Talk:Tales of Legendia/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: DragonZero (Talk · Contribs) 20:13, 3 July 2013 (UTC)

Issues must be addressed to pass. Suggestions are suggestions. DragonZero (talk · contribs) 20:47, 3 July 2013 (UTC)

Issues

• Change ref dates to match article dates, Month Day Year
• Source 25 does not cover who does what song
• Either add trans_title= to the cite web template with Japanese Kanji or replace the titles with a translation.
• Source for Korean Date?
• Images are excessively large
• Cover art image has weak rationale
• {{Link GA|ja}}, {{Link FA|ja}} Choose one.
• Song titles should be italicized. Also, are the song titles official translations? If not, use Nihongo3 and add a lit. to the English title to show it's a translation.

Yes, those are the official translations from the in-game sound test (which also appear in the ref). As far as I can tell, they are very close, if not exactly direct translations. I went ahead and italicized them as well.

• MoS Caps issues such as TAO or ref 27.

Took care of this, too.

Suggestions

• Add lead=yes to the top Nihongo
• Here's the Legendia Merchance page at [1]. You can use it to add the manga adaptions.
• Tales popularity poll would benefit the character list
• Nihongofoot for paragraphs where multiple nihongo templates are used
• I suggest having the characters reception on the characters themselves.

Thanks for taking the time to look this over. It's been so long since I've edited with the intent of actually making GAs I've gone out of the loop! Considering that this, of all games, has an FA on the Japanese wiki, I feel like we owe it to ourselves to at least get this thing to GA. Going by some of the bigger issues:

Change ref dates to match article dates, Month Day Year  Done

M/D/Y all over unless I've missed some.

Source 25 does not cover who does what song

Unless we're talking about something different, it should. Check out the "notes" section at the bottom under vocals. (It's source is #27 now)

Either add trans_title= to the cite web template with Japanese Kanji or replace the titles with a translation.  Done

Huh. I never even knew this parameter existed. I went with the tran_title since I don't exactly trust my translations to be 100% accurate.

Source for Korean Date?

Someone added this in just before I started cleaning up the article. I seem to remember that non-English releases shouldn't be in the info box anyway unless it's notable so I just took it out. I also added refs for the NA/JP releases since they probably should've been there in the beginning.

Images are excessively large  Done

The screenshot is now down to 400px and the box art is sitting at 250.

Cover art image has weak rationale  Done

Imported boilerplate.

{{Link GA|ja}}, {{Link FA|ja}} Choose one.  Done

Looks like the bot just put in the FA template and left the other one in. It's always the bot's fault.

Also, I added the nihongo lead and info from the 2nd character popularity poll into the reception section (straight from the Japanese wiki - the only one I could find at the moment). I can put some manga info in at some point as well.

If there's anything else that needs to go in or if you just feel like it needs more work let me know. I greatly appreciate your suggestions and hope we can get this thing up to a much better standard. Nall (talk) 03:43, 5 July 2013 (UTC)

You should reply under my points like what goes on here and avoid using images. Last issues and I'll pass it. DragonZero (Talk · Contribs) 05:12, 5 July 2013 (UTC)

Passing. DragonZero (Talk · Contribs) 08:05, 6 July 2013 (UTC)