Talk:Menahem Shemuel Halevy

Possible copyright violation

This article has quite a few signs of cipyright violation: It was uploaded all at once, it reads like a biograph, and event as a section titled "Headline". No online source has identicle text, however. Sagsaw 05:36, 29 December 2006 (UTC)

I think it unlikely this is a copyvio, for the following reasons:

1. In this version I do not find any sections, nor in the original version.
2. There are spelling mistakes and other typos that suggest it is not a copy-paste
3. The original article swaps between historic present and past tense in a way that is unlikely in a piece of published work
4. The original article does not flow, but reads more as a "dump" of salient information.
5. The editor has come back and made substantial additions to the article, showing knowledge of the subject supporting the hypothesis that they wrote the original text.
6. The original editor's user name is that of an author who has written extensively about the subject.

Rich Farmbrough, 12:34, 4 July 2011 (UTC).