| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| A sysop arrives |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 1#A sysop arrives
|
| AIDS in Africa |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 1#AIDS in Africa
|
| Paraphimosis |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 1#Paraphimosis
|
| Length of the article |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 1#Length of the article
|
| Disputed paragraphs and comments |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 1#Disputed paragraphs and comments
|
| Looks ok to me |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 1#Looks ok to me
|
| Historical information |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Historical information
|
| Links from introduction |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Links from introduction
|
| NPOV Concerns |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#NPOV Concerns
|
| Correcting Inaccuracies |
5 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Correcting Inaccuracies
|
| Bensley/Boyle survey |
17 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Bensley/Boyle survey
|
| Evidence of the sexual effects of circumcision |
12 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Evidence of the sexual effects of circumcision
|
| Unrelated to medical analysis |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Unrelated to medical analysis
|
| Loony Tunes Link |
9 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Loony Tunes Link
|
| Cervical Cancer Death Rates |
9 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Cervical Cancer Death Rates
|
| Limitations of the Laumann study |
7 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Limitations of the Laumann study
|
| Misleading Description of Edits |
6 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Misleading Description of Edits
|
| Sexual Effects |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 2#Sexual Effects
|
| Introduction dispute |
7 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 3#Introduction dispute
|
| Winkelmann and Taylor |
6 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 3#Winkelmann and Taylor
|
| Deleting relevant information |
5 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 3#Deleting relevant information
|
| Revert War - Request + Information |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 3#Revert War - Request + Information
|
| Protection |
6 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 3#Protection
|
| Proposal |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 3#Proposal
|
| Introduction |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 3#Introduction
|
| "anti-circumcision activist(s)" - POV |
17 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 3#"anti-circumcision activist(s)" - POV
|
| Libel |
15 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 4#Libel
|
| A sense of proportion |
6 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 4#A sense of proportion
|
| The Rural Uganda Study |
5 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 4#The Rural Uganda Study
|
| 'Doctor' Van Howe |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 4#'Doctor' Van Howe
|
| NPOV |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 4#NPOV
|
| HIV/AIDS |
11 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 4#HIV/AIDS
|
| Split |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 4#Split
|
| I think this or something like it belongs. |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 4#I think this or something like it belongs.
|
| FYI |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 4#FYI
|
| Continuous Reversions |
17 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#Continuous Reversions
|
| Disputed paragraph |
6 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#Disputed paragraph
|
| Sexual fetishism |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#Sexual fetishism
|
| Female Arousal |
7 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#Female Arousal
|
| "potential" |
6 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#"potential"
|
| STD Infection Rates in the USA |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#STD Infection Rates in the USA
|
| Protected |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#Protected
|
| Poll |
5 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#Poll
|
| Herpes risk of circumcision |
5 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#Herpes risk of circumcision
|
| An Opinion and Some Commentary |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#An Opinion and Some Commentary
|
| The the |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 5#The the
|
| Ad Hominem qualifications |
16 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Ad Hominem qualifications
|
| Is there any other surgery like circumcision? |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Is there any other surgery like circumcision?
|
| Circumcision is not a requirement for Christians |
6 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Circumcision is not a requirement for Christians
|
| Fallacious caveats |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Fallacious caveats
|
| Philosophical Point of View |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Philosophical Point of View
|
| Foreskin may be sexually responsive |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Foreskin may be sexually responsive
|
| Recent changes |
8 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Recent changes
|
| Suppression of information in the guise of removing propaganda |
7 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Suppression of information in the guise of removing propaganda
|
| Clarification of wording |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Clarification of wording
|
| Epididymitis |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Epididymitis
|
| Banned editors |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Banned editors
|
| We want balanced articles not this |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#We want balanced articles not this
|
| Breastfeeding and circumcision |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Breastfeeding and circumcision
|
| Penile cancer |
5 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Penile cancer
|
| Current studies on HIV/AIDs transmission in Sub Saharan Africa |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Current studies on HIV/AIDs transmission in Sub Saharan Africa
|
| Objectives |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Objectives
|
| Cleanup |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Cleanup
|
| Review of the Literature on Circumcision |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Review of the Literature on Circumcision
|
| Here's one way to end a meaningless debate |
6 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Here's one way to end a meaningless debate
|
| "Please discuss this on the talk page. Thanks." |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#"Please discuss this on the talk page. Thanks."
|
| Minority views should get less attention. Why is the minority view getting the most attention? |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#Minority views should get less attention. Why is the minority view getting the most attention?
|
| POV |
34 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#POV
|
| References |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 6#References
|
| Excessive reversions |
34 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Excessive reversions
|
| Suggest removal of '2.2.1 Images of Invasive Penile Cancer in Uncircumcised Men' |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Suggest removal of '2.2.1 Images of Invasive Penile Cancer in Uncircumcised Men'
|
| Balance |
14 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Balance
|
| Bratu et. al. study |
41 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Bratu et. al. study
|
| Excessive quote from ACS |
7 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Excessive quote from ACS
|
| Rfc against me |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Rfc against me
|
| Reverting |
30 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Reverting
|
| Original Research is seeing shells and guessing eggs, not in seeing and noting the shells. |
16 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Original Research is seeing shells and guessing eggs, not in seeing and noting the shells.
|
| Prostate Cancer |
21 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Prostate Cancer
|
| Nandesuka and DanBlackham |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Nandesuka and DanBlackham
|
| Circumcision to reduce HIV risk |
10 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Circumcision to reduce HIV risk
|
| User:84.69.230.138 |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#User:84.69.230.138
|
| Removal of MSSA discussion |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Removal of MSSA discussion
|
| The staph connection was peer-reviewed 40 years ago! |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#The staph connection was peer-reviewed 40 years ago!
|
| So please lets discuss. |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#So please lets discuss.
|
| HPV and cervical cancer |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#HPV and cervical cancer
|
| circumcision and BPH |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#circumcision and BPH
|
| Circumcision and HIV |
15 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Circumcision and HIV
|
| Update the article |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Update the article
|
| Moving content here? Summary style proposal for Circumcision article |
7 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Moving content here? Summary style proposal for Circumcision article
|
| New title |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#New title
|
| Policy section |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Policy section
|
| HIV section |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#HIV section
|
| Pratt-Thomas et al |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Pratt-Thomas et al
|
| References |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#References
|
| Van Howe |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Van Howe
|
| AMA definition of "non-therapeutic" |
5 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#AMA definition of "non-therapeutic"
|
| Archive? |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Archive?
|
| Nice job, boys. |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Nice job, boys.
|
| Appendectomy |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Appendectomy
|
| Refs for deaths |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Refs for deaths
|
| Position - Canada |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Position - Canada
|
| Stating date of policy statement |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 7#Stating date of policy statement
|
| Definition of "relative risk" |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Definition of "relative risk"
|
| Title of section after complications |
58 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Title of section after complications
|
| The case of the mysterious Arda study |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#The case of the mysterious Arda study
|
| Brennerman and Freud |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Brennerman and Freud
|
| Non-mention of prostate cancer |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Non-mention of prostate cancer
|
| Delete 'smegma and cancer' section |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Delete 'smegma and cancer' section
|
| Describing authors |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Describing authors
|
| Lead Policy Sum |
6 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Lead Policy Sum
|
| Organisation of penile cancer section |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Organisation of penile cancer section
|
| HIV section |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#HIV section
|
| FYI |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#FYI
|
| Marshall, CIRP, and misquoting |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Marshall, CIRP, and misquoting
|
| Prostate cancer section |
5 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Prostate cancer section
|
| Herpes and NPOV |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Herpes and NPOV
|
| Potential disadvantages |
7 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Potential disadvantages
|
| A separate "Circumcision and HIV" article |
9 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#A separate "Circumcision and HIV" article
|
| The Mucous membrane Issue & Circumcision |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#The Mucous membrane Issue & Circumcision
|
| Use of an ellipsis instead of "or benefits" in a BMA quote |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Use of an ellipsis instead of "or benefits" in a BMA quote
|
| overquote in the references? |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#overquote in the references?
|
| Meticillin succeptible or resistent |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Meticillin succeptible or resistent
|
| Miscellaneous comments |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Miscellaneous comments
|
| Restraints |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Restraints
|
| Numerous medical studies? |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Numerous medical studies?
|
| Major health benefits are unlikely from an evolutionary point of view. |
23 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Major health benefits are unlikely from an evolutionary point of view.
|
| Huge series of dubious changes |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 8#Huge series of dubious changes
|
| Help formating ! |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 9#Help formating !
|
| Is the Circumcision Procedure section necessary on this page? |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 9#Is the Circumcision Procedure section necessary on this page?
|
| Lead addition |
1 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision/Archive 9#Lead addition
|
| news article addition |
8 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision#news article addition
|
| American Academy of Paediatrics back circumcision |
2 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision#American Academy of Paediatrics back circumcision
|
| Anything old should be removed |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision#Anything old should be removed
|
| Why should this article exist? |
3 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision#Why should this article exist?
|
| Review of sources |
4 |
Talk:Medical analysis of circumcision#Review of sources
|
