Coltons | Keep | keep | The Coltons |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Ku Klux Klan In Prophecy | Keep | keep | The Ku Klux Klan In Prophecy |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The London Eye in popular culture (2nd nomination) | Keep | keep | The London Eye in popular culture |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Seamstress (A Tale of Two Cities) (second nomination) | Speedy keep | keep | The Seamstress (A Tale of Two Cities) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Skeptic (film) | Keep | keep | The Skeptic (film) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Suburbs (web series) | Weak keep | keep | The Suburbs (web series) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Well (church) | Keep | keep | The Well (church) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tommy Pickles | Keep | keep | Tommy Pickles |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Cunningham (Tony & Friends) | Delete | delete | Tony Cunningham (Tony & Friends) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toothing (2nd nomination) | Keep | keep | Toothing |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turbo Tu-Tone | Keep | merge to C.O.P.S. | Turbo Tu-Tone |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Two Brothers Brewing (2nd nomination) | Keep | keep | Two Brothers Brewing |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 in downloadable songs for the Rock Band series | Speedy keep | keep | 2007 in downloadable songs for the Rock Band series |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 in downloadable songs for the Rock Band series | Speedy keep | keep | 2008 in downloadable songs for the Rock Band series |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 in downloadable songs for the Rock Band series | Speedy keep | keep | 2009 in downloadable songs for the Rock Band series |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 in downloadable songs for the Rock Band series (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | Keep | 2009 in downloadable songs for the Rock Band series |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Undermountain | Keep | keep | Undermountain |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unforgivable Journey | Delete | delete | Unforgivable Journey |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Upstairs at The Gatehouse | Keep | speedy keep | Upstairs at The Gatehouse |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valerie Gray | Keep | keep | Valerie Gray |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Venus Flytrap (WKRP in Cincinnati) | Keep | keep | Venus Flytrap (WKRP in Cincinnati) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virginia Lewis (10th Kingdom) | Keep...Update | no consensus | Virginia Lewis (10th Kingdom) |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whers | Keep | keep | Whers |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Graham, 3rd Earl of Menteith (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | speedy keep | William Graham, 3rd Earl of Menteith |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Women in Shakespeare (2nd nomination) | Speedy keep | KEEP | Women in Shakespeare |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WoodyRimShot | Delete | delete | WoodyRimShot |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wyatt Cain | Keep | keep | Wyatt Cain |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoe Graystone | Keep | keep | Zoe Graystone |
Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/User:Dream Focus | Keep | Keep | User:Dream Focus |
Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/User:Richard Arthur Norton (1958- )/The League of Extraordinary Deletionists | Delete | drama-killing keep | User:Richard Arthur Norton (1958- )/The League of Extraordinary Deletionists |
Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron (4th nomination) | Speedy keep | keep...No consensus | Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron |
Notes
[edit]- ^ Closed twice with same results. See [1] and [2].
- ^ Undeleted and redirected by closing administrator following polite request and fair and mature response to that request.