Jump to content

User:77.103.88.137

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

A Moment Like This

[edit]

As a Reply to your edit on my user page in case you haven't seen it:

"Nor does the previous holder of record have any "bearing on the performance and reception of that song". The fact that Britney held the record previously has no impact upon the song itself - yet is there because it is extra information about the song and about the record - and for this reason if Britney is mentioned so would Burke. No Leona isn't on BOMT's page, but that has no holding on the issue; what I would see as a wrong on another page doesn't justify the continuation of a wrong on this one.
We can also look at the mention of John Landy on Roger Bannister's page - both Bannister's and Lewis' records were relatively significant and at the very least a mention of the record being broken is necessary and as such should be included." Sirrontail (talk) 22:32, 21 December 2008 (UTC)