1985 Timaru by-election

1985 Timaru by-election
Turnout	22,027 (89.99%)
Member before election; Sir Basil Arthur; Labour	Elected Member ; Maurice McTigue; National

The Timaru by-election of 1985 was a by-election for the electorate of Timaru during the term of the 40th New Zealand Parliament. It was triggered by the death of Sir Basil Arthur (who had held the seat since 1962) on 1 May 1985. Sir Basil was Speaker of the House, and had inherited the rank of baronet from his father in 1949.

The by-election was held on 15 June 1985 and was won by Maurice McTigue of the National Party with a majority of 1,492 votes.

Candidates

Labour

Ten candidates were nominated for the Labour Party nomination:^[1]

Doug Low, a trade unionist who was the chairman of the Timaru Trades Council
Peter Melhopt, a Timaru animal health officer with the Ministry of Agriculture
David Polson, an Oamaru lawyer who was Labour's 1984 candidate for Otago
Ian Quigley, a brewery manager and former MP for Otago Central
Lewis Rivers, a psychologist with the Department of Education
Ian Simmonds, a Timaru school teacher
Geoff Stone, a horticulturalist from Hinds who was Labour's 1984 candidate for Ashburton
Brian Tomlinson, Labour's 1984 candidate for Rangiora
Jan Walker, a Rotorua City Councillor and lawyer for the Maori Affairs Department
Bill Woods, Labour's candidate for Selwyn in 1978 and 1981

The selection meeting of around 220 party members was held. The selection committee of Helen Clark MP, Fred Anderson (party former executive), Tony Timms (general secretary), Alan Aldridge (electorate chairman), Roly Anderson (electorate vice-chairman), and Francis Griffin (electorate executive) deliberated for over four hours. They selected Walker as the candidate. She was the daughter of former Timaru City councillor and lawyer, Gordon Walker, and was chairman of the Labour Party's women's council as well as secretary of the Labour's Bay of Plenty Regional Council.^[2]

National

At least four men were nominated were nominated for the National Party candidacy. They were:^[3]

James Andrews, of Rangiora
Maurice McTigue, a Temuka farmer and National's 1984 Timaru candidate
Peter Miller, a Hamilton insurance company manager
Peter Paterson, the director of National's Otago-Southland division

McTigue was chosen via a ballot a selection meeting by party members.^[4]

New Zealand Party

The New Zealand Party had four candidates vying for selections.

Dr Bill Greenslade, Timaru surgeon
McGregor Simpson, a Geraldine food processor
Graham Ellery, a Geraldine freezing worker
Denise Ownsworth, a Timaru sales manager

Greenslade was selected by party members at a selection meeting.^[4]

Social Credit

Bruce Beetham, the leader of the Social Credit Party who had lost his seat of Rangitikei, was offered to stand in the seat. Beetham did not rule out standing, but inferred it unlikely and would do so only if Social Credit's previous candidate in the seat was unwilling to stand again.^[5] Lynley Simmons, a district commissioner of apprenticeships at the Department of Labour, was selected for the by-election. She had been Social Credit's candidate for Timaru in 1981 and 1984.^[6]

Others

The Values Party selected Jamie Luck, a schoolteacher, as their candidate. He was a founding member of the party and was its spokesman on international affairs.^[7] Alan Falloon, a geologist and former Labour Party member, stood for what he called a new Labour Party whose aim was to "create a type of trade union structure which truly represents the interests of the individual." Previously he had unsuccessfully sought Labour candidacy for Papanui and Christchurch Central. He was a distant relation to John Falloon, a National MP.^[8]

Campaign

David Lange recalled a meeting during the by-election campaign when Labour general secretary Tony Timms manhandled a noisy heckler out of the building. He said that the Labour candidate Jan Walker was a good lawyer (and was later a Family Court judge), but that the Labour Party organisation (i.e. head office) insisted on the selection of a candidate who "did not live in Timaru and her opinions, and even her appearance, were at odds with the conservative character of the electorate"; although Jim Anderton predictably (and publicly) blamed the defeat on "the government's abandonment of traditional Labour policy".^[9]

New Zealand Party founder Bob Jones (who had already achieved his primary goal of ending the Muldoon government) was disappointed by his party's performance in the by-election came to the decision to put the party into recess.

The by-election was the last time the Social Credit Party name was used before the party renamed itself as the Democratic Party later in the year.^[10]

Polling

Two polls were conducted by The Timaru Herald.^[11]

Poll	Date^{[nb 1]}	Maurice McTigue	Jan Walker	Bill Greenslade	Lynley Simmons
Poll	Date^{[nb 1]}
The Timaru Herald	30 May 1985	39.8	19.3	10.8	6.3
The Timaru Herald	13 June 1985	31.9	14.8	10.8	6.8

^ These are the survey dates of the poll, or if the survey dates are not stated, the date the poll was released.

Results

The following table gives the election results:

1985 Timaru by-election^[12]
Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±%
	National	Maurice McTigue	9,371	42.67	+4.22
	Labour	Jan Walker	7,879	35.88
	NZ Party	Bill Greenslade	2,998	13.65
	Social Credit	Lynley Simmons	1,628	7.41	+2.10
	Values	Jamie Luck	54	0.25
	Independent Labour	Alan Falloon	31	0.14
Majority			1,492	6.79
Informal votes			66	0.29
Turnout			22,027	89.99	−3.19
Registered electors			24,476
	National gain from Labour		Swing

References

^ "Ten seek Labour Party ticket". The Press. 14 May 1985. p. 1.
^ "Timaru by-election Labour's candidate woman solicitor". The Press. 17 May 1985. p. 2.
^ "Labour plans to woo women voters". The Press. 7 May 1985. p. 4.
^ ^a ^b Mein, Geoff (13 May 1985). "Surgeon and farmer candidates for Timaru". The Press. p. 1.
^ "Mr Beetham asked to stand for Timaru". The Press. 3 May 1985. p. 1.
^ "Candidate for Socred". The Press. 8 May 1985. p. 3.
^ "Values chooses teacher". The Press. 16 May 1985. p. 1.
^ "New party contests seat". The Press. 24 May 1985. p. 3.
^ David Lange (2005). My Life. Viking. ISBN 0-670-04556-X.
^ Calderwood, David (2010). Not a Fair Go: A History and Analysis of Social Credit's Struggle for Success in New Zealand's Electoral System (Thesis). University of Waikato. p. 123.
^ "Poll has Labour closing the gap". The Press. 13 June 1985. p. 2.
^ Norton 1988, p. 363.

Norton, Clifford (1988). New Zealand Parliamentary Election Results 1946–1987: Occasional Publications No 1, Department of Political Science. Wellington: Victoria University of Wellington. ISBN 0-475-11200-8.

[dates-12] These are the survey dates of the poll, or if the survey dates are not stated, the date the poll was released.

[1] "Ten seek Labour Party ticket". The Press. 14 May 1985. p. 1.

[2] "Timaru by-election Labour's candidate woman solicitor". The Press. 17 May 1985. p. 2.

[3] "Labour plans to woo women voters". The Press. 7 May 1985. p. 4.

[Nats_and_NZ-4] Mein, Geoff (13 May 1985). "Surgeon and farmer candidates for Timaru". The Press. p. 1.

[5] "Mr Beetham asked to stand for Timaru". The Press. 3 May 1985. p. 1.

[6] "Candidate for Socred". The Press. 8 May 1985. p. 3.

[7] "Values chooses teacher". The Press. 16 May 1985. p. 1.

[8] "New party contests seat". The Press. 24 May 1985. p. 3.

[9] David Lange (2005). My Life. Viking. ISBN 0-670-04556-X.

[10] Calderwood, David (2010). Not a Fair Go: A History and Analysis of Social Credit's Struggle for Success in New Zealand's Electoral System (Thesis). University of Waikato. p. 123.

[11] "Poll has Labour closing the gap". The Press. 13 June 1985. p. 2.

[FOOTNOTENorton1988363-13] Norton 1988, p. 363.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[nb 1]

[12]

v t e « (1912–1938) « By-elections in New Zealand in the two-party era (1939–1995) » (1996–present) »
26th Parliament	Christchurch South, 1939 Auckland West, 1940 Waipawa, 1940 Waitemata, 1941 Bay of Plenty, 1941 Mid-Canterbury, 1942 Temuka, 1942 Hauraki, 1942 Christchurch East, 1943 Northern Maori, 1943
27th Parliament	Awarua, 1944 Western Maori, 1945 Hamilton, 1945 Dunedin North, 1945 Raglan, 1946
28th Parliament	Avon, 1947 Mount Albert, 1947 Westland, 1947
29th Parliament	Brooklyn, 1951
30th Parliament	Dunedin North, 1953 Onehunga, 1953 Onslow, 1954 Patea, 1954
31st Parliament	Riccarton, 1956 Bay of Plenty, 1957
32nd Parliament	Hamilton, 1959
33rd Parliament	Hurunui, 1961 Waitaki, 1962 Buller, 1962 Timaru, 1962 Otahuhu, 1963 Northern Maori, 1963 Grey Lynn, 1963
34th Parliament	There were no by-elections during the term of the 34th Parliament.
35th Parliament	Southern Maori, 1967 Fendalton, 1967 Petone, 1967 Palmerston North, 1967 Eastern Maori, 1967 Hutt, 1968
36th Parliament	Marlborough, 1970
37th Parliament	Sydenham, 1974
38th Parliament	Nelson, 1976 Mangere, 1977 Pahiatua, 1977 Rangitikei, 1978
39th Parliament	Christchurch Central, 1979 Northern Maori, 1980 Onehunga, 1980 East Coast Bays, 1980
40th Parliament	There were no by-elections during the term of the 40th Parliament.
41st Parliament	Timaru, 1985
42nd Parliament	There were no by-elections during the term of the 42nd Parliament.
43rd Parliament	Tamaki, 1992 Wellington Central, 1992 Tauranga, 1993
44th Parliament	Selwyn, 1994