Template:Donegal All Stars record

Donegal has 34 All Stars, as of 2019. 22 different players have won, as of 2019. No player has won more than four All Stars.   denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.

1972: Brian McEniff
1974: Donal Monaghan
1983: Martin McHugh
1990: Joyce McMullin
1992: Gary Walsh, Matt Gallagher, Martin Gavigan, Anthony Molloy, Martin McHugh^2nd, James McHugh, Tony Boyle
1993: John Joe Doherty
2002: Kevin Cassidy
2003: Adrian Sweeney
2006: Karl Lacey
2009: Karl Lacey^2nd
2011: Karl Lacey^3rd, Kevin Cassidy^2nd, Neil McGee
2012: Paul Durcan, Neil McGee^2nd,  Karl Lacey ^4th, Frank McGlynn, Neil Gallagher, Mark McHugh, Michael Murphy, Colm McFadden
2014: Paul Durcan^2nd, Neil McGee^3rd, Neil Gallagher^2nd, Michael Murphy^2nd
2016: Ryan McHugh
2018: Ryan McHugh^2nd
2019: Michael Murphy^3rd