Talk:Quorum (distributed computing)
 | This article has not yet been rated on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||
| |||||||||||
The explanation for quorum based voting is very confusing. Especially the below part :
Every site in the system is assigned a vote Vi. Let us assume that the total number of votes in the system is V and the abort and commit quorums are Va and Vc, respectively. Then the following rules must be obeyed in the implementation of the commit protocol: Va + Vc > V, where 0 < Vc, Va \le V. Before a transaction commits, it must obtain a commit quorum Vc. The total of at least one site that is prepared to commit and zero or more sites waiting \ge Vc.[2] Before a transaction aborts, it must obtain an abort quorum Va The total of zero or more sites that are prepared to abort or any sites waiting \ge Va.
- What is a quorum?
- is Va a quorum or the number of abort quorums? It's not clear from the language.
- What does this sentence even mean ? - The total of zero or more sites that are prepared to abort or any sites waiting \ge Va.
How can anything ever be comitted if Va+Vc>V is required? V is the total number of votes, and each vote can be commit, abort, or unknown. Even if everybody (!) votes for commit, Va (=V) + Vc (0) is not greater than V.
Start a discussion about improving the Quorum (distributed computing) page
Talk pages are where people discuss how to make content on Wikipedia the best that it can be. You can use this page to start a discussion with others about how to improve the "Quorum (distributed computing)" page.
