Talk:Saskatchewan Highway 5/GA1
Appearance
GA Review
[edit]Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Comments:
- Done What is the purpose of two maps in the infobox?
- Are there shields for the roads Highway 5 intersects? will try to modify template at User:Pomte/Template:SK road shield for this...
- Done In first paragraph of lead, add comma after "Yellowhead"
- Done Make the third parapgraph of the lead an italicized note at the top of the page
- Done In first sentence of history, capitalize "river"
- Done In first sentence in second paragraph of history, add comma after "Route"
- Done In next sentence, change "an" to "a"
- "a dirt to gravel to all weather road" sounds awkward, try rephrasing
- Done The sentence "In 1925, access from Saskatoon to Provincial Highway 5 was via Provincial Highway 12 due north of Saskatoon connecting with Highway 5 west of Warman or via Provincial Highway 27 which traveled east and north from Saskatoon connecting at Aberdeen" sounds unclear.
- Done "north south" should be hyphenated
- "became retitled? sounds awkward
- Done Try to combine some of the short sentences in the Communities section
- Done "down town" should be one word
- Done "at the Saskatoon Transit"? sounds awkward
- Done In the sentence "The Highway 5 - Highway 35 junction features historical plaque which commemorates the Touchwood Hills Hudson Bay Company fur trade post established in 1879." add "a" between features and historical
- Done Fix spelling of "Hw 755"
- What kind of museums are in Sturgis and Preeceville?
- Done "is hosted at Verigin" sounds awkward, Try rephrasing
- In first sentence of Geophysical features section, add comma after "Saskatchewan"
- Done Make sure to use present tense when describing the current aspects of the route, do not use "travel will be through"
- Clarify what an ecoregion is, possibly by adding a wikilink
- Done "re-opened" should not be hyphenated
- In second paragraph of Geophysical features section, what are Watson and Wadena?
- Done Hyphenate "three lake"
- Replace opening brace with parentheses
- Done In Highway economy section, replace "agricultural" with "agriculture"
- Done In first sentence of second paragraph of Highway configuration section, add comma after "Kamsack"
- Done In next paragraoh, "directions" should be singular
- Done In Upgrades section, remove comma after 2008
- Done Can you make the second paragraph of the Upgrades section more clear by rewording?
- Done In first section of third paragraph of upgrades section, change "a" to "an"
- Done Fix redlink to correspond to wikilink to Ministry of Highways and Infrastructure (Saskatchewan)
- Done "re-surface" should not be hyphenated
- Combine a lot of the short paragraphs in the Travel route section
- Done "Zig-zagging" sounds awkward; try using a different word
- Do you think you can make the sentences more varied in the Travel route section?
- Done Add an intersections table to the article
- I would suggest making the format of the article in line with the standards at Wikipedia:WikiProject Canada Roads by moving some of the sections around
I am placing the article on hold Dough4872 (talk) 03:21, 6 February 2009 (UTC)
- Thank you for taking time to review the article. I have adressed the basic ones first, and will return to the more in-depth ones tomorrow when it is earlier in the day. Kind Regards SriMesh | talk 05:18, 6 February 2009 (UTC)