Template talk:English gender-neutral pronouns
Appearance
New template to link all the gender-neutral pronouns. —Quarl (talk) 2006-01-24 14:20Z
- Since the VfD decision on sie and hir means that they've all had to be redirected to gender-neutral pronoun, this should probably go. Martin 21:23, 1 January 2007 (UTC)
- I've redirected all the Neologisms to Gender-neutral pronoun#Neologisms as per the Sie and hir decision.
- I've also added She and It as gender neutral pronouns.
- Gender neutral she is very common in American academic writing. I've been encountering it for years while reading journal articles in philosophy, for example.
- However, as an Australian, I'm aware of a usage of she with a much longer history in colloquial speech -- "She's a beauty!" This has nothing to do with sex, gender or even animate or personal. She's a beauty and many very common and similar expressions can be applied to gold nuggets, cricket balls, the weather, houses, cars... In fact, a very Australian response to "How do you do?" is to take it literally, and reply you are as well as it is possible to be -- She's a beauty! Ergo, she is a gender neutral pronoun, in some of her usages. ;)
- Gender neutral it raises the implicit assumption that we are talking of personal third person forms, which would normally rule it out (sorry about that one). However, Is it a boy or a girl? is a question that has been asked on at least number-of-native-English-speakers times circa-half-a-dozen occasions. Surely this is enough to demonstrate that it too has a fine tradition of gender-neutral usage.
- I will include these in the relevant articles, so the justification for their existence on the template is explicit to readers. G'day to y'all! Alastair Haines 05:05, 15 April 2007 (UTC)
Update with xeno/neopronouns
[edit]Should we update with xenopronouns and neopronouns? Nithin🚀 talk 04:15, 2 June 2021 (UTC)