Talk:Stacie Monroe
 | This article was nominated for deletion on 20 April 2015. The result of the discussion was merge to List of Hustle characters. |
Merger proposal
[edit]I propose that Stacie Monroe be merged into Hustle (TV series). This proposal supersedes original suggestion from June of 2011 that was never discussed. This article's subject's notability has also been in question since June of 2011. This article includes only one third-party reference that I found myself before proposing this merger. SaveATreeEatAVegan 22:27, 10 February 2012 (UTC)
- Seems reasonable provided it doesn't make the main article unwieldy. PRL42 (talk) 08:13, 11 February 2012 (UTC)
- You'll notice, Rob Jarvis as Eddie, Matt Di Angelo as Sean Kennedy, and Kelly Adams as Emma Kennedy do not have a separate article for their characters either. It often appears the ones who do, such as Robert Vaughn as Albert Stroller or Robert Glenister as Ash "Three Socks" Morgan, have multiple issues and have also been tagged for a merger since June of 2011. We really need an overhaul on this project it appears. Might be hard to gather a consensus unless they're eventually brought to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion, but only time will tell if that should become necessary. Thanks for your feedback. SaveATreeEatAVegan 02:39, 13 February 2012 (UTC)
- As I mentioned, the only objection I can see is that it would make the main article unwieldy (and give undue prominence to that character). Another possibility is to split 'Main characters' from the main article and merge all the individual characters there. I'm not sure of the protocol for doing something like that so, unless anyone objects in the next couple of weeks, I'll create a 'Main characters' article and copy the individual articles there. Then, anyone who so wishes can nominate the individual articles for deletion. PRL42 (talk) 11:33, 8 May 2012 (UTC)
- This has now been done (The 'Main Characters' article already existed so the expanded text from the individual articles was merged into that). PRL42 (talk) 15:46, 24 May 2012 (UTC)
- As I mentioned, the only objection I can see is that it would make the main article unwieldy (and give undue prominence to that character). Another possibility is to split 'Main characters' from the main article and merge all the individual characters there. I'm not sure of the protocol for doing something like that so, unless anyone objects in the next couple of weeks, I'll create a 'Main characters' article and copy the individual articles there. Then, anyone who so wishes can nominate the individual articles for deletion. PRL42 (talk) 11:33, 8 May 2012 (UTC)
- You'll notice, Rob Jarvis as Eddie, Matt Di Angelo as Sean Kennedy, and Kelly Adams as Emma Kennedy do not have a separate article for their characters either. It often appears the ones who do, such as Robert Vaughn as Albert Stroller or Robert Glenister as Ash "Three Socks" Morgan, have multiple issues and have also been tagged for a merger since June of 2011. We really need an overhaul on this project it appears. Might be hard to gather a consensus unless they're eventually brought to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion, but only time will tell if that should become necessary. Thanks for your feedback. SaveATreeEatAVegan 02:39, 13 February 2012 (UTC)
- I was about to ask that if this was the consensus on notability, then surely Billy Bond and Danny Blue would also need to be merged, and possibly even all the characters. I then see that this, too, has been suggested. I agree with merging Billy Bond as that is a woefully inadequate article, but the characters of Stacie and Danny seem rather important with regards to the TV series. Much of the articles would need to be cut out, such as history and background, to merge it into the main article. I am not completely against this, as I did not create those articles, but deleting articles on all the major characters seems rather drastic, while merging into the main article would indeed be too unwieldy (imo). Another possible solution may be to merge into List of Hustle characters? Feudonym (talk) 02:32, 13 April 2012 (UTC)