Jump to content

Talk:Sounds from a Town I Love

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Following film article guidelines

[edit]

The editor who created this article is anxious to earn a DYK, but it needs to follow Film Project guidelines. I removed the so-called "reviews" because an amateur blogger's comments are not an acceptable form of critical reception. Also, IMDb is not an acceptable reference, so I removed it wherever it was cited as a source of information. Actually, I don't think this film even meets notability requirements, because it wasn't released in theaters and hasn't received full-length reviews by two or more nationally known critics. The film features significant involvement by a notable person, i.e. Woody Allen, but it can't be considered a major part of his career. An article about a film should be created only if there is so much information about it that it would clutter up the biography page of that person, i.e. Woody Allen, if it was mentioned there. Most of this article is padding that doesn't say anything about the film itself, so the film should have been mentioned in the Woody Allen article instead of having a separate article written about it. MovieMadness (talk) 17:05, 8 August 2009 (UTC)[reply]