Talk:Suleiman Khater

Stamp image

The stamp image I've currently linked to is kind of horizontally stretched; there's a smaller version of the image (not stretched) on Hebrew Wikipedia at he:Image:Solayman.jpg; don't feel like copying it over to English Wikipedia and filling in all the tedious multiple redundant fair use paperwork at the moment, but there's no reason why it couldn't be... AnonMoos (talk) 11:53, 22 January 2009 (UTC)

Street name

Do a simple Google search to see abundant evidence of Soleyman Khater St., Tehran... AnonMoos (talk) 12:00, 22 January 2009 (UTC)

Neutrality

This article contains much speculation and appears to be sympathetic towards Khater. It needs its neutrality checked and less POV language inserted. Paris1127 (talk) 08:10, 9 February 2013 (UTC)

Uncited section: "Egypt my Mother"

The following section, titled "Egypt my Mother" was moved from the article, since it has no citations and I couldn't find any reliable sources that discuss this:

In a letter he wrote in prison he mentioned that when one of the prisoners asked him “what are you thinking about?” he answered “I’m thinking of Egypt my mother. I’m thinking she’s a good woman like my mother who works really hard, and I’m telling her: “I’m just one of your loving sons, of your soil, and my blood is of your Nile”, and when I cry, I picture her sitting right next to me, just like my mother at home who used to hold me to her chest and say: “Don’t cry Suleiman, you did exactly what I was expecting from you””. In the court, Suleiman said: “I’m not afraid of death, it’s fate. What I’m afraid of is that the sentence I’m going to receive might affect my colleagues badly and kill their patriotism”. And when he was sentenced he said: “This sentence is a sentence against Egypt, because an Egyptian soldier did his duty”, and talked to the guards saying: “Go guard Sinai, Suleiman doesn’t need any guards”.

If anybody can find a reliable source that includes this text, feel free to add it back in. APerson241 (talk!) 20:32, 20 June 2013 (UTC)

Uncited material: "Investigation with Suleiman"

The following material was moved from the section titled "Investigation with Suleiman" because it was uncited:

(Pointing to another accident where an Israeli woman stripped in front of an Egyptian soldier in Sinai to get the CSF equipment frequency from him) “Why did you order us not to let anyone pass then? If you wanted us to let them then just tell us so”. As the investigator asked him, “why do you insist on filling your weapon, Suleiman?” Khater answered, “because whoever loves his country takes care of his weapon, and vice versa... That’s pretty axiomatic”. He said, “because I love it as much as I love Egypt” when he was asked “how do you reason that you memorize your weapon’s number?”

If anybody can find a reliable source that includes this text, feel free to add it back in. APerson241 (talk!) 20:42, 20 June 2013 (UTC)

Uncited material: "Early Life"

The following material was moved from the section titled "Early Life" because it was not cited:

Maybe these scenes were of a strong impact on Suleiman who was 9 years old back then, as said by his sister who told Al-Jazeera that Suleiman “rush out to see what’s happening and came back with a shock of what he saw”.

If anybody can find a reliable source that includes this text, feel free to add it back in. APerson241 (talk!) 20:44, 20 June 2013 (UTC)

Sulayman Khater “ The true story “

Sulayman Khater is an Egyptian soldier who was defending his service location aganist intruders , he warned the israelie intruders in both Arabic and English that they are trespassing but they refused to comply to his orders to stop or turn back , as per his orders he shot warning shots in the air then near to the intruders legs however, the intruders kept on trespassing the borders , the final procedure as per the army protocol is to shoot to kill in order to stop trespassing which he did.

Sulayman Khater is an Egyptian hero who ended up being an escape goat to a corrupt regime .

Wikipedia, either to authenticate your facts or not publish them at all .

Please, read more about Sulayman Khater and pray for his soul . رحمه الله علي البطل الشهيد 94.128.69.215 (talk) 09:30, 29 November 2021 (UTC)

That sounds like 1980s Arab propaganda. Why did he need to kill four children and two women when he had a gun and they didn't??? That sure seems like "depraved indifference to human life" (to use a U.S. legal term) to me... AnonMoos (talk) 20:25, 1 December 2021 (UTC)