Jump to content

Talk:Korczak (film)

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Confusing Reception section

[edit]

At the moment, the Reception section reads:

"Among the strongest defendants of the epic was Marek Edelman, the Polish Jew who survived the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. Wajda saw the idea of showing the children being led into the Treblinka gas chambers as unnecessary addition of tearjerking moments."

What does Edelman have to do with that following sentence about Treblinka? What does Wajda's feeling about that depiction have to do with Edelman? The construction implies something like Edelman encouraging or desiring this depiction, but Wajda disagreeing. But where did talk of this depiction even come from? Was it in the movie? Not in the movie? Did Edelman defend it because it was present? Did Wajda change his mind and include the scene? Remove it? Does it actually have anything at all to do with Edelman, or are there just two completely unrelated sentences set next to each other and unnecessarily creating confusion? FangsFirst (talk) 04:43, 11 December 2022 (UTC)[reply]

!!

[edit]

Pretty sparse article! Was hoping for a little more. Anyone care to oblige? ThePeg (talk) 16:23, 3 July 2008 (UTC)[reply]