Talk:Terri Schiavo case/archives

These are the archived pages of the Talk:Terri Schiavo case page.

February 2005

1. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 1: bit-by-bit changes
2. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 2: Michael estranged? Greer's affiliations

March 2005

1. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 3: POV, Michael as cause?, external links
2. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 4: Baden's assessment, Euthanasia vs Right-to-die, POV, George Greer, why remove tube, Catholic-influenced decision?, condition wording, open adultery statute, $10M offer, feeling pain, potential abuse, first names, external link quality
3. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 5: NCDave conduct, link cleanup, biography request, S686 text, Sun Hudson, Ms./Mrs.
4. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 6: court decisions, legal implications, family members' character, wording of condition, pundits, S686 vote, Iraq, Sun Hudson
5. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 7: Ms. or Mrs., photo usage, initial collapse, insurance, feeding tube, pronunciation, legal costs
6. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 8: cause of collapse, Larry King transcript, Hammesfahr's credentials, Michael's role, nurse's affidavit, the Vatican, page protection
7. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 9: photo inclusion, alleged GOP memo, mentioning the money, bulimia as cause, pro-life/anti-abortion, role of the church
8. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 10: feeling pain, cleanup of additions, proposed addition of Lieberman analysis and vocalizations
9. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 11: poll on terminology ("pro-life" or other), including public opinion, wording on Mr. Schiavo's role, overlinking
10. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 12: sources for external links, date correction, "Culture of Life"/"Culture of Death", ABC poll, CAT Scans
11. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 13: authority to report condition, NPOV tag, pain speculation in lead?, Catholic category, edit warring, Reuters cite, brain scan, nurse Iyer affidavit
12. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 14: disability rights, Ms./Mrs. again, Hammesfahr update, POV issues, Michael an RN, poll on stating pain status
13. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 15: summarizing televised statements, LA Times, cremation?, weight, Mr. Schiavo's girlfriend, "life support", Dr. Maxfield, 1994 hospice care, parents sent out before death?, who is "family", relevance of early life, fork article?
14. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 16: still "current event"?, family in room, lead section, pronunciation, Last Rites, NYT, list of neurologists, TOC, copyediting, talk archiving and refactoring, "recent developments", affidavits
15. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 17: "fact"/"alleged"/"disputed"/"claimed", Martinez talking points memo, HTML entities, Dr. Cranford, Zogby poll

April 2005

1. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 18: Mr. Schiavo living will?, GAL question, NPOV tag, article refactor, medical lodgings, wikithanks, cause of death, other articles
2. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 19: short or long intro?, splitting article, relevance test, URL test, Tropix sock puppet?, Perry Fine quote
3. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 20: Terri's weight discrepancy, unusually stiff neck, length, web accessibility/definition of life-prolonging procedure, paraphrase v. quote, legal grist, re: Patsw rv., uncited statements?
4. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 21: Valentine's Day rewritten, splitting article, to Ann Heneghan, the NCDave situation, Natural means
5. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 22: NCdave troll?, NCdave vandalism / Prof. Ninja 3RR, Malpractice Suit, Reference links, Pecarek report, To Tropix, Consensus, Abuse, Factual Accuracy v. Neutral Point of View, issues of dispute
6. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 23: POV tag, lead section, Bernat Senate Testimony, NCdave editing from IP, "formal vs. journalistic" style, LRod please create an account, Changes by JYolkowski

June 2005

1. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 24: Name formats, burial, FuelWagon vs GordonWatts, 'wacky edits', links - crackpot or not?, general squabbling
2. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 25: POV again, Iyer affidavit again, Michael Schiavo and AStanhope hate cats, opening paragraph discussions, name format again, links, 'singling out Hammesfahr'
3. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 26: Trying to settle things, Let's begin mediation, Points of Contention, autopsy announced (& picked apart), 'Bulimia again', again and again, Life prolonging, more squabbling, name calling, resizing.
4. Talk:Terri_Schiavo case/Archive 27: Splitting "Political activism and public opinion" section; Schiavo burial details; NCdave's claims about Schiavo neuropathology report; dispute over Dr. Cheshire's "diagnosis;" number of doctors who examined Schiavo; brief discussion on autopsy, dehydration; Duckecho v NCdave over neuropathology report.
5. Talk:Terri_Schiavo case/Archive 28: Disappearance of article version; "Why This Page Will Always Appear POV;" "How can Michael's own testimony be POV?;" Schiavo's dating, criticism; Ghost on glacial improvement; Polls on splitting various sections into new articles; PVS in medical crisis section; invasion of Lord Voldermort; minor header issue.; Split of article -subarticle on Public opinion and Activism; "Legal refinement" of Lead/Intro section; Doctors selected by courts.

July 2005

1. Talk:Terri_Schiavo case/Archive 29: "Reading for the Enemy;" "Eventually" choosing to withdraw life support; family disputes / legal disputes; Lead/Intro/Summary section; The London bombings; "Diagnosed;" Autopsy rewrite; Our ahistorical account of the Schiavo story; Terri Template, refs house style, italics, etc; Intro again; bush investigation;Initial Medical Crisis; Diagnosis dispute; The Intro. Part troix; PVS, family relationship; The Intro. Part quatre; Euthanasia; Size doesn't matter; Apology to the group (Duck)
2. Archive 30: Just way too long and uncordial - maybe someone else can summarize the threads.
3. Talk:Terri_Schiavo/Archive 31: Protected , Cooperative editing, PVS, Perspective, Intro again, Application of diagnosis—the "do-not-resuscitate" order, Yet another intro rewrite, Removal of sentence, Minor edit, Revert?, PVS, "diagnosed as", and NPOV dispute, moving sections around, Wagon, does this removed text need to be in the article?

August 2005

1. Talk:Terri_Schiavo case/Archive 32: End of life, sic, Heads up; Neutrality made major changes in intro, 33 affidavits, leftover agreement, Chronological, Euthanasia?, Distinguishing one dispute from another, Current status of "sparked a fierce debate over euthanasia" edit, The different points of views around euthanasia, Peer review, Table of contents
2. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 33: Submission for Featured Article Candidates, discussion of introduction rewrite
3. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 34: Euthanasia again, self promotion, "right to life" and "right to die" POV language?, making references invisible, shorten the article, pictures, Greer didn't "clarify", placement in hospice, too many links, oral feeding and guardianship challenge, stay of execution

September 2005

1. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 35: Length and structure questioned, weight and eating habits, RfC & Featured Article observations, beginning of hospice paragraph debate
2. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 36: Gordon and FuelWagon debate hospice paragraphs. Other editors get lost. Notability and intro.
3. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 37: Hospice debate continued including vote, length questioned, bulimia, limited editing agreement reached, vows re-insertion, urinary tract infection discussed
4. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 38: Edit counting and agreement discussed, memorial reduction, GAL reduction, eating disorder debated, article cut in half plus debate, copyvio.
5. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 39: Editcountitis, suggested re-insertion of legal history, article length, extensive debate over Gordon’s links, memorial pics
6. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 40: Memorial pic debate, Gordon's links, GFDL and fair use, mergeback legal history debate, page protect and unprotect

October 2005

1. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 41: Unprotect and mergeback of legal history, extensive bulimia debate and Michael's testimony re same
2. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 42: some little things, naming conventions ("Terri" or "Schiavo), extensive debate over Catholic host/bread/wafer

November 2005

1. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 43: Host debate continues at length, bit on euthanisia, bulimia, editing style

December 2005

1. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 44: Extensive Pinktulip ruminations, medical info delegated to subpage, reducing bloat, squabbling about minor reverting and the threat of major reverting by Marskell

December 2006

1. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 45: (Selected highlights from this HUGE, year-long archive, covering approximately 10 December 2006 to 23 November 2006) - the never ending edit...; Strawpoll (evil!); Mergeback; Michael taking Terri home; not quite NPOV (exaggerated translation, for clarity); Barb Weller; Whats missing in this article; Not menstruating.; Allegations of Murder; Added automated peer review; About the 2 tagged sections on contradiction; and, Article promoted (where Cedars writes, in part: "Hi all, I have promoted the article to the status of good article...")

July 2007

1. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 46: Something going on with Calton, little other progress. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by SallyForth123 (talk • contribs) 17:16, August 21, 2007 (UTC).
2. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 47: Jan-Feb 2007
3. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 48: Feb 2007
4. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 49: Feb 2007
5. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 50: rest of the first half of 2007
6. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 51: last half of 2007
7. Talk:Terri Schiavo case/Archive 52: All of 2008