Jump to content

Talk:Stranger (magazine)

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Comment

[edit]

This article should not be deleted. It dovetails with a new section on Cornish magazines I am writing as part of the Cornish media article. -- Tinminer 17:23, 13 July 2007 (UTC) This is a smaller Wikipedia page based on a British magazine called Stranger. The article talks about the origins of the magazine, their community outreach and the various awards the magazine has won. The community outreach section was a bit unnecessary to have as a stand alone paragraph, I would have put it in the section for the history of the magazine. The article is completely neutral, only referencing the history of the magazine and what it did. There is no advocating for or against the publication. There are no viewpoints in this article as it is just information on what the article has done. Some of the citations had no links because they were books but the authors and the websites cited were reliable. The one source that could be questioned was the first cited source which was to a newspaper article, though it was only to reference who started the magazine. The article has not been updated in a year and it is possible there has been some new information as far as awards or community outreach that could be put in the article. The only conversation on the talk page is a plead for the page not to be deleted. This article is rated start class-low importance. Wikipedia doesn't talk about the impact of magazines and media alike whereas in class we put more of an emphasis on that. How could this page be better organized and is it necessary for the community outreach to have its own tab? --Ll99ll (talk) 00:31, 2 February 2018 (UTC)[reply]