Talk:Nuccio Rinaldis
 | This page has been recently proposed for deletion (7 September 2024) by Mach61 (talk · contribs). It was contested by CoolJazz5 (talk · contribs) with the comment: Rinaldis has been for 30 years the trusted Audio engineer of the performer considered number 1 in the Italian music scene: Mina. He has worked alongside her on multiple studio Hits and Live concerts, including the singer's last performance captured in the Album Mina Live'78 |
Beyond the relevance of the topic, before changing the nationality and activity of the biographer after my reporting (finally making the correct change) the first proposed deletion presented Nuccio Rinaldis, noted sound engineer for many years of the most important Italian pop singer Mina, as a Bosnian musician, thus making the proposal unacceptable. [1] CoolJazz5 (talk) 21:33, 8 September 2024 (UTC)
- @CoolJazz5 I didn't add the short description calling him Bosnian; that was in the very first edit of the page. I added the proposed deletion tag for the reasons stated in the tag, namely that I did not think he met the English Wikipedia's inclusion guidelines for people. If you have a well formed objection to my reason for deletion, you may remove the tag (I only readded it because it seemed that you confused the tag with the short description). Cheers, Mach61 23:30, 8 September 2024 (UTC)
- @Mach61, Rinaldis has been for 30 years the trusted Audio engineer of the performer considered number 1 in the Italian music scene: Mina. He has worked alongside her on multiple studio Hits and Live concerts, including the singer's last performance captured in the Album Mina Live'78. I firmly believe that Nuccio Rinaldis' relevance in the music business can be considered unquestionable and that he is among the very few who have reached levels unattainable today. If you agree in the afternoon I'll remove the delation notice. Cheers, --CoolJazz5 (talk) 10:02, 9 September 2024 (UTC)
- @CoolJazz5 I disagree with that assesment, but since it is a proper objection, I will remove the tag. Mach61 13:45, 9 September 2024 (UTC)
- @Mach61, Rinaldis has been for 30 years the trusted Audio engineer of the performer considered number 1 in the Italian music scene: Mina. He has worked alongside her on multiple studio Hits and Live concerts, including the singer's last performance captured in the Album Mina Live'78. I firmly believe that Nuccio Rinaldis' relevance in the music business can be considered unquestionable and that he is among the very few who have reached levels unattainable today. If you agree in the afternoon I'll remove the delation notice. Cheers, --CoolJazz5 (talk) 10:02, 9 September 2024 (UTC)