| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Untitled comments |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 1#Untitled comments
|
| Red Links |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 1#Red Links
|
| Scientific basis |
48 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 1#Scientific basis
|
| what? |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 1#what?
|
| Western medicine |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 1#Western medicine
|
| questionable statement |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 1#questionable statement
|
| RK v. RR |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 2#RK v. RR
|
| Great Chinese Medicine article ! |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Great Chinese Medicine article !
|
| I see a direct parallel between modern Chinese medicine and Western Medieval medicine |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#I see a direct parallel between modern Chinese medicine and Western Medieval medicine
|
| Request for comment |
9 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Request for comment
|
| RK's edits |
11 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#RK's edits
|
| We are going in circles |
9 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#We are going in circles
|
| Thinning the page |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Thinning the page
|
| Preliminary review of TCM |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Preliminary review of TCM
|
| = Jiang's reversions |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#= Jiang's reversions
|
| 中医学 vs 中药学 |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#中医学 vs 中药学
|
| More page thinning |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#More page thinning
|
| Where is Five elements (Chinese) (??)!? |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Where is Five elements (Chinese) (??)!?
|
| Ways to organize this subject of oriental medicine |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Ways to organize this subject of oriental medicine
|
| Some off-topic comment |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Some off-topic comment
|
| Moved from Uses section |
10 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Moved from Uses section
|
| Changes based on personal experience |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Changes based on personal experience
|
| Lead section |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Lead section
|
| Linkspam? |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Linkspam?
|
| Taking a liberty |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Taking a liberty
|
| Delete or improve |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Delete or improve
|
| Empirical knowledge |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Empirical knowledge
|
| TCM model of the body |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#TCM model of the body
|
| Requests for clarification |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Requests for clarification
|
| Beland's work |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Beland's work
|
| Note to editors - monthly statement |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Note to editors - monthly statement
|
| TCM and Internet |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#TCM and Internet
|
| Seahorse reference |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Seahorse reference
|
| Dried Deer Penis? |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Dried Deer Penis?
|
| "Heat" |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#"Heat"
|
| "Liu hairuo" |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#"Liu hairuo"
|
| West came to China in the 1930s!?!? |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#West came to China in the 1930s!?!?
|
| Recent multiple edits by one new congtributor |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Recent multiple edits by one new congtributor
|
| Article in need of major cleanup |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Article in need of major cleanup
|
| General style and structure |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#General style and structure
|
| Historical Documentation |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Historical Documentation
|
| Seahorses and their effect |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Seahorses and their effect
|
| licensing bodies |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#licensing bodies
|
| The question of efficacy |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#The question of efficacy
|
| removal of 'Mechanism of action' |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#removal of 'Mechanism of action'
|
| merging of "Uses" and "Macro approach to disease" content |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#merging of "Uses" and "Macro approach to disease" content
|
| Opposition |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Opposition
|
| In the Intro |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#In the Intro
|
| Classic Chinese medicine and Traditional Chinese medicine |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Classic Chinese medicine and Traditional Chinese medicine
|
| Pathology |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Pathology
|
| Pseudoscience |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Pseudoscience
|
| Modern TCM History rewrite |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Modern TCM History rewrite
|
| On my reasons for commenting out section 10/31/08 |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#On my reasons for commenting out section 10/31/08
|
| In-line citations |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#In-line citations
|
| Links to relevant english language schools for TCM |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Links to relevant english language schools for TCM
|
| Request for clean-up and copy-editing |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Request for clean-up and copy-editing
|
| Start Over |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Start Over
|
| western medicine? |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#western medicine?
|
| Relation with Western Med |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Relation with Western Med
|
| CCM vs. TCM: proposals for solving the current content fork |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#CCM vs. TCM: proposals for solving the current content fork
|
| Amusing paper |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Amusing paper
|
| Clarify for Non Chinese |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Clarify for Non Chinese
|
| Content, organization |
107 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Content, organization
|
| Unnecessary sentence |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Unnecessary sentence
|
| Makeover |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Makeover
|
| Theory section |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Theory section
|
| Commented-out section |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Commented-out section
|
| Delete theory section |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Delete theory section
|
| More than just alternative medicine, excludes science based medicine |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#More than just alternative medicine, excludes science based medicine
|
| Occult |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Occult
|
| TCM - "inconsistent with modern science", or merely "not accepted by modern science"? |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#TCM - "inconsistent with modern science", or merely "not accepted by modern science"?
|
| Need to add inconsistencies to science section; too much focus on efficay studies, not enough on inconsistency with anatomy |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Need to add inconsistencies to science section; too much focus on efficay studies, not enough on inconsistency with anatomy
|
| Metaphysics, alchemy, astrology, numerology |
17 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Metaphysics, alchemy, astrology, numerology
|
| Penis to penis; Tongue to penis - Dangerous practices |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Penis to penis; Tongue to penis - Dangerous practices
|
| Campaign to clean up (pseudo)-medicine articles |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Campaign to clean up (pseudo)-medicine articles
|
| large revert |
16 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#large revert
|
| Proposed organizational structure |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Proposed organizational structure
|
| POV |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#POV
|
| TCM as lifestyle |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#TCM as lifestyle
|
| Please help find RS for NRS "theory" section material |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Please help find RS for NRS "theory" section material
|
| Please help find RS for NRS material in "zàng-fǔ" section |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Please help find RS for NRS material in "zàng-fǔ" section
|
| Please help find RS for "tequniques" section material |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Please help find RS for "tequniques" section material
|
| malaria RS needed |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#malaria RS needed
|
| Overall Neutrality Dispute |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Overall Neutrality Dispute
|
| Abuse of POV tag |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Abuse of POV tag
|
| Feasibility of placebo controlled studies |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Feasibility of placebo controlled studies
|
| Boldness, WP:Burden, WP:RS re use of Chinese language sources |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Boldness, WP:Burden, WP:RS re use of Chinese language sources
|
| Theoretical superstructure |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Theoretical superstructure
|
| History |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#History
|
| Page needs complete overhaul on style/editorship. |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Page needs complete overhaul on style/editorship.
|
| Use of Chinese language sources and hard copy sources. |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Use of Chinese language sources and hard copy sources.
|
| Unfaithful citations, required quotation and translation, NRS vs. RS |
17 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 3#Unfaithful citations, required quotation and translation, NRS vs. RS
|
| Undue weight of Opisthokont; marine and animal products and fungi |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Undue weight of Opisthokont; marine and animal products and fungi
|
| Translation to English request |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Translation to English request
|
| Unfaithful citations - Journal of Biocommunication artice |
11 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Unfaithful citations - Journal of Biocommunication artice
|
| Section on Ban Xia states one thing and cites a source which says something different. |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Section on Ban Xia states one thing and cites a source which says something different.
|
| Picture from Erotic photographer |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Picture from Erotic photographer
|
| Definition of and scope of "TCM" |
46 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Definition of and scope of "TCM"
|
| History |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#History
|
| "Environmental factors" |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#"Environmental factors"
|
| Endangered plants |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Endangered plants
|
| This Article Should Be Flagged |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#This Article Should Be Flagged
|
| Mugwort |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Mugwort
|
| Call for citation: aconite |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Call for citation: aconite
|
| Supernatural mushroom |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Supernatural mushroom
|
| Ginkgo inaccuracy |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Ginkgo inaccuracy
|
| Strychnine tree seeds |
9 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Strychnine tree seeds
|
| Why the Picture of Tibetan Medicine? |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Why the Picture of Tibetan Medicine?
|
| SARS section? |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#SARS section?
|
| " just as chemotherapy is used to treat cancer in western medicine" |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#" just as chemotherapy is used to treat cancer in western medicine"
|
| the toxic dose of a poisonous drug is generally close to its therapeutic dose. |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#the toxic dose of a poisonous drug is generally close to its therapeutic dose.
|
| Matuk article is questionable source - No "complex association with gods" |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Matuk article is questionable source - No "complex association with gods"
|
| RS needed for safety content |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#RS needed for safety content
|
| human parts, licorice in feces, urine sediments and oral hygiene, placenta, metaphysics of the soul, breath |
15 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#human parts, licorice in feces, urine sediments and oral hygiene, placenta, metaphysics of the soul, breath
|
| Red linked refs |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Red linked refs
|
| Editor interactions |
33 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Editor interactions
|
| PPdd Article Topic Ban |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#PPdd Article Topic Ban
|
| Crticism from inside China of TCM as backward, unscientific, and superstitious |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Crticism from inside China of TCM as backward, unscientific, and superstitious
|
| Re - Multiple AGF attacks on me on this talk page and these edit summaries |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Re - Multiple AGF attacks on me on this talk page and these edit summaries
|
| Sources |
11 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Sources
|
| Scraping (Gua Sha) |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Scraping (Gua Sha)
|
| Example of “expertise” of an editor on TCM - why nonRS opinion based on editor-“experts” MUST not replace RS content |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Example of “expertise” of an editor on TCM - why nonRS opinion based on editor-“experts” MUST not replace RS content
|
| Table of Substances still too focused on exotica |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 4#Table of Substances still too focused on exotica
|
| This is a seriously POV article |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#This is a seriously POV article
|
| Unsure what this means |
14 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Unsure what this means
|
| Article is a little confusing - suggestions for improvement - POV |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Article is a little confusing - suggestions for improvement - POV
|
| Examples of patterns |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Examples of patterns
|
| New take on "theoretical model" section |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#New take on "theoretical model" section
|
| Is it okay that I deleted this? |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Is it okay that I deleted this?
|
| Redundant summarizing sections |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Redundant summarizing sections
|
| Organ extension |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Organ extension
|
| Some feedback |
19 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Some feedback
|
| "Nonpenetrating Sham Treatment" |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#"Nonpenetrating Sham Treatment"
|
| Medicines? |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Medicines?
|
| TCM\YIN & YANG |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#TCM\YIN & YANG
|
| Efficacy testing |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Efficacy testing
|
| Lede |
9 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Lede 2
|
| Famous doctors |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Famous doctors
|
| General comment on the article |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#General comment on the article
|
| hidden overview? |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#hidden overview?
|
| structure |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#structure
|
| Deleting "Chinese alchemy" section |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Deleting "Chinese alchemy" section
|
| Shortlist of medicinals |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Shortlist of medicinals
|
| Medicinals pictures |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Medicinals pictures
|
| Acupuncture efficacy |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Acupuncture efficacy
|
| Lede |
20 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Lede 3
|
| Translating 中医 |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Translating 中医
|
| "Yinyangism"? |
10 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#"Yinyangism"?
|
| Lede, 2nd sentence |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Lede, 2nd sentence
|
| The table in the "History" section |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#The table in the "History" section
|
| What to include in the History section? |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#What to include in the History section?
|
| The "Fengshui and Chinese astrology" section |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#The "Fengshui and Chinese astrology" section
|
| Hiding feng-shui section |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Hiding feng-shui section
|
| Draft of new "History" section: requesting comments |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Draft of new "History" section: requesting comments
|
| New take on lede |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#New take on lede
|
| TCM model of the body wiki article |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#TCM model of the body wiki article
|
| question about TCM research |
18 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#question about TCM research
|
| Influence on other cultures |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Influence on other cultures
|
| Lede: bear bile |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Lede: bear bile
|
| neutrality |
19 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#neutrality
|
| Lead/Lede |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Lead/Lede
|
| Relative importance of Anatomy in TCM |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Relative importance of Anatomy in TCM
|
| Efficacy |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Efficacy
|
| Tone indication in pinyin headings |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Tone indication in pinyin headings
|
| Removed Cite errors |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Removed Cite errors
|
| Quote in herbs section |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Quote in herbs section
|
| Environmental Impact |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#Environmental Impact
|
| On Manchu Medical Manuscripts and Blockprints |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 5#On Manchu Medical Manuscripts and Blockprints
|
| Recent edits regarding animal parts |
13 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Recent edits regarding animal parts
|
| Unbalanced/POV? |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Unbalanced/POV?
|
| WP:SYN |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#WP:SYN
|
| Traditional Chinese medicine |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Traditional Chinese medicine
|
| Relationship with evidence based medicine |
43 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Relationship with evidence based medicine
|
| Fixing the archiver configuration |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Fixing the archiver configuration
|
| Chairman Mao Invented Traditional Chinese Medicine, but Didn't Believe In It |
11 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Chairman Mao Invented Traditional Chinese Medicine, but Didn't Believe In It
|
| WHO |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#WHO
|
| Problematic reverts |
9 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Problematic reverts
|
| Ernst on Vickers |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Ernst on Vickers
|
| Concise summary |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Concise summary
|
| Criticism |
13 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#Criticism
|
| Recent edits |
34 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Recent edits
|
| Edit did not match edit summary |
24 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Edit did not match edit summary
|
| WP:MEDRS violations again |
28 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#WP:MEDRS violations again
|
| Edits on "Legal and political status" vol. II |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Edits on "Legal and political status" vol. II
|
| Edits on "Legal and political status" vol. I |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#Edits on "Legal and political status" vol. I
|
| Drug discoveries |
19 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#Drug discoveries
|
| Historical reference |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 6#Historical reference
|
| Non-notable or duplicate sources moved to talk |
30 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#Non-notable or duplicate sources moved to talk
|
| Traditional Chinese medicine minerals |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#Traditional Chinese medicine minerals
|
| Two kinds of xue? |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#Two kinds of xue?
|
| although…although… |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#although…although…
|
| Drug research, continued |
33 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#Drug research, continued
|
| Chairman Mao Reinvented Traditional Chinese Medicine? |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#Chairman Mao Reinvented Traditional Chinese Medicine?
|
| Ginger |
9 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 7#Ginger
|
| Removing medical jargon |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#Removing medical jargon
|
| Inappropriate conclusion in lede of article |
45 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#Inappropriate conclusion in lede of article
|
| Labels: Pseudoscience, proto-science, pre-science |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#Labels: Pseudoscience, proto-science, pre-science
|
| Pseudoscience |
11 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#Pseudoscience
|
| Protoscience |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#Protoscience
|
| Disruptive editing by user QuackGuru |
11 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#Disruptive editing by user QuackGuru
|
| Labels: pseudoscience, protoscience |
26 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#Labels: pseudoscience, protoscience
|
| Role of traditional concepts: belief system or mnemonic? |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#Role of traditional concepts: belief system or mnemonic?
|
| TCM and purinergic signalling |
20 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#TCM and purinergic signalling
|
| Definitions: traditional Chinese medicine, pseudoscience, and actual science |
16 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Definitions: traditional Chinese medicine, pseudoscience, and actual science
|
| RfC: Is the Nature article an appropriate source for the claim it is attached to? |
164 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#RfC: Is the Nature article an appropriate source for the claim it is attached to?
|
| Sources on acupuncture with positive results |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#Sources on acupuncture with positive results
|
| The wording in the lede is ambiguous |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#The wording in the lede is ambiguous
|
| What's the purpose of this tag? |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#What's the purpose of this tag?
|
| No full citation found in the footnote section |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 8#No full citation found in the footnote section
|
| Original research? |
12 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Original research?
|
| Best source? |
22 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Best source?
|
| Criticism spans the whole article |
16 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Criticism spans the whole article
|
| Pseudoscience and other meanings |
15 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Pseudoscience and other meanings
|
| Deletion of text without discussion |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Deletion of text without discussion
|
| Why is Mao's fraud invention of TCM as "traditional" not in the lead first sentence? |
14 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Why is Mao's fraud invention of TCM as "traditional" not in the lead first sentence?
|
| Broke formatting? |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Broke formatting?
|
| Neutrality POV ? |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Neutrality POV ?
|
| Why does the lead first sentence contain an entire line of Chinese characters? |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Why does the lead first sentence contain an entire line of Chinese characters?
|
| Attempt to make the article more neutral, per many discussions on this page |
10 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Attempt to make the article more neutral, per many discussions on this page
|
| Why was National Science Foundation removed as a source? |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Why was National Science Foundation removed as a source?
|
| The lead first paragraph should have info about Mao, that TCM is alt med, and that it is not based on science |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#The lead first paragraph should have info about Mao, that TCM is alt med, and that it is not based on science
|
| US National Library of Medicine sources on Traditional Chinese Medicine |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#US National Library of Medicine sources on Traditional Chinese Medicine
|
| can't understand why delete the content I added |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#can't understand why delete the content I added
|
| TCM |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#TCM
|
| Your "clarification" on Traditional Chinese medicine |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Your "clarification" on Traditional Chinese medicine
|
| Article in South China Morning Post about TCM |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Article in South China Morning Post about TCM
|
| Review in Cell Biochemistry and Biophysics |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#Review in Cell Biochemistry and Biophysics
|
| What the Nature citation does not (and does) say |
11 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 9#What the Nature citation does not (and does) say
|
| Brain excitability in stroke: the yin and yang of stroke progression. |
9 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Brain excitability in stroke: the yin and yang of stroke progression.
|
| According to TMC's critics |
11 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#According to TMC's critics
|
| TCM is alternative medicine, requires same explicit caution granted "Alternative Medicine" wiki as well as "Criticism" section |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#TCM is alternative medicine, requires same explicit caution granted "Alternative Medicine" wiki as well as "Criticism" section
|
| External links modified |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#External links modified
|
| TCM the source for today's Nobel prize in medicine |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#TCM the source for today's Nobel prize in medicine
|
| Reference |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Reference
|
| wood blue??? |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#wood blue???
|
| Vacuity and repletion??!? |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Vacuity and repletion??!?
|
| Add content on other drugs to drug research section |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Add content on other drugs to drug research section
|
| New law sparks debate |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#New law sparks debate
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#External links modified 2
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#External links modified 3
|
| Is there such a thing as American Modern TCM |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Is there such a thing as American Modern TCM
|
| "Lead content" image caption |
9 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#"Lead content" image caption
|
| Adding to Article |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Adding to Article
|
| Categorization under Alternative and Pseudo-medicine |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Categorization under Alternative and Pseudo-medicine
|
| Misinformation from at least two sources |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Misinformation from at least two sources
|
| Capitalize "medicine" |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Capitalize "medicine"
|
| Introduction Improvements |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Introduction Improvements
|
| Wording on Nature editorial |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Wording on Nature editorial
|
| Section needed about extinction |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Section needed about extinction
|
| New Nature Article "Demystifying traditional herbal medicine with modern approaches" |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#New Nature Article "Demystifying traditional herbal medicine with modern approaches"
|
| RfC - Again |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#RfC - Again
|
| Scientific American: WHO is now promoting unproved traditional Chinese medicine |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Scientific American: WHO is now promoting unproved traditional Chinese medicine
|
| Imbalance between lead and body, on science |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Imbalance between lead and body, on science
|
| irrelevant section "Medical development" |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#irrelevant section "Medical development"
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 16 September 2019 |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Semi-protected edit request on 16 September 2019
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 9 October 2019 |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Semi-protected edit request on 9 October 2019
|
| TCM kills: animals, nature and people. Let us add such section. |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#TCM kills: animals, nature and people. Let us add such section.
|
| Delete intro to gender in Chinese medicine? |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Delete intro to gender in Chinese medicine?
|
| Introduction readability |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Introduction readability
|
| Sciencelogic40 edits continually reverted |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Sciencelogic40 edits continually reverted
|
| Re: Critique |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Re: Critique
|
| Critiques |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Critiques
|
| Updated Page please. |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Updated Page please.
|
| Distinguishing TCM from "Western" Medicine |
10 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Distinguishing TCM from "Western" Medicine
|
| Movement of the Critique section |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Movement of the Critique section
|
| Removal of repeated links in header of article |
14 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Removal of repeated links in header of article
|
| Addition of World Health Organisation decision |
15 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Addition of World Health Organisation decision
|
| Removal |
8 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 10#Removal
|
| Second sentence |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Second sentence
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 21 January 2021 |
9 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Semi-protected edit request on 21 January 2021
|
| POV? |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#POV?
|
| pseudoscience |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#pseudoscience
|
| Blaming TCm for Covid 19 is false |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Blaming TCm for Covid 19 is false
|
| I think the Chinese version of this article is written more neutrally. |
44 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#I think the Chinese version of this article is written more neutrally.
|
| Basic confusion: "TCM" was not found in Traditional China; it was a 20th century invented tradition |
5 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Basic confusion: "TCM" was not found in Traditional China; it was a 20th century invented tradition
|
| Inacurrate understanding and description of Chinese medicine. |
6 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Inacurrate understanding and description of Chinese medicine.
|
| Editing pseudoscientific claims |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Editing pseudoscientific claims
|
| China is the primary consumer of illegal ivory |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#China is the primary consumer of illegal ivory
|
| Is this a reliable source? |
12 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Is this a reliable source?
|
| Related discussion |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Related discussion
|
| safety - irrelevant paragraph on covid-19 |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#safety - irrelevant paragraph on covid-19
|
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment
|
| Revised and augmented lead sentence |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Revised and augmented lead sentence
|
| Intro revision |
10 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Intro revision
|
| The lede needs to be revised |
20 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 12#The lede needs to be revised
|
| Biases |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Biases
|
| Commercial web sites as references |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Commercial web sites as references
|
| Is there a distinction between Traditional Chinese medicine and ancient Chinese medicine? |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Is there a distinction between Traditional Chinese medicine and ancient Chinese medicine?
|
| Source "Understanding Traditional Chinese Medicine Therapeutics: An Overview of the Basics and Clinical Applications" |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Source "Understanding Traditional Chinese Medicine Therapeutics: An Overview of the Basics and Clinical Applications"
|
| Do you think restructuring the lead like this is better? |
7 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Do you think restructuring the lead like this is better?
|
| New Section |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#New Section
|
| WP:PROFRINGE |
10 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#WP:PROFRINGE
|
| Agreed. This lead is false and misleading. Over 13,000 studies in 60 countries prove so. |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 12#Agreed. This lead is false and misleading. Over 13,000 studies in 60 countries prove so.
|
| Proposal: Change infobox image back to photograph |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Proposal: Change infobox image back to photograph
|
| See Also list is too big |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#See Also list is too big
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 31 January 2024 |
2 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Semi-protected edit request on 31 January 2024
|
| Wiki Education assignment: Health Psychology |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Wiki Education assignment: Health Psychology
|
| Citation 6 |
4 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#Citation 6
|
| TCM and Mental Health |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 11#TCM and Mental Health
|
| Wooden language |
19 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine/Archive 12#Wooden language
|
| Pseudoscience and western biomedicine colonialism bias/western ethnocentrism |
17 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine#Pseudoscience and western biomedicine colonialism bias/western ethnocentrism
|
| This page is scientifically inaccurate and negatively biased |
3 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine#This page is scientifically inaccurate and negatively biased
|
| Article should not be in the pseudoscience category |
20 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine#Article should not be in the pseudoscience category
|
| Replaced source on Mao not believing in TCM |
1 |
Talk:Traditional Chinese medicine#Replaced source on Mao not believing in TCM
|
