Talk:Waiting (2015 film)/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Carbrera (talk · contribs) 20:52, 28 June 2016 (UTC)

Infobox

• The official movie poster requires an alt description in the "alt" parameter, so please add one

Done

• "27 May 2016" --> What release was this? Worldwide? US? etc.?

Added

• Is there any information available regarding the "budget" parameter?

Nothing available.

Lead

• Fantastic! Nothing to add here

Plot

• Nada! Not too long either!

Cast

• No sources

They are all verified in the production section.

Production

Development and casting

• Please add the year that London, Paris, New York was released in, in parentheses after the movie's title (in this case, (2012).)

Added

• "South Indian actress Suhasini Maniratnam made her debut in Hindi cinema; she plays the role of Shah's character's wife in the film." --> "South Indian actress Suhasini Maniratnam made her debut in Hindi cinema, where she plays the role of Shah's character's wife."

Fixed

Soundtrack and reception

• "The first song of the album Tu Hai Toh Main Hoon was released on YouTube on 4 May 2016.[20]" --> "The first song of the album "Tu Hai Toh Main Hoon" was released on YouTube on 4 May 2016.[20]" (Italicize --> Quotation marks)
• "The first song video song Tu Hai Toh Main Hoon was released to positive response from critics and audiences.[20]" --> "The first music video for the song "Tu Hai Toh Main Hoon" was released to positive response from critics and audiences.[20]" (Italicize --> Quotation marks; plus slight rewording)
• "The second song Zara Zara was released on 12 May, and RadioMusic.com deemed it "worth falling in love all over again".[21]" --> "The second song "Zara Zara" was released on 12 May, and RadioMusic.com deemed it "worth falling in love all over again".[21]" (Italicize --> Quotation marks)
• "Manavi Kapoor of Business Standard in her review wrote, ""Zara zara" and "Tu hai toh main hun" are haunting and perfectly capture the poignant tone of the film."[22]" --> "Manavi Kapoor of Business Standard in her review wrote, ""Zara Zara" and "Tu Hai Toh Main Hun" are haunting and perfectly capture the poignant tone of the film."[22]" (Capitalization fixes)

Fixed all.

Release

Marketing and Release

• Please switch section title to "Marketing and release"

Done

• "t the release of the film executive producer Priti Gupta founder of Ishka Films said, "It is an endearing and beautiful movie for not just Indian, but the world audience, as it is essentially about the universal human circumstances, which are deftly portrayed in a tender yet humorous way."[24]" --> "It the release of the film executive producer Priti Gupta founder of Ishka Films said, "It is an endearing and beautiful movie for not just Indian[s], but the world audience, as it is essentially about the universal human circumstances, which are deftly portrayed in a tender yet humorous way."[24]"

Fixed

Box office

• "However, ‘'Waiting’' showed good growth over the day with the best occupancy among the aforementioned films.[36]" --> "However, Waiting showed good growth over the day with the best occupancy among the aforementioned films.[36]" (Switch to italics here please.)

Fixed

Reception

India

• "The performances of the leading pair of Koechlin and Shah were chiefly praised by several critics." --> No source; the following statements do not discuss this.

The following review do discuss the performances of the two.

Overseas

• Great work again!! :)

Accolades

• Great!

End of GA Review:

Thanks for giving me the heads-up with the review! I'm glad I got this chance! On hold for seven days to allow for any changes! Thanks so much! Cheers, Carbrera (talk) 19:13, 29 June 2016 (UTC).

@Carbrera:Thank you for your comments and words of appreciation. I have fixed/replied to all of them. I really appreciate you taking up the review. NumerounovedantTalk 21:04, 29 June 2016 (UTC)