Jump to content

Talk:Lewis House

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

SIA

[edit]

This mass of redlinks makes it quite difficult for the reader to find an actual article ... it clearly needs to be broken into two, a set index article with all the lewis houses in, and a true dab page linking to blue links only. Abtract (talk) 22:30, 2 October 2008 (UTC)[reply]

There's an ongoing, central discussion of this at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Disambiguation‎#what is wp:NRHP doing wrong RE disambiguation?. I think it makes it faster, on average, for a reader to find an actual article, if the U.S. section is one list arranged clearly by state and city. I do think it would help if the order was clarified by a simple statement "(by state and city)" at the top of the U.S. section though. However, the SIA alternative and the "by state" note and other variations seem to be opposed by some in the central discussion (including me against the SIA option, because, among other reasons, i think it moves the article into AfD deletion debates and other problems). The article meets dab page MOS standards; it's not clear if it would survive a regular SIA article AfD. Note it is incoherent, it includes a company and a bunch of places that have Lewis House in their name. No one is interested in this as a set, per se. doncram (talk) 01:47, 3 October 2008 (UTC)[reply]