Talk:Kirloskarwadi

Comment posted on Sept 25, 2005. 1.34 pm EST: Many people have been editing this page and the Wikipedia editors have marked this page for cleanup several times. This page was created by me (Sameer) and I plan to develop it on the guidelines of other similar pages related to a particular place. The layout I want to follow most closely is that of Lowell, Massachusetts page in Wikipedia. Anyone editing this page... please first visit the Lowell, Massachusetts page and then make changes accordingly.

There's probably no real objection to following that layout, but no editor vcan make that decision for others; if other editors prefer a different layout, they're free to try it (and if there's a difference of opinion, it can be sorted out in discussion here.

I'm not sure why the cleanup tag was removed, as the article still badly needs it. It's still too much of a publicity piece for a company rather than an article on a town; the English also needs overhauling. --Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 21:52, 25 September 2005 (UTC)

I agree that no editor can make a decision about the format. But I do urge people to have a look at pages describing other towns and try to develop a format which is on those lines. I won't be removing the cleanup tag till the editors are satisfied. As far as the contents go, some information about the company is unavoidable since the town exists because of the company. I am not trying to make a publicity piece here but the history of the town requires the mention of the company. I will make an attempt not to put overtly "publicity" kind of info about the company and also try to avoid links about the company. -- Transmogrifier 17:35, 18 October 2005 (UTC)