Talk:Killeigh parish

Scope

What is this article "for"? If the scope is:

"Geographical" (as implied by its original infobox/categorisation/etc) then why wouldn't the related text/topics be covered in the Killeigh or Geashill or other existing (and actually geographical) articles. That are better suited for geographic text (about mountains and villages and whatever)
"Ecclesiastical" (as implied by the [confusing] "directory of priests") why wouldn't that be covered within the existing Roman Catholic Diocese of Kildare and Leighlin article?
"Architectural" (as implied by the list of church buildings) why wouldn't that also be covered in the articles on the villages where those churches are located. Or, if the individual buildings meet WP:NBUILDING, a standalone article. As would typically be the case.
"Sporting" (as per the list of 3x GAA clubs) why would that subject be covered in an article about an ecclesiastical parish? Yes, some GAA clubs/catchments traditionally follow similar boundaries to that of the local Catholic parish, but GAA clubs themselves are not a "sub-set" of a Catholic parish?

Other than acting as a WP:NOTMIRROR of the parish website and repeating content (a WP:CFORK) already in other existing articles, what is this title "for"? I'm especially confused as to how the titular subject (the ecclesiastical parish) has notability independent of geographic area in which it sits. What am I missing? How is the ecclesiastical parish independently notable? And where is the significant and independent coverage which establishes that notability? Guliolopez (talk) 01:12, 11 November 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Note. Unless there's an indication of independent notability (supported by significant coverage in independent sources), I'm inclined to redirect this title to Killeigh#Religion. Where any small amount of text about the Catholic parish (that doesn't redundantly replicate stuff already covered there or elsewhere) can easily be covered. Otherwise, as above, I'm having a hard time understanding how a separate/standalone title is justified. Or what it could cover - that isn't already/appropriately covered elsewhere.... Guliolopez (talk) 02:22, 11 November 2024 (UTC)[reply]