Tiffany Problem

The Tiffany Problem, or Tiffany Effect, refers to the issue where a historical or realistic fact seems anachronistic or unrealistic to modern audiences of historical fiction, despite being accurate. This often occurs with names, terms, or practices that, although historically accurate, feel out of place because of modern associations.^[1]

Origin of the term

Author Nicola Cornick first discussed the Tiffany Effect in 2018 after learning about the phenomenon and encountering the term. She explained that the name Tiffany derives from Theophania, a name for girls in medieval England and France. The old French form c. 1200 was Tifinie, and the spelling Tiffany first appears in English c. 1600.^[2] However, if a historical fiction writer were to name an English character Tiffany in an Early Modern European setting as early as 1600, the audience would likely perceive it as inaccurate, associating the name with contemporary times or the 1980s in particular when the name reached peak popularity.^[3] Fellow author Jo Walton coined the term Tiffany Problem in 2019 to refer to this phenomenon.^[4]

Examples

Names

Like the name Tiffany, the following names have been mistakenly thought to be of modern origin but are actually historical:

Shane, which dates back to the 17th century as a masculine name derived from Gaelic
Beverly, which originated from the term "beaver meadow" and has historical usage
Wade, which is rooted in Early English and was popular in the medieval period
Nicola, which was historically used as a male name in Italy and was borne by notable figures like the 12th-century Nicola de la Haye^[2]

Others

The first known vending machine, created in the 1st century A.D. by Hero of Alexandria, dispensed holy water. This invention predates the modern concept of vending machines by nearly 2,000 years, making it seem anachronistic in ancient history.^[5]

Another example is the hoodie in the form of a woolen or cotton pullover with a hood; although most people likely believe it to be a late 20th century garment, its existence dates back to the 18th century. Some forms of it can be traced back to before the 7th century (hoods cloak).^{[citation needed]}

European royalty would have worn silk until the 10th century at least. The Silk Road connected China with Europe as early as the first century BC, making silk garments and textiles a fixture of the elite for many hundreds of years.^[6]

The oldest recognizably modern postal service (using riders and coaches) can be traced back to the first century in Rome (cursus publicus), and these systems existed at least until the 6th century with some breaks in the 3rd century, continuing in some parts of Europe, on and off, until the 18th century (Kaiserliche Reichspost).^{[citation needed]}

References

^ Lingen, Marissa (2019-03-05). "That Never Happened: Misplaced Skepticism and the Mechanisms of Suspension of Disbelief". Uncanny Magazine. No. 27. p. 120.
^ ^a ^b Cornick, Nicola (2018-04-23). "The Tiffany Effect". Word Wenches. Retrieved 2024-08-16.
^ Pendergraft, Nat (May 2023). The Gray Area: Sexuality and Gender in Wartime Reevaluated (Master of Arts thesis). Orange, CA: Chapman University. pp. 6–7. doi:10.36837/chapman.000476.
^ Russo, Stephanie (2023-12-01). The Anachronistic Turn: Historical Fiction, Drama, Film and Television. Taylor & Francis. p. 41. ISBN 978-1-003-81434-4.
^ Franco, Samantha (2022-04-08). "The Tiffany Problem: 6 Historical Oddities That Don't Seem To Make Sense". The Vintage News. Retrieved 2024-08-16.
^ Wagner, Stephen (2016-09-14). "The Impact of Silk in the Middle Ages". Textile Society of America.