Talk:Let's Dance (David Bowie song)/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: K. Peake (talk · contribs) 08:00, 9 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Good Article review progress box

Criteria: 1a. prose () 1b. MoS () 2a. ref layout () 2b. cites WP:RS () 2c. no WP:OR () 2d. no WP:CV ()

3a. broadness () 3b. focus () 4. neutral () 5. stable () 6a. free or tagged images () 6b. pics relevant ()

Note: this represents where the article stands relative to the Good Article criteria. Criteria marked are unassessed

This should take around two days! --K. Peake 08:00, 9 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Infobox and lead

WP:OVERLINK of David Bowie in the infobox under songwriter(s)

Done

"originally released as" → "originally included as" and move the lead single part to the sentence after the folk origins one

If you mean before Vaughan's sentence that makes zero sense to me. Instead made it "Released as the album's as the lead single in full-length and edited formats" – zmbro _{(talk) (cont)} 15:23, 11 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Remove "the band" before Chic since this is not notable for the lead
"to a dance-number" → "to a dance number"
Why is rock not listed under the embraced genres?
Wikilink bassline

Above four done

"while the rising vocal intros were" → "while the rising vocal intro was"

There's more than one in the song – zmbro _{(talk) (cont)} 15:23, 11 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

"under a "serious moonlight" and" → "under the moonlight and" because quotations like these are not suitable for the lead

Done

The commercial performance sentence should be the one after the above one
"from the lyric to" → "from a line to", as the lyric in question has no context in the lead
Mention performances that were included in the 1980s and 2000s
"video games, and television commercials." → "video games and television commercials."

Above three done

Background and development

Img looks good; really interesting choice of text!!
Introduce Chic as an American band, as the main character of this article is infact British
"musical interests,[3] eventually asking him" → "musical interests;[3] he eventually asked him"
For the quote of the artist informing Bowie, either place the punctuation inside the quotes if it is a full sentence or remove the comma before if not
"the two men regrouped" wouldn't "the duo" work better or Bowie and Rodgers, then write his home later on in the sentence?
"Dismissing it as" → "Dismissing the number as"
[9] does not mention the quote used in prose; either add one from the source or remove it from this sentence

All done

Demo

Wikilink bassline
Pipe digitally to Music download

both done

Recording

"for the upcoming album." → "for the album."
"completed in just 17 days.[4] [8][9]" → ""completed in only 17 days.[4][8][9]""
"were going to play."" → "were going to play"." per MOS:QUOTE
Wikilink rhythm guitar
"vocalist David Spinner, and saxophonists" → "vocalist David Spinner and saxophonists"
Img looks good!
"other thing going on"." → "other thing going on."" since this is a full quote
"an old Fender amplifier, author Paul Trynka commenting" → "a former Fender amplifier; author Paul Trynka commented on" and if the amplifier is not a disused one, used something else other than former in place of old to be less repetitive

All done

Composition

First para looks good!

Music

The homage quote needs to be ended
"as the reason for the song's" → "as the reason for its"
"displaying likes of" → "displaying the likes of"
The Best Classic Bands ref should only be after dance-rock in the genres sentence since you shouldn't invoke it more than once here
"the scale – "if you should fall... into my arms", before" → "the scale – "if you should fall... into my arms" – before"
"boasts two interspersing hooks: "a" → "boasts the two interspersing hooks of "a"
Add the year of the Peter Gunn soundtrack

All done

Lyrics

Quote box looks good!
"all the time."" → "all the time"." per MOS:QUOTE

Done

Music video

Img looks good!
Remove overly obvious wikilink on Sydney, as it is a universally recognized city
"and an extra mime to" → "and an extra guest to"
"The video's only lyrical reference" → "The music video's only lyrical reference"
"says that their wearing by a female factory boss" → "says that a female factory boss wearing the outfit"
"puts them on, and sees a" → "putting them on and seeing a"
"ultimate cultural colonist."" → "ultimate cultural colonist"." per MOS:QUOTE
"generally – and the "Let's Dance" video in particular – as" → "generally, particularly the "Let's Dance" video, as"
Last para looks good!

All done

Release

Pipe vinyl to Phonograph record
"running 4:07 while the latter" → "running 4:07, while the latter"
The AllMusic source does not provide the release date
"it would be his" → "the song would become his"
Are the dashes really needed for number one and two?
"in the late-1970s,[7] and changed" → "in the late-1970s and changed" moving [7] solely to the end of the sentence

All done

Reception

"received positive reviews" → "was met with positive reviews"
"anyway – completely familiar."" → "anyway – completely familiar"." per MOS:QUOTE
"said that "[Nile] Rodgers' predictable" → "said, "[Nile] Rodgers' predictable" and add something like a writer of or the staff of before Billboard
"in its end-of-the-year list." → "in its list of the best tracks of 1983."

All done

Live performances

Wikilink Serious Moonlight Tour on the img text
Remove overly obvious wikilink on Melbourne since that is a capital city
"he even dismissed it as" → "he even dismissed the song as"
"acoustic style" Pegg compares" → "acoustic style" that Pegg compares"
The date of 25 June is not sourced
"made return appearances on" → "made further appearances on"

All done

Legacy

First para looks good!

Retrospective appraisal

[2][57][19][46][58] shouldn't these be in numerical order?
Add something like the staff or a writer of for Classic Pop
"wrote, "[the song] is one of" → "wrote that "[the song] is one of"
"modern era", and further praises" → "modern era" and further praises"
Pipe Consequence of Sound to Consequence (publication)
Last para looks good!

All done

Cover versions and tributes

Pipe interpolated to Interpolation (popular music)
"reworked by EMI, with Bowie's" → "reworked by EMI with Bowie's"
"backing vocals, and was accompanied" → "backing vocals and was accompanied"
Remove wikilink on Singapore, as it is a country
Img looks good!
"given away with Q magazine" sounds unspecific; be clearer about what you mean, as in was it packaged with magazine copies?

All done; last point clarified

Appearances in media

Remove "in the film" after Bowie's cameo because this is implied
"arbiter of cool."" → "arbiter of cool"." per MOS:QUOTE

Both done

Personnel

Good

Charts

Weekly charts

Pipe Los 40 Principales to Los 40

Done

Swap Digital Song Sales with Hot Rock & Alternative Songs

Kyle Peake Unsure how to do that – zmbro _{(talk) (cont)} 15:23, 11 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Year-end charts

Many of the charts are overlinked from weekly ones here
Shouldn't Cash Box be something like Top 100?

Done

All-time charts

Good

Certifications and sales

Sales certifications for "Let's Dance" → Sales and certifications for "Let's Dance"

Done

Notes

Good

References

Copyvio score looks satisfactory at 35.9%!!
Cite Yahoo! as publisher instead on ref 3

Done

What exactly makes ThinWhiteDuke.net a reliable source on ref 12?

replaced with Radio X – zmbro _{(talk) (cont)} 15:52, 11 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Fix MOS:QWQ issues with ref 21
Wikilink Irish Examiner on ref 24
Pipe Bloomsbury Academic to Bloomsbury Publishing on ref 27
Cite BBC News Online as publisher instead on ref 28
Pipe Official Charts Company to Official Charts on ref 35
Pipe Billboard to Billboard (magazine) on ref 39

Above six done

Why does ref 47 cite the entirety of Pegg 2016?

Fixed

Cite lescharts.com as publisher instead on ref 48
Wikilink PopMatters on ref 54 instead of ref 58
Cite BBC as publisher instead on ref 59
Wikilink Ultimate Classic Rock on ref 66 per MOS:LINK2SECT
Cash Box magazine → Cash Box and remove excess full-stop on the access-date for ref 76
For refs 78 and 125, either cite InfoDisc as publisher as work/website for consistency

Above six done

Remove or replace refs 81, 117 and 118 per WP:SELFPUB

Done – zmbro _{(talk) (cont)} 15:52, 11 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Pipe LP3 to Lista Przebojów Programu Trzeciego on ref 86
Cite Los 40 Principales as publisher instead and pipe to Los 40 on ref 88
Cite portuguesecharts.com as publisher instead on ref 101
Australian-charts.com → australian-charts.com and cite as publisher instead on ref 107
Cite Ö3 Austria Top 40 as publisher instead on ref 108
Cite Ultratop 50 as publisher instead on ref 109
Cite top-france.fr as publisher instead on ref 111
Cite GfK Entertainment Charts as publisher instead on ref 112
Cite Dutch Top 40 as publisher instead on ref 113
Cite Single Top 100 as publisher instead on ref 114
Cite Recorded Music NZ as publisher instead on ref 115
Cite Swiss Singles Chart as publisher instead on ref 116
Fix MOS:CAPS issues and WP:OVERLINK of Cash Box on ref 119
Cite Billboard as work/website instead on ref 126

above 14 done; I didn't really pay too much attention to these tbh – zmbro _{(talk) (cont)} 15:46, 11 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Sources

Wikilink Virgin Books
Wikilink Rowman & Littlefield
Pipe Guinness World Records Limited to Guinness World Records

All done

Final comments and verdict

On hold until all of the issues are fixed; that fit well into my timeframe! --K. Peake 09:03, 10 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Zmbro It is good that you have got back to me, however I meant with weekly charts to swap those two for the correct order. --K. Peake 11:01, 12 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]
Like that? – zmbro _{(talk) (cont)} 16:45, 12 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Zmbro No, I meant that Digital Song Sales should be listed first for alphabetical order. --K. Peake 10:32, 13 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]
Kyle Peake That's awkward. Fixed – zmbro _{(talk) (cont)} 13:09, 13 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

✓ Pass now, nice work and I hope you are successful if deciding to take this to FA! --K. Peake 09:06, 14 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Comment

Hi Zmbro and Kyle, great job! Quick question and a comment if I may ... Can you please check the change in Music video section (15:09, 11 Feb) from:

"while Bowie and an extra mime to the song" to

"while Bowie and an extra guest to the song"?

Did you mean to remove "mime"? Are they miming or playing? I can't tell from the source (and know very little about how music videos are made). Rolling Stone (Ref 42) says "Bowie, ... takes his place against the front wall, next to an extra who's thumping away on a stand-up bass." But it also calls the extra a "prop bassist" so he wasn't a musician? An alternative could be to use "play" the song or perform? Also guest/s is now used three times, so pub regulars or locals or even drinkers or customers might be a substitute? (Sorry to butt in but this is one of my all-time very favourite videos and this'll come up at FAC?) JennyOz (talk) 05:25, 13 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

I have checked and it should still include mime, plus I fixed overusage of guest. --K. Peake 10:32, 13 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]

Im not sure if I'll take it to FAC. I'm sure the prose is not up to standard, and given the song's popularity amongst fans and its swath of popular culture appearances, it'd be tough. Then again, "Paint It Black" was successful...so you never know. – zmbro _{(talk) (cont)} 15:55, 13 February 2023 (UTC)[reply]