| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Gibberish |
9 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Gibberish
|
| NPOV note |
22 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#NPOV note
|
| NPOVification |
10 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#NPOVification
|
| Alleged |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#Alleged
|
| An outside view |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#An outside view
|
| Arab equivalent? |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#Arab equivalent?
|
| Only source? |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#Only source?
|
| Palestinian Media Watch |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#Palestinian Media Watch
|
| Staff section |
6 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#Staff section
|
| Wikipedia obsessed by MEMRI? |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#Wikipedia obsessed by MEMRI?
|
| Wikipedia obsessed by MEMRI? |
4 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#Wikipedia obsessed by MEMRI? 2
|
| Article under dispute |
9 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#Article under dispute
|
| MEMRI is great! |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#MEMRI is great!
|
| unnoticed deletions |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#unnoticed deletions
|
| Re: Accuracy |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 1#Re: Accuracy
|
| Walayah = State |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#Walayah = State
|
| Neutrality tag |
9 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Neutrality tag
|
| Incredible |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Incredible
|
| Specifics of cricisism section |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Specifics of cricisism section
|
| Copyvio? |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Copyvio?
|
| Cole |
10 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Cole
|
| NPOVing the page: EVERYONE PLEASE READ AND COMMENT |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#NPOVing the page: EVERYONE PLEASE READ AND COMMENT
|
| POV in "Objectives" section |
4 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#POV in "Objectives" section
|
| top section--mild POV |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#top section--mild POV
|
| Political affiliation by marriage? |
8 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Political affiliation by marriage?
|
| Public servants |
12 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Public servants
|
| Good faith and bad |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Good faith and bad
|
| Mattes letter |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Mattes letter
|
| Move the political aff section to the top of criticism? |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Move the political aff section to the top of criticism?
|
| Political Affiliations section |
20 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Political Affiliations section
|
| RFC |
15 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#RFC
|
| Deleted "Funders" |
19 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Deleted "Funders"
|
| Section on Funders |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Section on Funders
|
| Section on Staff |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Section on Staff
|
| "Praise" section |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#"Praise" section
|
| Introduction |
7 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Introduction
|
| Blogs as sources (and more on the RFC near the bottom) (and more on the lawsuits at the bottom) |
14 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Blogs as sources (and more on the RFC near the bottom) (and more on the lawsuits at the bottom)
|
| Elizmr's Crusade to Protect MEMRI |
8 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Elizmr's Crusade to Protect MEMRI
|
| Juan Cole |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#Juan Cole
|
| Recent changes to Criticism/Controversy section and NPOV tag: March 17 2006 |
4 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Recent changes to Criticism/Controversy section and NPOV tag: March 17 2006
|
| Controvery section, Accuracy subsection |
43 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Controvery section, Accuracy subsection
|
| External Links |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 2#External Links
|
| Carmon quote in accuracy section |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Carmon quote in accuracy section
|
| Additional Scholarly Research on MEMRI |
7 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Additional Scholarly Research on MEMRI
|
| MEMRI Lead: No summary mention of controversy |
7 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#MEMRI Lead: No summary mention of controversy
|
| More research results |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#More research results
|
| Disgusted |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Disgusted
|
| Restored funding source info |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Restored funding source info
|
| Temporary Removals |
14 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Temporary Removals
|
| CIA guy |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#CIA guy
|
| Reynolds BBC article |
17 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Reynolds BBC article
|
| Livingstone criticism |
21 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Livingstone criticism
|
| Wot no controversy? |
9 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 3#Wot no controversy?
|
| Reorganized for fairness |
20 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#Reorganized for fairness
|
| Sources in the criticism section |
21 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#Sources in the criticism section
|
| Lee please read WP:RS |
20 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#Lee please read WP:RS
|
| RV OR but anon did give a cite |
8 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#RV OR but anon did give a cite
|
| where did the response to criticism section go? |
7 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#where did the response to criticism section go?
|
| Compromise incorporating above concerns |
19 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#Compromise incorporating above concerns
|
| headings--"pro MEMRI" and "anti MEMRI" vs previous? |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#headings--"pro MEMRI" and "anti MEMRI" vs previous?
|
| paragraph in crit section--overstating the case, introducing distortion |
15 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#paragraph in crit section--overstating the case, introducing distortion
|
| please review this sentence for appropriateness for the encylclopedia |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#please review this sentence for appropriateness for the encylclopedia
|
| The accuracy of MEMRI's translations is sometimes disputed. For example... |
9 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#The accuracy of MEMRI's translations is sometimes disputed. For example...
|
| Please Stop Deleting Text Without Comment Here |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#Please Stop Deleting Text Without Comment Here
|
| wilayah "controversy" |
38 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 4#wilayah "controversy"
|
| Protected |
67 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 5#Protected
|
| For the record |
14 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 5#For the record
|
| Also for the record |
7 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 5#Also for the record
|
| Getting Organized (Again) |
175 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 5#Getting Organized (Again)
|
| Jgui's pet sentence |
25 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 5#Jgui's pet sentence
|
| Snaps to all you hard workers |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 5#Snaps to all you hard workers
|
| MEMRI verifiability |
19 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#MEMRI verifiability
|
| Recent Edits |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 5#Recent Edits
|
| bin laden video |
10 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#bin laden video
|
| section headings |
4 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#section headings
|
| These arguments are going nowhere |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 5#These arguments are going nowhere
|
| No Response |
32 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#No Response
|
| MEMRI reliability HAS been questioned |
29 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#MEMRI reliability HAS been questioned
|
| Recent edits alleging "no response on Talk" |
8 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#Recent edits alleging "no response on Talk"
|
| Mediation on this page |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#Mediation on this page
|
| Why there is no mention that the founders of this propaganda organisation are jewish? |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#Why there is no mention that the founders of this propaganda organisation are jewish?
|
| Request for edit |
22 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#Request for edit
|
| deletion of sourced and relevant material |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#deletion of sourced and relevant material
|
| More deletion of sourced and relevant material |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#More deletion of sourced and relevant material
|
| An attempt to restore some semblance of NPOV to this page |
6 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#An attempt to restore some semblance of NPOV to this page
|
| finkelstein reverts |
15 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 6#finkelstein reverts
|
| Regarding Hamas and Mickey Mouse |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#Regarding Hamas and Mickey Mouse
|
| MickeyMouse incident |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#MickeyMouse incident
|
| MickeyMouse incident |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#MickeyMouse incident 2
|
| Deleted citation |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#Deleted citation
|
| Deleted citation |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#Deleted citation 2
|
| Another attempt at NPOV |
38 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#Another attempt at NPOV
|
| Another attempt at NPOV |
72 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#Another attempt at NPOV 2
|
| Response to Critism |
8 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#Response to Critism
|
| Response to Critism |
8 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#Response to Critism 2
|
| Moving Forward |
27 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#Moving Forward
|
| Moving On Again |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#Moving On Again
|
| Proposed Changes |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 7#Proposed Changes
|
| Hey Humus |
7 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 8#Hey Humus
|
| Full protection |
64 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 8#Full protection
|
| backing off |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 8#backing off
|
| page protection? |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 8#page protection?
|
| rewrite to address 'quotefarm' |
10 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 8#rewrite to address 'quotefarm'
|
| Armon's changes: |
41 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 8#Armon's changes:
|
| Rewrite of the Controversy section(s) |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 8#Rewrite of the Controversy section(s)
|
| Summary Style: Ridiculous Idea |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 8#Summary Style: Ridiculous Idea
|
| WP:OWN |
19 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 8#WP:OWN
|
| Official YouTube channel |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 8#Official YouTube channel
|
| Erlanger of NYT Quote |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Erlanger of NYT Quote
|
| Juan Cole is a reliable source |
40 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Juan Cole is a reliable source
|
| Blogs as sources |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Blogs as sources
|
| Please check Arabic translation edit |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Please check Arabic translation edit
|
| Self-published sources |
24 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Self-published sources
|
| RSN: Is Juan Cole's blog a RS? |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#RSN: Is Juan Cole's blog a RS?
|
| POV problem in "Controversy" section |
7 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#POV problem in "Controversy" section
|
| shorten |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#shorten
|
| Archive.org as a source? |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Archive.org as a source?
|
| Claims of disseminating disinformation |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Claims of disseminating disinformation
|
| Criticism and Praise |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Criticism and Praise
|
| Article introduction |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Article introduction
|
| Advertisement |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Advertisement
|
| Accusations of bias |
38 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Accusations of bias
|
| "ipsnews is not an RS" |
12 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#"ipsnews is not an RS"
|
| Reception |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Reception
|
| Carmon's background in lead |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Carmon's background in lead
|
| Whitaker quote |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Whitaker quote
|
| Praise for MEMRI Section |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Praise for MEMRI Section
|
| Tag does not have merit (February 2011 tag) |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Tag does not have merit (February 2011 tag)
|
| Institute for Research Middle Eastern Policy |
8 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Institute for Research Middle Eastern Policy
|
| Advertisement |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#Advertisement 2
|
| BLP removals |
8 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#BLP removals
|
| MEMRI Board |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 9#MEMRI Board
|
| Connection with Anders Breivik |
6 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Connection with Anders Breivik
|
| Let's make this quick. |
98 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Let's make this quick.
|
| Hypocritical section |
8 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Hypocritical section
|
| Brian Whitaker's "News Piece" |
34 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Brian Whitaker's "News Piece"
|
| "The organization's translations are regularly quoted by major international newspapers" |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#"The organization's translations are regularly quoted by major international newspapers"
|
| Whitaker: fact or opinion? |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Whitaker: fact or opinion?
|
| Wikipedia:Requests for mediation/Middle East Media Research Institute |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Wikipedia:Requests for mediation/Middle East Media Research Institute
|
| Source doesn't say that |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Source doesn't say that
|
| Turkish/Arab/Iranian media? |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Turkish/Arab/Iranian media?
|
| Accusations of bias |
16 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Accusations of bias
|
| report that has a page on memri |
12 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#report that has a page on memri
|
| Titles |
14 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Titles
|
| CNN/Atika Shubert |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#CNN/Atika Shubert
|
| Seemingly disruptive edits |
34 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 10#Seemingly disruptive edits
|
| removal of dead link |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#removal of dead link
|
| Julian Cole view |
18 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Julian Cole view
|
| IRmep |
33 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#IRmep
|
| Concerns about the IRMEP report |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Concerns about the IRMEP report
|
| Looks neutral to me: |
4 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Looks neutral to me:
|
| Missing Islamic Context of Meaning |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Missing Islamic Context of Meaning
|
| Professor Naomi Sakr (Sadr) |
13 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Professor Naomi Sakr (Sadr)
|
| Statements not reflecting sources |
34 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Statements not reflecting sources
|
| Weight in regards to statement of selectivity |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Weight in regards to statement of selectivity
|
| Mucking up the lead |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Mucking up the lead
|
| TRANSCRIPT |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#TRANSCRIPT
|
| Menahem Milson |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Menahem Milson
|
| MEMRI Youtube account suspended? |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#MEMRI Youtube account suspended?
|
| The Arab and Iranian Reaction to 911: Five Years Later |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#The Arab and Iranian Reaction to 911: Five Years Later
|
| Introduction |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Introduction
|
| WP/POV? |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#WP/POV?
|
| Projects |
12 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Projects
|
| Languages |
7 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Languages
|
| Staff |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Staff
|
| Background |
5 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Background
|
| Reception |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Reception
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#External links modified
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#External links modified 2
|
| MEMRI Fake Not-For-Profit? |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#MEMRI Fake Not-For-Profit?
|
| Reception |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Reception 2
|
| Staff |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Staff 2
|
| Edit request - wrong link within wikipedia |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute/Archive 11#Edit request - wrong link within wikipedia
|
| Age of sources in the lead for praise/;criticism |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute#Age of sources in the lead for praise/;criticism
|
| Mona Baker |
21 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute#Mona Baker
|
| Apparent misquote or grammatical error in citation 8 (needs verification) |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute#Apparent misquote or grammatical error in citation 8 (needs verification)
|
| Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 7 November 2023 |
3 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 7 November 2023
|
| Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 12 January 2024 |
2 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 12 January 2024
|
| Fixing mis-cited / incorrect claim in "Translation accuracy and controversy" Section |
1 |
Talk:Middle East Media Research Institute#Fixing mis-cited / incorrect claim in "Translation accuracy and controversy" Section
|
