Jump to content

Talk:Zuby Nehty

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Citations

[edit]

Just to clarify - Citations as given:

1. They formed under the name Plyn in 1979 links to a citation that links to a commercial website that sells articles (There is a $2.95 fee to view the full-text of any article) therefore can not be verified. (Thusly it is being removed). The full text of what you can freely reads does not even mention the band. (She can still remember Sundays at the park. The kids would gather there, surreptitiously trading rock 'n' roll records or buying them at black market prices. They would look over their shoulders, afraid of a police raid. They had all heard stories about public record burnings. From its inception, rock 'n' roll has been the music of defiance and rebellion, a primitive shout of freedom. But this was Czechoslovakia in the late 1970s, and )

2. released their first EP as Dybbuk links to citation containing an article about a live event and contains a very brief mention of Zuby Nehty: The alternative/indie jewel in the crown Zuby nehty will be turning heads with its self-described "bewitching and exuberant post-punk," featuring local hero Pavla Jónssonová, one of the founding members of Dybbuk, the essential all-woman Czech punk band. It does not say that Zuby Nehty had been named "Dybbuk", it says that Pavla Jónssonová was a founding member of "Dybbuk". There is also no mention of any recording.

3. Pavla Jonssonová has taught and researched gender studies is not a comment about the the subject of this article and links to a citation that links to an article about an event "at Stromovka park's Šlechtovka beer garden". It goes on to say the events attendance is "100 to 200 people most years." The relevant text says, in full: Also rocking distaff is The Pani Pavlova Band, the latest project of feminist professor, poet and ex-punk Pavla Jonssonová, formerly of the seminal Zuby nehty (and wife of fest founder Jónsson).

These citations would not qualify as "multiple non-trivial published works". As I had said in the prod, "This article lacks citations and links are to a fan site" in order to prove this band in notable and thusly may be non-notable. The three citations that were added after the prod was removed do not make the band seem any more notable. However they do seem to insinuate that Pavla Jónssonová might be notable enough to have her own article. So if an Editor can provide more criteria to meet the Wikipedia:Notability_(music) guidelines perhaps the article should redirect to an article about Pavla Jónssonová. Soundvisions1 (talk) 15:32, 13 October 2008 (UTC)[reply]