Talk:Operation Overlord/GA1
GA Review
[edit]Citations
[edit]Before recommending the article for GA status, I think the references should be cleaned up. I have the following specific complaints:
- Refs. 1 and 2. Zetterling is not identified (or did I miss something?).
- The form is not constant; sometimes the page numbers come at the end of the citation, other times in the middle, and sometimes are missing altogether.
- Sometimes, a paragraph number is given instead of a page number. This should be deprecated.
- Something is wrong with references 19 and 25. I can't figure out what the trouble is, and don't have the time to learn.
- Access dates are not used with books and other hard copy materials. On the other hand, they should be used with weblinks.
(This is the first time I have had anything to say in GA or higher reviews; am I going about it in the right way?) PKKloeppel (talk) 01:25, 2 July 2008 (UTC)