Jump to content

Talk:U.S. Route 20 in Indiana

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Good articleU.S. Route 20 in Indiana has been listed as one of the Engineering and technology good articles under the good article criteria. If you can improve it further, please do so. If it no longer meets these criteria, you can reassess it.
Article milestones
DateProcessResult
July 31, 2011Good article nomineeNot listed
February 24, 2012Good article nomineeListed
Current status: Good article

Several fixes needed yet

[edit]
  1. The article title is wrong. It should be U.S. Route 20 in Indiana. Once I can get that redirect deleted, I will move it.
  2. The major junctions table should be done West -> East, and it's missing counties.
  3. Actually, all content in the article needs to be West -> East, including the infobox (which is missing a county list) and the Route description section when added.
  4. There is content from the separate US Route 20 in Indiana that needs to be merged into this article, and THAT article needs to be redirected to the correct title.
  5. The whole article as it stands needs a cleanup and expansion to comply with WP:USRD standards.

If you have any questions, feel free to ask me! Imzadi1979 (talk) 22:31, 3 December 2008 (UTC)[reply]

GA Review

[edit]
GA toolbox
Reviewing
This review is transcluded from Talk:U.S. Route 20 in Indiana/GA1. The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.

Reviewer: Rschen7754 19:45, 24 June 2011 (UTC)[reply]

GA review (see here for what the criteria are, and here for what they are not)
  1. It is reasonably well written.
    a (prose): b (MoS for lead, layout, word choice, fiction, and lists):
    Prose needs improvement.
  2. It is factually accurate and verifiable.
    a (references): b (citations to reliable sources): c (OR):
  3. It is broad in its coverage.
    a (major aspects): b (focused):
  4. It follows the neutral point of view policy.
    Fair representation without bias:
  5. It is stable.
    No edit wars, etc.:
  6. It is illustrated by images, where possible and appropriate.
    a (images are tagged and non-free images have fair use rationales): b (appropriate use with suitable captions):
  7. Overall:
    Pass/Fail:
Lead
  • The lead is too short. It needs to be at least another paragraph, and cover the content of the whole article. See WP:LEAD for details.
    • Better, but the second paragraph has no links, and there are grammar issues.
    • The first complete section of the parkway being called "Bypass US 20". - fragment
    • Other small realignment included the route through Michigan City, which followed US 35 from US 12 to I-94. - realignments?
    • A small realignment in LaGrange County was done in 2005, in which the roadway was straight. - straightened? Rschen7754 20:38, 25 June 2011 (UTC)[reply]
  • US 20 though Gary, East Chicago, and Whiting, Indiana, US 20 varies between one-way streets, two-lane streets, four-lane streets, and same part with US 12 are even more lanes. - bad sentence structure
  • Then east of Gary to Michigan City US 20 is a two-lane highway. From Michigan City to west of South Bend US 20 is a four-lane undivided highway and two-lane rural highway. - commas would help with readability
  • US 20 bypasses around the west and south sides of South Bend and Elkhart. - bypasses around is not a good construction.
  • Please go through and add commas where necessary- it's definitely making things harder to read.
Route description
  • You don't need subsections for every single paragraph.
  • Please go through and add commas where necessary- it's definitely making things harder to read.
  • Replace Ave. with Avenue.
  • From Bridge Street to Vermont Street eastbound traffic of US 12/US 20 are on 5th Ave. and westbound traffic is on 4th Ave. - subject/verb agreement.
  • After US 35, US 20 is four-lane undivided highway until Rolling Prairie, passing State Road 39 at Springville. - is a four-lane undivided highway?
  • Section 1.4 - you keep using the same words over and over again to start sentences.
  • Then US 20 has an interchange with US 33 near Dunlap.. - really choppy (try US 20 then?), also, you've got 2 periods.
  • US 20 heads east from Elkhart, passes through or near Middlebury at State Road 13, Shipshewana at State Road 5, Lagrange at State Road 9, and Angola at Interstate 69. - run-on
    • Better, but "Passing through an intersection with SR 15 south of Bristol." is not a complete sentence. Every sentence needs to have a subject and a verb. Furthermore, English has some rules regarding dependent clauses and gerunds that influence whether a sentence is complete.
  • St. Joseph Valley Parkway is linked twice; it should only be linked once. --Rschen7754 06:48, 27 June 2011 (UTC)[reply]
  • This intersection is a four-lane undivided highway, then soon after the intersection US 20 becomes a two-lane highway. - run-on sentence. Rschen7754 20:38, 25 June 2011 (UTC)[reply]
  • Soon after the interchange with Old US 20 is an interchange with CR&nsp;17.
  • Just west of Ohio State Line US 20 passes under the Indiana Toll Road (I-80/I-90). - Just west of the Ohio state line?
  • US 20 passes through is intersection as a four-lane divided highway, then soon after the intersection US 20 becomes a two-lane highway.
    • Still not fixed.
  • Then soon after the intersection US 20 becomes a two-lane highway. - Bad to start a sentence with "Then".
  • On th south side of Middlebury US 20 has an intersection with SR 13.
  • On the way th Lagrange US 20 passes through an intersection with SR 5 just south of Shipshewana.
  • This section of US 20 is two lanes, undivided highway. - is a two-lane undivided highway?
  • With small sections near the intersection with SR 15 and SR 13 having four-lanes divided highway. - fragment
  • US 20 then enters downtown Angola, passing through a roundabout with SR 127 and Old US 27]].
History
  • The first paragraph is entirely unsourced.
  • Illinois State Line - should be "the Illinois state line." State lines are not proper nouns. Please go through and correct.
  • "Until the 1998," - Until 1998?
  • In 2005 a series of sharp curves around Rainbow Lake were removed, the curves were located six miles west of Lagrange - run-on, you can't just randomly combine sentences like that.
  • I'm against long quotes like that; WP:NOT a quote repository - that's Wikisource.
  • I don't get how the Dunes Highway relates to US 20.
Future
  • Plans to make US 20 a four-lane highway from the east end of the St. Joseph Valley Parkway to SR 13. - fragment
Overall sourcing
  • You only cite maps and DOT/FHWA sources here - which is fine for GA class, but will cause problems in higher venues. Just a warning.
  • Source 12 should really be 2 citations.

Placing article on hold - the prose needs cleanup, and the history needs sourcing. --Rschen7754 20:18, 24 June 2011 (UTC)[reply]

  • Made notes above. Some of the issues above were not addressed. I do agree with some of Imzadi1979's comments below, and it probably is beneficial to incorporate some of his suggestions if you want to take this article further; however, some of them are beyond the GA criteria, and the decision to pass the article remains up to me, the initial reviewer. --Rschen7754 20:54, 25 June 2011 (UTC)[reply]
Comments from Imzadi1979
  • I don't think that the History section is very complete. There is a major issue there: footnote 1 is a link to a page on I-69 in Indiana from INDOT, and has nothing to do with US 20 at all. That means that this History section is still unsourced.
  • Honestly, I think the history section is probably only a third or a quarter of the size it should be to cover the historical information about the highway that should exist. It should be cited to historical maps or newspaper articles to detail these changes unless INDOT has some sort of archive of historical documentation on the roadway.
  • Can we get the locations (townships, I assume) for the two blank spots in the junction list?
  • "9.63-10.01" that should have an en dash (–) instead of a hyphen to correctly match the other similar entries.
  • Can we have consistent date formats in the references?
  • Can we have consistent usage of abbreviations in the prose of the article. In general, it's a good practice to give the full name of a highway by type the first time it's used, and then abbreviate all other highways of that type thereafter. Since US 20's abbreviation is given in the first sentence of the lead, all other US Highways should be abbreviated on all uses. Give the first mentioned State Road's name in full with the abbreviation in parentheses afterwards, and then abbreviate the rest of them. Same for the Interstate Highways and County Roads.
  • "Only the segment of US 20 that is concurrent with the St. Joseph Valley Parkway are included as a part of the National Highway System (NHS)." This sentence needs the citation. "The NHS is a network of highways that are identified as being most important for the economy, mobility and defense of the nation." needs a separate citation; that map does not back that statement.
  • The See also section could use the {{portal|Indiana|U.S. Roads}} box added.

Imzadi 1979 → 00:02, 25 June 2011 (UTC)[reply]

Replies to Both Rschen7754 and Imzadi1979
  • Foot note number one was linking to I-69. This was due to INDOT changing the website on late Thursday PM or Friday sometime. The old page was the mile log, the foot note number one is now linking to the mile log in PDF format on INDOT's website.
  • Added more to the history section.
  • Added more references, the new references are not maps.
  • In the route description removed the five sections, now having only two sections.
  • Reworded the old section 1.4.
  • Reworded some of the old section 1.5.

Your comments should be resolved. Detcin (talk) 15:37, 25 June 2011 (UTC)[reply]

More comments from Imzadi1979
  • What's all that stuff about the Dunes Highway doing in here? You've missed my point completely.
    • Rather than have the 85-year history of US 20 in Indiana detailed, the previous article had just a paragraph that laid out a few details without explaining them fully.
    • There is still an entire paragraph of the History that has no citations at all, yet has details that should be cited.
    • There is still a gap in time in the History from the 1930s (note, decades don't get the apostrophe. 1930's is possessive form) to the 1970s. Are you saying that US 20 was not changed at all for 40 years, even though the Toll Road and other Interstate Highways were built during that time frame?
  • That Dunes Highway stuff increased the length of the History, yes, but it's also problematic for other reasons
    • WP:UNDUE: is that not undue weight to focus so much of the History on one section in the northwest of the state when US 20 is so much longer and traverses the full width of the state?
    • I seriously think that the section was just copy-pasted into this article without much attempt to integrate it. Case in point, the footnotes from that section don't match the footnote style from the rest of the article.
  • Footnotes 1 and 4 still don't have access dates. While they aren't strictly required, it helps others in case the links go dead or get changed in the future.
  • Date formatting in the citations is still inconsistent. I would suggest reformatting all of the ISO-style dates (i.e. 2011-05-02) as American standard format dates (i.e. May 2, 2011) for both consistency and reader readability.
  • Footnote 4 should have its publication date added (December 17, 2007).

Imzadi 1979 → 18:54, 25 June 2011 (UTC)[reply]

Replies to Rschen7754
  • Cited the paragraph of the History that had no citations at all.
  • US 20 was concurrent with US 12 from the Illinois state line to Michigan City and US 12 is the Dunes Highway. Until US 20 was reroute farther away from Lake Michigan, the alignment it takes today.
  • Reworded the area around South Bend and Elkhart.
  • Fixed the typos
  • Added links to the lead

Your comments should be resolved. Detcin (talk) 01:47, 27 June 2011 (UTC)[reply]

Detcin, do you plan on making the above changes soon? --Rschen7754 20:17, 15 July 2011 (UTC)[reply]

Rschen7754, I believe the above changes have beed resolved.Detcin (talk) 01:32, 31 July 2011 (UTC)[reply]

Not to step on any toes, but there are several errors in the references used. From the footnote I used on U.S. Route 131 (footnote e): "The Indiana State Highway Commission, later the Indiana Department of Highways, was merged into the Indiana Department of Transportation in 1989." which is cited to footnote 56 (updated after and INDOT website revamp): Staff. "Facts & Photos". Indiana Department of Transportation. Retrieved July 30, 2011. Imzadi 1979 → 02:04, 31 July 2011 (UTC)[reply]
Noted, I'll start working on this again over the next few days. --Rschen7754 08:12, 31 July 2011 (UTC)[reply]

Failing article - nominator frequently states that all comments have been resolved, when clearly they haven't, and no attempt was made to resolve some of the comments. This article *still* needs a thorough copyedit and it's clear that the nominator is not capable of doing so. The history section is still a mess. It's not our responsibility at GAN to rewrite the article, and there are entire sections that may have to be. We are happy to help you with this article, but GAN isn't the place for the extensive work that is still needed. --Rschen7754 21:36, 31 July 2011 (UTC)[reply]

GA Review

[edit]
GA toolbox
Reviewing
This review is transcluded from Talk:U.S. Route 20 in Indiana/GA2. The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.

Reviewer: Dough4872 (talk · contribs) 16:35, 18 February 2012 (UTC)[reply]

GA review (see here for criteria)
  1. It is reasonably well written.
    a (prose): b (MoS):
    • In the lead, you use "two-lane rural highway" twice. Can one instance be reworded?
    • The sentence "US 20 enters Indiana with US 12 and US 41, underneath the Indiana Toll Road." sounds awkward.
    • In the first paragraph of the Route description you begin two consecutive sentences with "After". Can one of them be changed?
    • "On the east side of Michigan City US 20 has an interchange with SR 212. Soon after SR 212, US 20 has an interchange with I-94 followed by an intersection with the northern terminus of US 35." Reword one of the instances of "has an interchange".
    • More use of "has an interchange" and "has an intersection" in route description. Can you try to vary the wording?
    • Also a lot of uses of "passes through".
    • You use "US 20" in almost every sentence of the route description. Can you try changing some instances to other words such as "the road" or "the route"?
    • The sentences "US 20 was part of the first alignment of the Lincoln Highway in 1913. From current SR 2 in Rolling Prairie to Elkhart, where the Lincoln Highway turned southeast on to current US 33." should be combined.
    • "One important project was the 1900 to 1910 macadamizing of part of the Old Chicago Road, Northwest Indiana's major auto route between Gary and Michigan City before the Dunes Highway.", try to paraphrase this quote.
    • Can the Dunes Highway information be integrated in the beginning of the history as to describe the route in chronological order?
  2. It is factually accurate and verifiable.
    a (references): b (citations to reliable sources): c (OR):
  3. It is broad in its coverage.
    a (major aspects): b (focused):
    • Perhaps mention when US 20 was first designated in lead and when segments of the road were first built.
    • Can some more details about the physical surroundings be added to the route description? For instance, in Northwest Indiana does it pass through residential, commercial, or industrial areas? In the rural areas, does it pass through farmland or woodland? Can some attractions along the route be mentioned?
    • Is there any history of the road from before the Lincoln Highway?
    • Any dates for the future plans of US 20?
  4. It follows the neutral point of view policy.
    Fair representation without bias:
  5. It is stable.
    No edit wars, etc.:
  6. It is illustrated by images, where possible and appropriate.
    a (images are tagged and non-free images have fair use rationales): b (appropriate use with suitable captions):
  7. Overall:
    Pass/Fail:

I will put the article on hold for fixes to be made. Dough4872 16:35, 18 February 2012 (UTC)[reply]

First I would like to thank you for the review. I have been out of town for the past few days and I fixed some of the problems today. I will fix the other problems tomorrow. Detcin (talk) 03:08, 21 February 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Replies

  • I fixed the lead problems and added info into the lead.
  • Fixed the sentence "US 20 enters Indiana with US 12 and US 41, underneath the Indiana Toll Road." Changed underneath to under, if you would like another change I‘ll change.
  • In the first paragraph of the Route description you begin two consecutive sentences with "After". Changed
  • "On the east side of Michigan City US 20 has an interchange with SR 212. Soon after SR 212, US 20 has an interchange with I-94 followed by an intersection with the northern terminus of US 35."Changed
  • I reword most of the “an intersection with” or “an interchange with”, by add details about the interchange/intersection. (traffic light, Cloverleaf interchange, etc….)
  • I removed as many US 20 as much as possible, removing some in Northwest Indiana would be very confusing with US 12 and US 41 concurrencies and how many turns onto different surface streets that US 20 follows.
  • Try to avoid using "then" in describing progression of route. I removed many “then” with other words.
  • The sentences "US 20 was part of the first alignment of the Lincoln Highway in 1913. From current SR 2 in Rolling Prairie to Elkhart, where the Lincoln Highway turned southeast on to current US 33." combined.
  • The sentence "When the State of Indiana built Bypass 20, New US 20, or the St. Joseph Valley Parkway, the route downtown was decommissioned" fixed.
  • One important project was the 1900 to 1910 macadamizing of part of the Old Chicago Road, Northwest Indiana's major auto route between Gary and Michigan City before the Dunes Highway.", paraphrased.
  • Can the Dunes Highway information be integrated in the beginning of the history as to describe the route in chronological order? Done
  • Perhaps mention when US 20 was first designated in lead and when segments of the road were first built. Done
  • Can some more details about the physical surroundings be added to the route description? For instance, in Northwest Indiana does it pass through residential, commercial, or industrial areas? In the rural areas, does it pass through farmland or woodland? Can some attractions along the route be mentioned? Done Northwest Indiana is very hard to tell about the physical surroundings with it being residential a half a block, commercial for the rest of that block, industrial for a block, and so on. I add some attractions
  • Is there any history of the road from before the Lincoln Highway? Dunes Highway/Chicago Road before that it was mostly unpaved and unsigned roads that were little more than very narrow lanes.
  • Any dates for the future plans of US 20? The planned completion date is 2020, but this could always change.

Sorry about the length of the replies and the delay in fixing the problems.

If I missed something please tell me, I‘m more than willing to fix. Detcin (talk) 01:57, 23 February 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Made some replies above. Dough4872 02:22, 23 February 2012 (UTC)[reply]
I think I may have fixed the two things? Detcin (talk) 19:15, 24 February 2012 (UTC)[reply]
The article looks good now so I will pass it. Dough4872 20:31, 24 February 2012 (UTC)[reply]

In Lake and Porter counties, US 12 is/was the old Dunes Highway. US 20 was an entirely different road on a more southerly alignment and was tied more historically to the old Sauk Trail between South Bend and Gary. It passes to the south of the old Bailly Homestead, where the old (and present) Dunes Highway is to the north of that point. As a result, I'm going to pull the 'graph and photo out that reference Dunes Highway (the photo specifically notes that it's near the intersection of US 12 & IN 49 -- not US 20) --mhking (talk) 19:05, 23 December 2012 (UTC)[reply]

US 20 and US 12 (was SR 43) was one road from IL state line and Michifgan City and the Sauk Trail was became the Lincoln Highway. The Linoln highway is now SR 2 from Valporiso and Rolling Praine, then US 20 east to South Bend. Detcin (talk) 23:21, 23 December 2012 (UTC)[reply]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:U.S._Route_20_in_Indiana&oldid=1202584970"