Jump to content

Talk:The Astounding Adventures of Charlie Peace

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Just for the sake of posterity...

[edit]

...as I did see the ancient debate at Charlie Peace (comics), I redirected the previous stubby Charlie Peace article here as most sources refer to the strip, rather than the character. The only other place (not counting The Big One, which was reprints and thus kept the "Astounding Adventures" bit) the IPCetc version has appeared in to date is Albion, which with distance seems destined to be a half-remembered footnote of dubious quality and sincerity compared to what Rebellion are doing. Also considering Peace is a real historical figure there are possibly other comic incarnations of him out there that have nothing to do with the Buster version, so this seemed generally more robust. Retaining the old page as a redirect and for categorisation purposes seems like a fair step in the meantime, but naturally as ever I remain open to discussions about how wrong I am. BoomboxTestarossa (talk) 18:51, 5 August 2023 (UTC)[reply]