The Idiot (song)

"The Idiot" is a song written by Stan Rogers, found on his albums Northwest Passage and Home in Halifax. On Home in Halifax, Rogers introduces the song by explaining that it is about the movement of people away from the Atlantic Provinces of Canada to the province of Alberta for work. The introduction also states that the song contains the "knuckle-dragging" beat characteristic of Morris dance tunes.

Story

The song's narrator recounts how he moved to Alberta six years earlier. Many factories in his home province had closed, employment was scarce, and he did not want to go on unemployment because he "take[s] nothing free." Instead, he moved west and took a job in a refinery. He finds his new city unpleasantly dirty and he misses his old hometown, but he respects himself for making his own living and not having to rely on social assistance. He urges other young men from the Eastern provinces "who've been beaten to the ground" to follow his example, saying that they will probably miss their hometowns, as he does, but they will have "self-respect and a steady cheque" rather than the "government dole" that will "rot [their] souls."

The song however ends on a melancholy note in Seth Staton Watkins's version, where the narrator reflects that this is just a story that he tells himself when he misses home. "I tell myself I'm doing right" the narrator states while reflecting that he is not free even here in the last line of the song, "Why can't I just be free".

Recordings

Song

• Stan Rogers on Northwest Passage (1981) and Home in Halifax (1993)
• Seth Staton Watkins on his 2022 album Working Folk, with an additional verse.

Tune

The “knuckle-dragging rhythm” of the tune, so described by its author on Home in Halifax, has inspired many, primarily Cotswold, Morris teams to write dances to the tune. Some examples are:

• Merrimac Morris (New Hampshire, USA) wrote a dance to be danced to the tune of "The Idiot", in the Field Town style of morris dance, in 1986.
• Uptown-on-Calhoun Morris of Minneapolis does a dance to the tune of "The Idiot".
• The Bassett Street Hounds morris team of Syracuse, N.Y. have written a dance called "The Drunken Idiot", performed to the same tune but with alternative words written by Jon Berger.
• Maple Morris wrote a big morris to the tune, seen performing it at the Sidmouth Folk Week in 2011.
• Corb Lund used the tune of the song for his song "I Wanna Be in the Cavalry" on the 2007 album Horse Soldier! Horse Soldier!.