| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| More general use |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#More general use
|
| ESA/NASA Joint Mission |
6 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#ESA/NASA Joint Mission
|
| Historical part |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Historical part
|
| More Information to add here |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#More Information to add here
|
| Outdated |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Outdated
|
| Help needed on current plans for Mars sample return missions |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Help needed on current plans for Mars sample return missions
|
| Suggestion for new "Concerns" section |
9 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Suggestion for new "Concerns" section
|
| Suggestion for a new article "Back contamination concerns for a Mars sample return" |
5 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Suggestion for a new article "Back contamination concerns for a Mars sample return"
|
| Back contamination concerns for a Mars sample return |
11 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Back contamination concerns for a Mars sample return
|
| Article provenance |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Article provenance
|
| Quotations in citations |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Quotations in citations
|
| Original Research |
5 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Original Research
|
| Legal requirement for public debate |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Legal requirement for public debate
|
| Section 3 redundant |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Section 3 redundant
|
| Major Surgery |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Major Surgery
|
| Risk Mitigation section |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Risk Mitigation section
|
| We don't need two articles on Mars Sample Return |
10 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#We don't need two articles on Mars Sample Return
|
| New draft |
5 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#New draft
|
| New draft is ready for discussion |
11 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#New draft is ready for discussion
|
| Deleted section on human quarantine |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Deleted section on human quarantine
|
| Changed title of Section 3 |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Changed title of Section 3
|
| Consolodation of 4 & 5 in the draft |
9 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Consolodation of 4 & 5 in the draft
|
| RE: Nomination for deletion |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#RE: Nomination for deletion
|
| Attempt at new clarity in the dispute |
11 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Attempt at new clarity in the dispute
|
| Added "No Action" section to Mitigation Strategies |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Added "No Action" section to Mitigation Strategies
|
| POV |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#POV
|
| The overall risk of an Andromeda Strain is "quite low" |
17 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#The overall risk of an Andromeda Strain is "quite low"
|
| More on POV |
9 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#More on POV
|
| Talk page section order |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Talk page section order
|
| Preamble needs to be completely reworked |
21 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Preamble needs to be completely reworked
|
| Example of global warming |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Example of global warming
|
| It is going to take a while, draft in progress |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#It is going to take a while, draft in progress
|
| Absence of evidence |
15 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Absence of evidence
|
| Too Early again - does this help? |
8 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Too Early again - does this help?
|
| Too Early - what am I doing wrong in your opinion? |
11 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Too Early - what am I doing wrong in your opinion?
|
| Another draft |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Another draft
|
| Are we at a complete impasse? |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Are we at a complete impasse?
|
| Dispute resolution process |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Dispute resolution process
|
| Request for assistance |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Request for assistance
|
| Some replies I missed before |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Some replies I missed before
|
| Absence of evidence (part 2) |
7 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Absence of evidence (part 2)
|
| Mars Community |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Mars Community
|
| Robert Zubrin against MSR |
7 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Robert Zubrin against MSR
|
| Latest |
14 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Latest
|
| Please, can we start the dispute resolution process? |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Please, can we start the dispute resolution process?
|
| Request for third party opinion |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Request for third party opinion
|
| nasaspaceflight.com thread announcing new Wiki article deleted |
5 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#nasaspaceflight.com thread announcing new Wiki article deleted
|
| More Title ideas |
9 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#More Title ideas
|
| On the third party opinion: |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#On the third party opinion:
|
| Root cause |
5 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Root cause
|
| Aims for the article |
9 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Aims for the article
|
| Add paragraph on existential risk of NOT doing MSR |
9 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 1#Add paragraph on existential risk of NOT doing MSR
|
| Biased POV sentence |
8 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Biased POV sentence
|
| I think I have gone too far the other way |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#I think I have gone too far the other way
|
| Scientists (and others) concerned about biohazard of any MSR to Earth with unknown samples even to biohazard facilities |
17 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Scientists (and others) concerned about biohazard of any MSR to Earth with unknown samples even to biohazard facilities
|
| List of those who advocate that the sample must not be returned to Earth at all until thoroughly studied first, on bio safety grounds |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#List of those who advocate that the sample must not be returned to Earth at all until thoroughly studied first, on bio safety grounds
|
| Each POV allowed its own voice |
8 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Each POV allowed its own voice
|
| Please list any things you find in my article that are POV or editorial or synthesis on my part |
30 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Please list any things you find in my article that are POV or editorial or synthesis on my part
|
| Tags to article |
7 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Tags to article
|
| NPOV/N Discussion |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#NPOV/N Discussion
|
| Prevailing View |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Prevailing View
|
| Warren's view, as shared with many space scientists in forum discussions |
12 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Warren's view, as shared with many space scientists in forum discussions
|
| Proposal to Merge with Main Article |
9 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Proposal to Merge with Main Article
|
| New title suggestion |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#New title suggestion
|
| Remove redundant and irrelevant content |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Remove redundant and irrelevant content
|
| Added POV template |
5 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Added POV template
|
| A proposal to merge article with main MSR page and delete this page |
20 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#A proposal to merge article with main MSR page and delete this page
|
| Merger Proposal from "Concerns for an early Mars sample return mission" |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Merger Proposal from "Concerns for an early Mars sample return mission"
|
| Nomination of Concerns for an early Mars sample return for deletion |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Nomination of Concerns for an early Mars sample return for deletion
|
| Revert Robert's reversion |
7 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Revert Robert's reversion
|
| Merger Revisited |
5 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Merger Revisited
|
| Re the cherry picking template on the article |
10 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Re the cherry picking template on the article
|
| Attribution |
17 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Attribution
|
| Reversion during AfD discussion |
38 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Reversion during AfD discussion
|
| Quarantine period extra possibility |
10 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Quarantine period extra possibility
|
| Section Issues with in situ study as a way to significantly reduce contamination risks |
21 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Section Issues with in situ study as a way to significantly reduce contamination risks
|
| Section: Robert Zubrin's view that back contamination risk has no scientific validity |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Section: Robert Zubrin's view that back contamination risk has no scientific validity
|
| New sections ESF update on biohazard risks of MSR, and on risk assessment probabilities |
14 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#New sections ESF update on biohazard risks of MSR, and on risk assessment probabilities
|
| Why is "Early" included in the article title??? |
19 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Why is "Early" included in the article title???
|
| What does kuru disease have to do with Mars Sample Return??? |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#What does kuru disease have to do with Mars Sample Return???
|
| Deletion of unsourced content |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Deletion of unsourced content
|
| Editing to remove the word Early etc |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Editing to remove the word Early etc
|
| Reversion completed |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 2#Reversion completed
|
| Zubrin quote taken out of context |
5 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Zubrin quote taken out of context
|
| Proposal to blanket change of "early" to "unsafe" throughout |
9 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Proposal to blanket change of "early" to "unsafe" throughout
|
| Section Risk assessment survey of microbiologists updated |
13 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Section Risk assessment survey of microbiologists updated
|
| Re Zubrins argument (OR) |
9 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Re Zubrins argument (OR)
|
| New approach to Early |
7 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#New approach to Early
|
| Update on the quote from the PPO that in situ research is not enough |
6 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Update on the quote from the PPO that in situ research is not enough
|
| Suggestion for reducing size of article |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Suggestion for reducing size of article
|
| Added separate risk mitigation sections |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Added separate risk mitigation sections
|
| New intro para may be a solution to the "Early" issue |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#New intro para may be a solution to the "Early" issue
|
| Article about concerns should be replaced by article about risk assessment and risk management |
13 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Article about concerns should be replaced by article about risk assessment and risk management
|
| Reorganizing the article |
7 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Reorganizing the article
|
| Re risk perception of MSR |
14 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Re risk perception of MSR
|
| Proposal to merge Robert's article into the ICAMSR article |
5 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Proposal to merge Robert's article into the ICAMSR article
|
| Measure of bias using word count |
8 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Measure of bias using word count
|
| Fixing citations and issues in tone, word flow and repetition |
8 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Fixing citations and issues in tone, word flow and repetition
|
| Fixed all the citations needed |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Fixed all the citations needed
|
| Best attempt at fixing the timing section |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Best attempt at fixing the timing section
|
| Have done some more rewriting of the main article, mainly the intro para. |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Have done some more rewriting of the main article, mainly the intro para.
|
| Started on citations and ref fixing |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Started on citations and ref fixing
|
| Okay I see the decision was delete and merge |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 3#Okay I see the decision was delete and merge
|
| AfD for Concerns for an early Mars sample return |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#AfD for Concerns for an early Mars sample return
|
| Bias of section on back contamination |
6 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Bias of section on back contamination
|
| Bias and errors in the back contamination section |
25 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Bias and errors in the back contamination section
|
| Question for Robert |
7 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Question for Robert
|
| Contribution to Back Contamination article |
3 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission/Archive 4#Contribution to Back Contamination article
|
| Offical POV on environmental disruption of the Earth by MSR now gone |
8 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Offical POV on environmental disruption of the Earth by MSR now gone
|
| Removal of templates |
25 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Removal of templates
|
| RFC on whether there is sufficient coverage of back-contamination |
52 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#RFC on whether there is sufficient coverage of back-contamination
|
| Bias and errors in the back contamination section |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Bias and errors in the back contamination section
|
| And now for more fun - ... arbitration request - withdrawn ? |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#And now for more fun - ... arbitration request - withdrawn ?
|
| Air filters |
4 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Air filters
|
| Legal process of approval of a MSR |
9 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Legal process of approval of a MSR
|
| FYI - 2018 |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#FYI - 2018
|
| Do we extend History with recent progress |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Do we extend History with recent progress
|
| Additional plans |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Additional plans
|
| Can we now archive the above discussion from 2013 ? |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Can we now archive the above discussion from 2013 ?
|
| What EXACTLY is an MSR? |
1 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#What EXACTLY is an MSR?
|
| Please don't remove footnotes in 2020 proposal |
13 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Please don't remove footnotes in 2020 proposal
|
| restructure nasa esa mars sample return mission |
5 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#restructure nasa esa mars sample return mission
|
| Modified {{excerpt}} to remove two images |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Modified {{excerpt}} to remove two images
|
| Collapsed table of sample details |
2 |
Talk:Mars sample-return mission#Collapsed table of sample details
|
