Talk:Sniff Petrol
 | This article has not yet been rated on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. |
This page seems to have been created by someone copy/pasting out my sandbox at User:Ckyliu/Sniff_Petrol, which is fine but I did't really think it was ready for primetime yet as it's very poorly referenced with original research and so on; I hope it doesn't end up being a speedy deletion candidate again... (as it has been once already when someone copy/pasted in September) Anyway the sandbox one is at the link I posted if anyone needs it for reference, I haven't really got the time to update it (I only found out from Sniff's twitter it was back) so I hope someone else can make it work before it falls by the wayside again.
So far as I can tell it needs:
- Neutral POV
- Sourcing from sites that aren't Sniff Petrol (there is already the Times and the Irish Times, needs a few more)
- Removal of original reserach (Alexa, Twitter stats etc are not suitable references)
The main bit is establishing notability by getting decent mentions from other publications, otherwise it will be deleted for not being notable.
--Ckyliu (talk) 01:20, 27 February 2011 (UTC)
It's a good start, certainly. There are some POV and Notability issues with it - as is always going to happen when you like something you're writing about! I've gone through and tried to remove as much of the POV stuff as possible, and slimmed down some of the lists of stuff to keep just the most major things, which will help with establishing Notability.