Jump to content

Template:Did you know nominations/American Peace Crusade

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The following discussion is an archived discussion of the DYK nomination of the article below. Please do not modify this page. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as this nomination's talk page, the article's talk page or Wikipedia talk:Did you know), unless there is consensus to re-open the discussion at this page. No further edits should be made to this page.

The result was: rejected by Crisco 1492 (talk) 11:35, 26 March 2012 (UTC)
Completeness (or a lack of it)

American Peace Crusade

[edit]
(
)

Created/expanded by SupernovaExplosion (talk). Self nom at 09:28, 29 February 2012 (UTC)

  • Length and date check out, article is well sourced, and hook is supported by references. Benea (talk) 19:53, 2 March 2012 (UTC)

I'm concerned that some of the structure and phrasing used by this article may be too close to that used by FNs 4 and 5. Nikkimaria (talk) 20:57, 5 March 2012 (UTC)

Thank you for your review. I have fixed the close paraphrasing concern. Hope it is ok now. --SupernovaExplosion Talk 15:21, 6 March 2012 (UTC)
  • I've spent some "quality time" with this article. I am concerned that the source for the hook fact -- and, indeed, for the entire thesis that this was a Communist-headed or Communist-led organization, is unacceptably weak. The source is a credible book, but that book mentions the organization in a single sentence, almost in passing: "America's last Communist-led peace group, the American Peace Crusade, expired in 1956." It is clear from various sources that J. Edgar Hoover's FBI and the HUAC committee in Congress were sure that the APC was a Communist front organization. Additionally, modern scholarly sources describe it as including or being influenced by Communists and fellow travelers, and I think it is reasonable to think that it was financed by Communists (although I've not yet seen a statement to that effect), but sources emphasize that groups like this one consisted largely of people who were sincere supporters of peace. Before Wikipedia emphasizes that this group was "Communist-headed" or "Communist-led", I'd want to see a more solid basis than that almost offhand mention in one book. I expect to continue to pursue this matter. --Orlady (talk) 18:25, 9 March 2012 (UTC)
  • I have addressed your concerns and made appropriate changes. Here is an alternate hook:
  • Time for a re-review? --PFHLai (talk) 11:13, 22 March 2012 (UTC)
  • OK, I'll stick my neck out and say that the article is a poor piece of historical research that does not deserve to be featured on the main page. It is based almost entirely on pulling statements from sources without providing relevant context (context that sometimes would have been available by reading more than one paragraph of a cited source). I infer that the article creator is too young to have much awareness of HUAC, McCarthyism, W.E.B. DuBois, and other topics relevant to this article -- and has not investigated them as historical topics. --Orlady (talk) 13:22, 22 March 2012 (UTC)
  • Holy cow? True I've added characterizations by experts, but how does that constitute "pulling statements from sources without providing relevant context"? I've added all the significant sources available in google books. You can't dismiss an article because you believe some more information need to be added, it is not a criteria for DYK. --SupernovaExplosion Talk 17:52, 23 March 2012 (UTC)
  • ALT hook
  • I have just read this article and am in full agreement with Orlady's rejection of it. It is exactly as she described it, a bunch of comments, essentially repetitions, and no context for why this is a problem or what "pro-Soviet" or "Communist-led" means. Here is a typical sentence: American Peace Crusade is variously characterized as "Communist-led peace group", "pro-Soviet peace initiative", etc. (with a ref after each quote). The sentence reads like two smears followed by "etc." No, this does not belong on the main page, even though I have just removed "variously" and the "etc." Marrante (talk) 22:42, 23 March 2012 (UTC)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Template:Did_you_know_nominations/American_Peace_Crusade&oldid=1189646181"