The staff ate it later
.jpg)
"The staff ate it later" is a caption shown on screen when food appears on a Japanese TV program. This indicates that the dish or ingredients were eaten and not thrown away; however, some question the authenticity of this statement, and others believe this caption lowers the quality of TV programs.
First appearance
[edit]It is thought TV stations first began showing the caption to protect themselves against complaints from viewers who disliked food being handled without consideration in TV variety shows.[1] It is uncertain when this note was first used, but TV producer Kenji Suga stated viewers complained about the waste of food when a performance using small watermelons was broadcast in Downtown no Gaki no Tsukai ya Arahende!! on Nippon TV. The TV station then showed this note on screen the following year in response.[2]
Authenticity
[edit]There are various claims as to whether or not staff actually eat the food that appears in the programs.[1][3][4]
Supporting Reports
[edit]According to AOL News in 2014, the crew on one information program testified that "It's sometimes impossible for the reporter to eat all the food provided by the restaurant. The reporter is told not to eat it all, but the crew will eat the rest out of consideration and a feeling of obligation towards the restaurant."[4]
Food comic artist Raswell Hosoki claimed in "Meshizanmai Hurusatonoaji" (Meshizanmai Taste of Hometown), that the note is true. Eriko Miyazaki, a reporter and TV personality for food shows, also claims the note is true and has stated, "The crew eats the rest of the food, at least at the shows I appear in."[5]
In January 2018, Miwa Asao, former professional beach volleyball player and TV personality, posted photos on her blog of staff eating food after recording "Saturday Night! Otona na TV" (TVQ Kyushu Broadcasting). She wrote "This is an on-site photo. The staff ate the rest of the food."[6][7][8]
Refuting Reports
[edit]Hitoshi Matsumoto, a comedian and TV host, was asked by sociologist Noritoshi Furuichi about this note in 2014 during the "Wide na Show" (Fuji Television). He said, "To be honest, I've never seen the crew eat the food. But that just means I haven't seen it. They might've eaten it."[9]
Beat Takeshi (also known as Takeshi Kitano), Japanese comedian, television presenter, actor, filmmaker, and author, referred to an instance where cake was smeared on the floor and said, "Liars. Who's going to enjoy cake they splattered all over the floor?" in his book Bakaron.[3] Commentator Tsunehira Furuya also stated that the food featured in the show is not eaten by the staff later and is instead simply thrown into garbage bags.[1]
Reception
[edit]Commentator Tetsuya Uetaki has commented on displaying the note, saying, "Producers have become more aware as viewers have become more critical after issues such as the Aru Aru Mondai (a natto shortage caused by a program claiming eating natto would make people lose weight), and it's fine as one method for dealing with that." However, Uetaki went on to say, "This shifts responsibility onto the viewers. We can't let it end as simply an empty concession. I want to see variety shows strive to properly handle information and properly put the show together, from the moment they start building it."[10]
Broadcast writer Sotani commented on the fact that production teams have become more sensitive to this in programs and have begun displaying such notes as an attempt to preempt pointless criticism. He claims this sort of extreme self regulation risks leading to a decline.[11] TV producer Kenji Suga claims it is necessary for programs to be disconnected from real life and society, to be "dumb and idiotic" to produce laughs, in the same way he used to get told my his mother that he shouldn't do what he saw on the comedic variety shows he watched as a child, and that harsh restrictions take away shows' humor.[2]
Columnist Takashi Matsuo argues that adults, not TV shows, should teach children the ethics surrounding the importance of food. He also argues that if a parent is uncomfortable with what a comedian expresses on TV, the right course of action would be to change the channel or turn off the TV, not send a complaint to the TV station.[12] Matsuo also points out the inconsistency that "the staff ate it later" caption is not displayed when large numbers of tomatoes are thrown at the festival of Tomatina in Spain or when athletes spray each other with champagne in celebration of a victory.[12]
Footnote
[edit]References
[edit]- ^ a b c Tsunehira Furuya (2017) "Dotoku Jikeidan" ga Nippon wo Horobosu, East Press, East Shinsho, ISBN 978-4-7816-5095-1
- ^ a b Cite from Asahi Shimbun, (2016), Tokyo Morning Newspaper, P-6
- ^ a b Beat Takeshi (2017) Bakaron, Shinchosha, Shinchoshinsho, ISBN 978-4-10-610737-5
- ^ a b Is the staff really eating the rest of the dishes used in the TV show?, AOL News, Oath, (2014). Retrieved 9 January
- ^ Raswell Hosoki, Mayumi Kato, Takako Aonuma, Sachiko Orihara, Junko Kubota, Eiko Kasai, Riyo Mizuki, Takotsumuri, Usami☆, and Somei Yoshino, (2017) Meshizanmai Hurusatonoaji, Bunkasha, BUNKASHA COMICS, ISBN 978-4-8211-3416-8
- ^ From Miwa Asao's official blog "Yesterday ...". Retrieved 26 December 2020
- ^ Miwa Asao releases photos of the staff eating the rest of the dishes., Ameba News, CyberAgent, （2018）、Retrieved 26 December 2020.
- ^ How many precautionary annotations are needed?, Oricon News, Oricon, (2018). Retrieved 26 December 2020
- ^ Hitoshi Matsumoto confesses his anguish on a variety show., Real Live, Naigai Times Sha, (2014). Retrieved 26 December 2020
- ^ Cite from Chunichi Shimbun, Chunichi Shimbunsha, (2007), Morning Newspaper, P-15
- ^ Cite from Hokkoku Shimbun, The HOKKOKU SHIMBUN, (2012), Morning Newspaper, P-36
- ^ a b Takasi Matsuo, Is over-annotation on television a self-protection to escape complaints?, Digital Mainichi, The Mainichi Newspaper Co., Ltd., (2017). Retrieved 26 December